Sottocasa Pizzeria
Pizzeria$$$$
Central Harlem, New York
"Hands down the best pizza in Harlem"(2 Tips)"4 Stagioni"(2 Tips)
"... and speck with a sparkly glass of champagne - you can't go wrong! Owners are wonderful,..."(2 Tips)
"Best pizza in NYC - love the Prosciutto pizza"(2 Tips)
50 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- stagioni
- espresso
- good for dates
- flourless chocolate cake
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
AlAnoud A AlGhunaimJuly 20, 2022If you’re worried that a trip to Harlem is “too far” you should reconsider. It doesn’t matter what pizza you order, you’ll enjoy it. Go to dishes are Diavola or Margherita, Tartufo is to die for!🤍
Harlem AmbassadorMay 28, 2016Leave Halal\ Kosher dietary restrictions at the door, and be sure to try that Talleggio & Prosciutto pizza which takes all of (2) minutes to perfect. Pizza, wine, salad and not much else! Authentic!
DevontaOctober 30, 2016Good vibes and good music inside this charming Pizzeria. Reminds me of of the pizza in Italy. I ordered the 4 Stagioni. 👍🏿
Ashley LoNovember 5, 2016My favorite is the Popeye, a classic combination with only the finest ingredients cooked to perfection. I'm obsessed with this place. The owner and service is great and the ambiance is perfect!- My favorite pizza in NYC (and I eat a lot of pizza in NYC). Try the Brussels sprouts and speck with a sparkly glass of champagne - you can't go wrong! Owners are wonderful, sweet and accommodating.
- Stephanie MMay 23, 2023Highly recommend this restaurant for its food & its atmosphere. Enjoyed: cappuccino, iced coffee, burrata plate, 4 Stagioni, parmigiana, & flourless chocolate cake with strawberry & whipped cream.
Milan PetrovicMarch 27, 2019Warm, Italian atmosphere. Owners are doing great job with the real Italian style pizza, and great espresso caffe. Pizza Regginela is on the level of the best pizza places in Napoli! Bravo!
Murphy BrownSeptember 30, 2020Best place for Pizza Lovers. I visited the place with my friends and we enjoyed it. Yummy and Delicious Pizza. Quality is superb and prices are reasonable. Recommended.
Central Harlem's newest spot for pizza makes their Neapolitan style and its popular. Be prepared to wait a bit, especially if you arrive around 6 PM, when dinner orders are being made.- Judy BishopJuly 29, 2024Sottocasa Pizzeria is generally praised for its cozy environment. The crust is frequently described as crispy and well-crafted, while the toppings are noted for their freshness and quality.
- Ernest HoltApril 24, 2024The centerpiece of Sottocasa's menu is their wood-fired pizzas. Each pizza is handcrafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection in a traditional brick oven.
- KonstantinMay 8, 2017Delicious Neapolitan Pizza. Very friendly and welcoming staff. Service is great. Wonderful place for families.
- John CookJanuary 6, 2024Sottocasa Pizzeria is a hidden gem! Exceptional service, cozy atmosphere, and the pizzas are a delight to the taste buds. A must-try for any pizza lover
Bokyung ParkFebruary 19, 2024During the weekdays, it’s dinner only. Casual atmosphere. They cook in an Italian wood-fired oven. A well-known place for authentic Italian Pizza.- Andrew MallettMarch 6, 2024Amazing pizza. Family friendly and super cool design. Pizza was definitely one of the best I’ve ever had and service was very quick.
- Ernest HoltMarch 4, 2024Considering the quality, the price is reasonable. Ideal for those who want a romantic night out. There was also plenty of room for bigger groups.
- Leisl EvansOctober 7, 2020Pizza my favorite One!. Try sprouts and spit with a sparkly glass of champagne from Brussels. Yummy.
- bill andreasMarch 4, 2024Such a great experience eating at this restaurant. The service was top notch and the pizza was to die for.
LorenzoOctober 7, 2017Neapolitan pizza at its best. The best in the city. And I am Neapolitan, I can tell ;)
Nailah HinesJuly 16, 2018ordered the salsiccia, really yummy! pair with a glass of Pinot Grigio for a cute lil weekday dinner- Susanne LambertMarch 5, 2024Delicious food, waiters are very attentive, and super nice atmosphere. Plus it’s all at an affordable price.
- Judy BishopJuly 9, 2024This cozy pizzeria immediately caught my eye with its inviting atmosphere and the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza.
69 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Fresh ingredients, wood fired oven imported from Napoli, and authentic flavors: this is what pizza is for us. Simple and Delicious. Benvenuto!
Open until 10:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 5:00 PM–10:30 PM
- Fri
- 5:00 PM–11:30 PM
- Sat
- Noon–11:30 PM
- Sun
- Noon–10:30 PM
(646) 928-4870
Features
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 8.4
"Best pizza I've ever had. Got 2 peroni beers and a whole pie for only 25.20 (including tax) I'll def be going back."
Kelsey Richard - 8.9
"New pizza spot in the neighborhood and it’s amazing. The thick, square slice of Sicilian style pepperoni was incredible. The best pizza place we have this area now."
Reagan Barbosa - 7.5
"Hot Bird and Spicy Salami are fantastic. The crust is the best crust I have ever had."
Mike Friedlich
Places people like to go after Sottocasa Pizzeria
- 8.9
"Carrot cake and candied yam are amazing seasonal flavors. Salted caramel and blueberry cheesecake are also delicious year round. Our favorite ice cream spot by far!"
Rachel K
- 9.1
"Amazing historical theater in the heart of a Harlem. I took my mom to see Luenell. The performance was great and the audience’s vibe was fun and welcoming."
Denise D. - 8.2
"Beautiful ambience and nice service. Sit outside if you can. Excellent wine list. Corn soup is delish (skip if you're lactose-intolerant)."
Akiko Bombita
Appears on 405 lists
Created by Max Wendkos
61 items • 2 followers
Created by Rens Herweijer
51 items • 4 followers
Dining in Harlem (cafes, bistros, sandwich shops)
Created by Harlem Ambassador
106 items • 29 followers
