See all
374 photos

Seamore's

(Now Closed)

Seafood Restaurant$$$$

NoLita, New York

Save

Seamore's

The experts at Eater and Gothamist recommend this place

180 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Nick AndlingerSeptember 2, 2015
Fantastic. Tuna poke, spicy squid tacos (actually spicy and perfect), and fish of the day were all on point. Surprised at how good it was. Loved the cucumber mint and gin cocktail.
Noah WeissAugust 29, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Great value, tasty seafood from the Meatball Shop team -- just stay to the right column to get the seared fish tacos, blackened fish sandwich, etc. The tuna poke to start, too.
Sam BrownMarch 11, 2016
Been here 10+ times
The Reel Deal is no joke, choose a white flaky fish from the daily landings blackboard, pair it with the red curry sauce, and a junior IPA! 👌🏻
ZenFoodsterSeptember 27, 2017
Get "Reel Deal" w/ choice of local, catch of the day + 1 sauce & seasonal grains, greens & veg. Love their 100% sustainable fish, Red Curry sauce, Fish tacos, Blackened Fish Sammie & Guava ice cream!
Jess NaldoJuly 9, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Fish tacos and the shishito peppers are some of the best I've ever had. Service treats you like fam and that includes Michael Chernow himself. Love their food values & there's no doubt I'll be back!
Melissa D.July 29, 2015
Poke was full of flavor. The fried fish tacos light and crispy. They also a crisp and refreshing light mediterranean rose. A perfect summer lunch.
ZenFoodsterSeptember 27, 2017
Wish Seamore's tasty 100% sustainable seafood & fresh grains, greens & veggie menu options would make their way to the UES!
EaterAugust 29, 2017
Michael Chernow’s Nolita restaurant doubles its summertime vibes in the warmer months, when it unveils a colorful patio with striped beach umbrellas. Read more
ZenFoodsterSeptember 27, 2017
Fish & Chips was another good menu option. Fish was fresh, buttery & flaky but a lighter batter (like Panko) would've made brought out the flavor of the fish & made it the star!
GothamistJuly 6, 2015
The focus is on "under-utilized local species" like porgy, monkfish and flounder, with a "Daily Landings" board heralding the catch of the day. Try the Reel Deal: choice of fish, sauce, and side. Read more
Anuj MathurApril 20, 2016
Been here 5+ times
a good selection of local brews on draft (and non-local cans) to enjoy while you watch passerby. easiest to grab a table outside if it's a party of two.
AnthonyMarch 25, 2016
Fresh and delicious, light but filling. If you need an introduction to seafood, this is it. The poké is a necessary appetizer. Try the crispy or braised fish taco. Sandwiches are a must if ur hungry!
Sasha JonesAugust 4, 2017
Their Bloody Mary is to die for! The avocado toast was delicious too and the sweet potatoes on the side were even better! I highly recommend this place for brunch and want to try it for dinner!
Bin YangJune 29, 2015
If you care about good food, sustainability of seafood, and the livelihood of American fishermen, this is it. Get the reel deal, share some tacos and ask how they caught the fish!
Shane Williams-NessMarch 31, 2017
Loved it!! Staff was friendly and efficient. Oysters were delish and the atmosphere super fun. Only had drinks and apps at the bar but will definitely go back for full evening of food and experience.
Emily WilsonMay 27, 2016
Definitely start with the poke. The grilled fish tacos are yummy, but hard to eat. Ask for hot sauce!
Matthew HuieNovember 25, 2016
You can't go wrong with the Reel Deal and poke! More importantly, their choice of hip-hop music is 👌.
Ariana VoyerAugust 29, 2016
Great poke bowl and fish tacos - cute atmosphere, outdoor seating, but also on the Caviar delivery app!
Alexa IliouFebruary 17, 2017
They make really tasty and unique cocktails. They also have very fresh fish. I shared tacos with friends. They were all great and had interesting flavors.
Celena ChanJuly 13, 2015
Cool new concept-- had the poke, reel deal w miso butter sauce, mussels, sweet potato fries and soft serve. Everything was a bit oversalted. Chill, trendy vibe.
Maria RiabtchenkoOctober 15, 2016
Currently obsessed with this place, everything and anything is great. Go for the reel deal, the seared fish tacos sometimes go light on the amount of fish 🎣
Paige CSeptember 2, 2019
Amazing brunch. I had the tuna steak and really enjoyed it. Fries were also perfectly cooked. Totally dog friendly patio.
Steph CrudeleJune 4, 2016
Ceviche was the best Ive ever had and the kale with mackerel was perfect to share for lunch. Great outdoor seating and beautiful inside the restaurant. Can't wait to come back!
Talia FisherSeptember 26, 2018
The miso brown butter sauce is soo good! Must come back for dollar oyster happy hour and the watermelon bellinis they serve at brunch.
Indulgent EatsJune 13, 2016
Excellent fish tacos and dinner plates, as well as other seafood items from Chef Michael Chernow of Meatball Shop fame. Grab a table on their sidewalk patio and end the meal with Oddfellows soft serve
IrmaZandl ZandlSlantJuly 29, 2015
Been here 5+ times
GORGEOUS space and good food. Monkfish is delish. A little pricey (almost $40 w/tip for lunch with no alcohol). staff is nice but everything seems a bit disorganized.
Jolie BennaimJuly 28, 2015
The Poke is quite possibly one of the best things I've eaten in a while. Refreshing, crunchy, precisely salty and a tiny bit spicy. Yes it's an appetizer but it's also a perfect stand alone meal.
TeresaJuly 8, 2015
It was extremely busy tonight and we ended up waiting about 1.5 hours for 2 people. Our waitress was amazing though. Poke and the blackfish were both delicious.
Ngan NguyenOctober 5, 2016
Crispy Fish Tacos were beautiful. Sweet potato fries were excellent. Fantastic menu with plenty to choose from. Definitely going back.
Isa LaraSeptember 7, 2018
Amazingly delicious heirloom tomatoes watermelon + shrimp salad. The jalapeños & watermelon create a delightful cool spice!
Ms HeleneJune 5, 2016
Poke to share $16, beets, mushroom & kale burger charred perfectly with greens $17. Outdoor seating on cnr of Nolita
jake furstJuly 23, 2015
kick-ass seafood served in very interesting preparations. mostly "fishermen's fish" that get a bad wrap but are delicious if prepared right, which they most definitely are (eg Bluefish).
Jon ChanOctober 25, 2017
Been here 5+ times
I always like to start with the poke and have the crispy squid tacos as an entree. Come early to avoid the crowds. Especially good for lunch.
AlexMarch 8, 2016
great service and lively space. fish cake bennie and the skate sandwich are yummy. poke is fresh, not the best.
Katie VanLangenAugust 26, 2016
The Poke bowl and Coconut Lemongrass soft serve were incredible. I could come back and eat them everyday. Try the agua fresca with gin.
Emily KaneFebruary 1, 2018
The lobster alfredo is a bit pricey, but I’m sure you’ve done something recently in your life that warrants treating yourself to it.
Caro SchieferNovember 11, 2017
Great and fresh food. Very good service. Try the Poke. It's without rice, but tastes delicious!!
Noah WeissMay 31, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Very tasty albeit expensive seared fish tacos and "surf & turf" tacos with steak and shrimp.
Nicole FormicaSeptember 15, 2015
The "reel deal" is the way to go. Choose a fish, choose a sauce. Served on top of the sides of the day.
Omer ZachNovember 6, 2015
For $22, the Reel Deal gets you a pice of freshly caught local fish, your choice of sauce, and all 3 daily sides.
Yoni ZloczewskiNovember 8, 2015
Tasty, straight forward flavors and a cool vibe. The real deal is the move to get bang for your buck. Chernow has another hit.
Jess NaldoJuly 9, 2015
Been here 5+ times
CAN'T FORGET THE KAFFIR LIME ICE CREAM. YOU CAN'T. THAT'S DARK MAGIC RIGHT THERE. Ps. It's vegan. Whaaaaaaaaat?
GothamistMarch 3, 2016
Next Monday is the start of "Montauk Mondays" at Seamore's which means featuring incredible dishes like skate, monkfish, porgy, and flounder for an irresistible meal. Read more
Cole KennedyAugust 26, 2015
Take a trip to Southern California right in Nolita. The seared seasonal fish tacos are killer, and you better start your meal with crispy shrimp.
Jordan MSeptember 16, 2015
Maybe the only place to get poke in NYC - don't miss it. Also the crispy fish tacos.
Mike O'SullivanAugust 16, 2015
One of my new fav seafood spots. I had the fish of the day sandwich and loved it. Avocado lovers won't be disappointed.
Honghui YuNovember 14, 2017
A super cute seafood restaurant opened up by one of the co-founders of The Meatball Shop. Too bad their food isn't as good as their fish logo
Alex HennesseyAugust 23, 2015
Beachy, montauk atmosphere. Unique, underutilized fish are the focus here. Bluefish, wreckfish, porgy, etc etc. Try the blackened fish sandwich for sure
mafetowersMarch 1, 2020
The shrimp tacos are the best. In general shrimp are rally good. The other plates I tried (beef and fish tacos) didn't like.
Judy CariDecember 14, 2018
We had the crispy squid, lobster Mac & cheese (sm) fish tacos and the reel deal plate. Fantastic. The Mac & cheese is really dense!!

1 2 3 4

374 Photos

Seamore's

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Seamore's

Appears on 1,152 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.