Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.Sea Witch
Bar$$$$
Greenwood Heights, Brooklyn
The experts at Eater and The New Yorker recommend this place
"PLEASE get the clam roll...its amazering!"(6 Tips)
"Love the backyard, the tropical fish tank, the beer selection."(10 Tips)
"... ambience with 25 ft. tropical fish tank, and outdoor garden and sensational clam..."(2 Tips)
"The blue point club is amazing."(3 Tips)
103 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- seafood
- outdoor seating
- tropical fish tank
- casual
- gardens
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Turnstile ToursMarch 17, 2014See if you can spot historical images from the Brooklyn Navy Yard. Our favorite is of the USS Vermont, the Yard's receiving ship after the Civil War. It looks like a giant floating apartment building.
It's fun to go for brunch when they just open. It's pretty quiet then. The eggs and egg sandwich are great for brunch. The burger is good and the shishito peppers are a great side to any meal.
Kazem EdmondJanuary 6, 2017This place is so unique and outstanding that I don't know what to say. Imagine a haunted version of The Little Mermaid, with matching soundtrack, and...A tiki bar. Outstanding.
Larissa AlvarezOctober 6, 2018Cool atmosphere and decor. Cocktails are delicious. Good beer selection. Awesome rock playlist. We liked the food. The fries were the best.
Abby Weichert MadiganAugust 10, 2013Pork schnitzel sandwitch was so yummy!! The backyard was spacious and relaxing and the bartenders were super nice! Can't say enough about the first visit. We will be back!!!
Stephanie P.September 28, 2013I love, love, LOVE the ocean/mermaid/nautical theme of this bar! Their fish tank is pretty amazing and their beer selection is pretty ace. Interesting food menu too! :D
OctaneNovember 6, 2014Completely in love with this place! Cute little backyard patio, Oyster Club is BANGING, Kyle the Bartender is incapable of making anything less than breathtaking.
LukeJune 18, 2016Ponds and streams and fish and also a good beer selection and one of the low key best pork schnitzel sandwiches in New York- The bar of my dreams. Sea witch ambience with 25 ft. tropical fish tank, and outdoor garden and sensational clam rolls and fried oysters.
Danielle DavisSeptember 1, 2014Incredible burger, friendliest chefs and a gorgeous outside space to enjoy it all 😊
GothamistJune 6, 2012This place offers up a sea-themed vibe, and we hear a garden is coming soon. When asked, our photographer simply told us: CLAM ROLL. So, get the clam roll. Pro tip: If you want a fork, bring your own.
love this place... except couple of bartenders. Whatever planet they live on, they need to come back to Earth. Just say something like thank you or how what would you like to drink.
Sunny Saturdays are the perfect time to sit in the back and enjoy a Bloody Mary, plus Becca's an awesome bartender. Not only does she make good drinks, she's cute too!
Christoffer JakobsenApril 23, 2016A maritime themed bar with a great selection of American craft beer on tap, including 3 nitro taps. Large backyard.
The cheeseburger patty is phenomenal. Its on the smaller side but considering the light price, its still a great deal.
Lynn HarrisDecember 16, 2011Loved this place. Great Manhattan. Nice bartender. Totally cool without TRYING to be. And a FISH TANK!
Jen M.September 22, 2013On a nice late summer evening.. sit outside with some pumpkin ale.. order the shishito peppers (SOOOO GOOD) and the Burger.. it won't dissapoint
Matthew ManningJuly 15, 2016The portions are a little small for the price but the quality is unbelievably good. The back patio area is pretty awesome too
Gorgeous zen-like backyard complete with live turtles and fish. Grab a craft beer, friends, and relax!- Porter MasonSeptember 15, 2014The blue point club is amazing. I will return. And I will have the blue point club. As god as my witness.
- Love the backyard, the tropical fish tank, the beer selection. Good food too
Sally RichardsonApril 1, 2016Lovely sun trap in the garden and plugs sockets by all the booths (if you're low on juice)- Nate FolkertJanuary 5, 2014Clausthaler bottles. Mine came with the label pre-peeled, though not sure if that's a coincidence or if that's a thing. #nonalcoholic
Grab a friend or three and sit in the back to talk over drinks by gas lantern one evening.
Harry AdamsSeptember 16, 2014Bartenders here are real pricks, especially the guy that sounds like tweety bird. If you own this place, please fire everyone.
I've never had a sober bartender here... for better or worse, but the backyard is great for a peaceful drink.
Lyndsey MatthewsMarch 15, 2015Great neighborhood spot, with amazing backyard, friendly cooks, good beer selection.
Anthony DJuly 9, 2016Didn't know the food was separated from the bar but you can bring it in. Nice outdoor patio as well.
Michael KinneyJune 22, 2012Great place, except for the red-bearded jerk behind the bar who basically told us to quiet down because we were "the loudest ones in the bar". DUDE IT'S A BAR, NOT A LIBRARY. We immediately left.
Ken PrydeAugust 29, 2014Check out the food, pretty much everything is amazing, especially when you have the drunk munchies.
Once they figure out how to fix the lighting situation outside (bright emergency lights for now?) this will be my favorite place to get a beer.
Ask Kyle to make you something off the top of the dome.
Nice decor, with a friendly staff. Try a nice craft beer here in this low-key South Slope watering hole.
Jennifer CoiaMarch 11, 2013Monday night happy hour 2 for 1 with a great fish taco = a filling delicious dinner for $ 11 :)
Adam PodolnickJanuary 28, 2013The kitchen is open pretty late and they make a great cheeseburger and fries.
Alexandra JenkinsJune 17, 2015Kinda crappy. The prices seem low, but it's all low quality (except the fish tacos, those were pretty good). They also kicked us out of the backyard before 11 PM. Not one of my faves,
256 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until Noon (Show more)
- Mon–Wed
- 5:00 PM–4:00 AM
- Thu
- 4:00 PM–4:00 AM
- Fri
- 3:00 PM–4:00 AM
- Sat–Sun
- Noon–4:00 AM
(347) 227-7166
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"always characters here and it feels homey and inviting. rotating, inventive drinks and always solid beers on tap. plus pinball!"
Ro - 8.1
"Cute place, big hall, great for group gathering and get your drink on!"
Angel S - 9.1
"Always a new beer to try here. Best selection in Park Slope and up there in all of NYC. Love that it's dog friendly too."
Adam Chlan
Places people like to go after Sea Witch
- 7.8
"Dive of dive bars. Love this place $3 PBR cans and a solid food menu that I'm looking forward to trying."
Melissa Yu - 9.1
"One of the most amazing cemeteries. Fantastic history and amazing Victorian stone architecture in the mausoleums. Great place to walk around on a crisp fall day."
eric bornemann - 8.4
"Kid friendly! Amazing white sangria!"
Dan Makarov
Appears on 482 lists
Created by rahul d
85 items • 133 followers
Created by D
178 items • 155 followers
NY Best Burgers (Readers Choice + Critic Picks)
Created by Time Out New York
17 items • 773 followers
