See all
61 photos

Sfoglia

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Carnegie Hill, New York

Save

Sfoglia

8.2^/10

152

ratings

Ranked #3 for pappardelle in New York
Has a stamp of approval from Village Voice and New York Habitat
"Sit at the bar, and order the pappardelle and seasonal dessert tart."(9 Tips)
"Sfoglia’s chicken al mattone and Bread Pudding!!!"(3 Tips)
"Holy god the bolognese is killer (in the best way possible)"(8 Tips)
"Cute, intimate, and tasty Italian fare in the UES."(3 Tips)

53 Tips and reviews

Filter:

bread pudding
desserts
chicken
tarts
pork shoulder
cute
great value
bread
good for special occasions
dinner
staff
antipasto
well
cauliflower
pricey
crowded
takes reservations
exotic
tangerine
Tuscany
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Joanne PangJanuary 20, 2015
Date spot alert! The crispy chicken flakes right off the bone; the pappardelle was substantial but on the heavier side. I'd go back -- and that trip will include the bread pudding!
Beka COctober 24, 2015
One of the best Italian restaurants in the city, let alone uptown. Best way I can describe it "exotic Italian"...with great specials and well curated wine selection. It's a hidden gem true NYers
JosetteJune 11, 2015
Great atmosphere, reminds me of the small, lovely restaurants of Tuscany. The best Italian bread in NYC, hot from their oven. Wish pasta was not over cooked!
Ben WatersJanuary 16, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Sit at the bar, and order the pappardelle and seasonal dessert tart. You can't go wrong with any of the cocktails (especially the tangerine cello). The roast chicken is a staple and always delicious.
Warrent SattJanuary 13, 2014
Widely praised for “authentic” Italian cooking, “knowledgeable” servers and “romantic” “farmhouse” digs, “the real deal”; though “pricey”, most agree it’s “worth the money”
Roger SchonfeldDecember 21, 2014
They did something wonderful with the cauliflower that was part of the antipasti last night. Pastas were worth traveling for. Bread pudding and diff tart worth an airplane ride.
Gloria DumasSeptember 23, 2016
Everyone says sit at the bar and have the bolognese. It's true. To die for. The house made bread is a homey indulgence. Could've passed on the semi freddo
Village VoiceJune 3, 2013
This spot gets a lot of recognition on the UES, and for good reason. Their chicken al mattone is so delicious, crispy, and moist it will take the edge off how long it took you to score a reservation.
Village VoiceJanuary 18, 2013
The lovely intimate atmosphere (they work with a 10 person dining area) make it advisable to call ahead for a reservation. Worth every minute!
Roger SchonfeldDecember 21, 2014
Lovely smart knowledgeable un-fussy service. Pricy wine list with a few Kress expensive "funky" options well worth trying.
Elizabeth ClosmoreMarch 28, 2013
Make a res! Order the Antipasti - I hate Brussels sprouts and they were incredible along with some incredible mushrooms. Also a winning cheese plate.
Caroline SchulweisJune 23, 2014
The bolognese pasta and chicken entree were delicious. Our entire table loved the cauliflower side as well.
New York HabitatMay 15, 2012
This rustic Italian restaurant is perfect for an intimate evening. Ask the staff for wine suggestions to accompany your meal.
connieMarch 25, 2014
Come for lunch, no reseys needed. Share the chicken and save room for the panna cotta.
NYMagNovember 16, 2011
Actress and Blue Tree-owner Phoebe Cates calls this UES Italian spot her "home away from home" in this weeks NY Diet. Try the chicken al mattone! Read more
EatMeDrinkMeNYCOctober 28, 2010
The chicken. You have to get the chicken. So moist! The secret is the brick oven. They are so confident you'll love it that no sides accompany it.
Avril ShowerMarch 25, 2012
The 3 best dishes: pappardelle alla Bolognese, Sfoglia’s chicken al mattone and Bread Pudding!!!
Christopher PepeMarch 8, 2013
The gnocchi with pork shoulder is amomg the best pasta dishes I've ever tasted.
USA TODAYNovember 22, 2010
Save room for the bread pudding—it’s difficult, but worth it. The dish needs to be ordered when you arrive and is meant to be shared. Read more
Joshua MillerJuly 1, 2012
Go for the blueberry cobbler if they have it!
Shindy COctober 5, 2013
Cute, intimate, and tasty Italian fare in the UES.
Melissa RogersJanuary 7, 2014
Their fresh-baked bread is washed in olive oil and dusted with salt. Buy a loaf - they sell out quickly!
Ronnie GutmanNovember 18, 2021
Ask price of dessert before you get it 😉
Jonathan CohenSeptember 16, 2016
Order the pappardelle and thank me later.
Warrent SattFebruary 2, 2014
The evening began with an order of the antipasta della casa. The appetizer was full of seasonal fresh veggies, do ordered the pappardelle handmade pasta with a fresh bolognese sauce an excellent dish.
Bjorn de CarroDecember 3, 2019
Serious Italian with great pasta / Milanese
Jane DoeDecember 6, 2018
Antipasti, pappardelle, and the chicken
ashley tevatiaJune 18, 2010
The house bread is fantastic. Get the formaggi app with the plum jam. You won't be disappointed.
Peter WoloszynDecember 5, 2013
Holy god the bolognese is killer (in the best way possible)
Christi ScofieldApril 6, 2010
Go to Sfoglia and get the Chicken cooked under a brick. Fantastic! And don't miss the bread pudding for dessert.
Bjorn de CarroDecember 3, 2019
Not cheap but very good cousy Italian
Ron AllenDecember 13, 2014
Everything.
Erich WiernaszAugust 22, 2015
The chicken. Get the chicken.
suneelApril 25, 2014
garganelli and pappardelle are outrageously good
NanceApril 7, 2011
Amazing warm bread, great pasta dishes, and delicious desserts!!
EatMeDrinkMeNYCOctober 28, 2010
So many great dishes so get half-portions and try more than one!
Eddie EinbinderDecember 7, 2010
been here a few times now and everything i order is fabulous...
Lauren GilchristJuly 11, 2012
Italian dining for the 1%. Good for parents.
Jenny AnneNovember 11, 2011
Red wine and the Papardelle..... So good!
Ginny BechtoldJune 18, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Tagliatelle Bolognese is house speciality--not to be missed!
Scott DamassaFebruary 13, 2011
Pappardelle bolognese was heavy and overbooked. Given the other high reviews, I bet it was just an off night.
James HerbertJuly 21, 2010
Chicken was amazing - best I've had in a long while
Restaurant FairyJune 20, 2013
Try the Antipast
Restaurant FairyJune 20, 2013
Try the lasagna
Restaurant FairyJune 20, 2013
Try the Squid
MikeyMay 24, 2018
This place was just average!
Bobby TreanorJanuary 14, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Pork shoulder. That's all.
suneelApril 25, 2014
the bread is ridiculous
Flynn JonesMay 1, 2012
Tip to self: the Pappardelle alla Bolognese is great. The Rhubarb and Cherry Torta with Vanilla Gelato is--somehow--even better.
Kira RochaFebruary 15, 2012
Pasta for delivery wasn't good at all. And very small portion for $20 per mediocre pasta dish

1 2

61 Photos

Sfoglia

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Sfoglia

Appears on 322 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.