See all
435 photos

Supper

Italian Restaurant and Wine Bar$$$$

Alphabet City, New York

Save

Supper

8.5^/10

1,135

ratings

Ranked #8 for burrata cheese in New York
The experts at Eater and Gothamist recommend this place
"And the Spaghetti al Limone and Risotto al Limone are soooo good!"(16 Tips)
"lemon pasta is the way to go. or lasagna on wed"(13 Tips)
"The kale gnocchi and hazelnut panna cotta were perfection."(8 Tips)
"Cacio e Pepe and lemon spaghetti are both simple and delicious!"(8 Tips)

274 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
burrata cheese
risotto
priest stranglers
daily specials
good for groups
trendy
brunch food
polenta
French toast
cute
bruschetta
veal
rustic
casual
lemon
outdoor seating
meats
dinner
omelettes
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Dan S.October 15, 2011
Cash ONLY. Ask prices for unpriced specials to avoid surprises Great food.
Erin H.August 13, 2019
Supper has the ambiance down but they are a cash only expensive establishment. I was not impressed with the food, it was pretty mediocre - not worth the $$. Save your money and go somewhere better!
Lauren KnickerbockerJune 3, 2013
Spaghetti ai limone has been my order at least 5 times and I'm still not sick of it!
Rex PhamJanuary 26, 2014
It was cool to see the chefs at work in the kitchen but the food wasnt inpressive
PureWowAugust 3, 2016
Spaghetti Al Limone: There’s nothing more satisfying than squeezing a giant hunk of lemon onto your pasta, then topping it with the world’s largest mountain of cheese. Trust us. Read more
Heather HeckApril 26, 2015
Kale gnocci 👌🏻
Yuki SuzukiJune 16, 2011
Be prepare, back seating area is effing so loud!!! If you cab sit down outside, I recommend to do that. Too loud. Couldn't enjoy the good food and conversation.
happycontentmeApril 1, 2011
Cash only!!! Fridays and Saturdays are a longass wait but Thursday is perfect.
Mary SomersJanuary 15, 2012
Ask for cappuccino and they write a message to you!
TingOctober 26, 2014
Get the Osso buco
TrevorMay 5, 2019
Fresh pasta 💯
Amanda SmithFebruary 21, 2012
This place is delicious and the service was quick and friendly!!
Kashem MiahApril 22, 2012
Try the meatball special. It's delicious
doug jaegerAugust 17, 2010
Been here 25+ times
Burrata mozzarella, it's a special. Thursday usually, occasionally Monday. Try it, it will not fail you?
IanApril 24, 2013
The best Italian restaurant is not in Little Italy it's here. Everything on the menu is great. Make sure you start with the huge ball of mozzarella. Cool interior...cash only... great date spot :)
Rachel SklarMarch 26, 2009
Been here 5+ times
Get the Tuscan Panzanella salad - delicious salad of tomatoes, capers and awesome grilled bread cubes sopped in a delicious vinegary dressing. BEST.
Jenny GomezNovember 17, 2012
The specials. Only mess with the specials.
Nancy YiMarch 29, 2015
Great for date night
Russell SemmelJanuary 19, 2014
1 star. Specials menu didn't list prices. We were shocked when the bill came. Charged unreasonable and inconsistent amounts and was highly misleading. Slow service too. Good food though.
Jane Y.December 13, 2009
Get the mozzarella to share.. it's the most buttery, delicious mozzarella i've ever tried.
Carlie RiceSeptember 27, 2015
Service was garbage but the food was delicious
Amanda TheilerApril 25, 2015
pasta 11-16$. long wait on saturdays.
Mike FarahJanuary 4, 2011
Nice little Italian joint. Simple, good food. I second the mozzarella.
Patrick BaskinSeptember 15, 2015
Food is good, but not as good as hyped, watch out for the bait and switch pricing
Stacy CurtinAugust 14, 2011
The burrata mozzarella is amazing!
Len GrandJune 26, 2014
A third place
Jake ArchibaldMarch 9, 2015
Traditional Italian food.
Elizabeth LightbodySeptember 14, 2015
Lemon pasta baby!
Lindsay SwartzMarch 26, 2011
The papardelle in lamb ragu is to die for
David BirdsongDecember 23, 2014
Great vibe
Paulina PeltaJanuary 29, 2018
Good for takeout
Saarim ZamanJanuary 15, 2016
Lemon pasta forever
Brett PerryApril 27, 2015
Cash only FYI.
Igor S.March 10, 2011
Order the non-hazelnut panacotta. It's unbelievably good.
Joseph MisitiDecember 11, 2011
great food ... cash only though
Joseph MisitiDecember 11, 2011
great food... cash only though
William HubaJuly 17, 2019
Really overpriced for mediocre Italian food. Drop about $10 off all the items and it would be fine.
Matt 🐹October 5, 2014
This is the spot
Jaclyn 💃🏻August 25, 2013
Kale and goat cheese omelet.
MelzieMay 20, 2011
Been here 5+ times
It is so all about the lemon pasta! Read more
Pawel GodlewskiMay 23, 2010
Get the Rabbit. It's delicious. Tomatoes here are also unreal.
Colin RhoadsOctober 6, 2011
daily special - tis a safe bet
Andrew HinesAugust 7, 2014
Family dinner
Ryan SinclairSeptember 3, 2011
Veal meatballs and spinach gnocchi=heaven!
AdamOctober 20, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Some secrets can only be shared in person.
Saif DiaSeptember 8, 2015
Same owners as Frank's
Mike HSeptember 25, 2011
Very delicious, but very loud and very cramped.
Gauri SharmaNovember 21, 2010
The vest Buffalo Mozzerala I have had in my life!
Liz MillerOctober 14, 2010
Lasagna was delicious but small. More please!
Lisa BurnettFebruary 4, 2010
get the gnocci with the garlic cream sauce - skip the grilled calamari

1 2 3 4 5 6

435 Photos

Supper

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Supper

Appears on 1,572 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.