Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012
Braise Restaurant & Culinary School is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

1. Braise Restaurant & Culinary School

8.5
1101 S 2nd St (at W. Washington St.), Milwaukee, WI
Tapas Restaurant · Walker's Point · 16 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Well-done cocktails made with infused liquors (they're always changing, too), an interesting wine list and craft beers draw guests to the bar. Look for Braise's culinary school to open soon.

Buckley's Restaurant & Bar is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

2. Buckley's Restaurant & Bar

9.0
801 N Cass St (at E Wells St), Milwaukee, WI
Bar · Juneau Town · 56 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Try the appetizer of house-made potato gnocchi with wine-braised short rib, or a gorgeously crisp Cornish hen that's served with spicy braised kale, chickpeas and Greek yogurt that modulates the heat.

Circa 1880 is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

3. Circa 1880

1100 S 1st St (W Washington St), Milwaukee, WI
American Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: On the menu, four ingredients describe each item. From there, chef-owner Thomas Hauck runs with the dish.

Odd Duck is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

4. Odd Duck

8.9
2352 S Kinnickinnic Ave (Just South of Lincoln Avenue), Milwaukee, WI
American Restaurant · Bay View · 49 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Order one of several entrée-size plates, and the staff likely will encourage the table to share even those. Small plates are the name of the game here, adventurous dishes with striking flavors.

Rumpus Room - A Bartolotta Gastropub is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

5. Rumpus Room - A Bartolotta Gastropub

1030 N Water St (at E. Highland Ave.), Milwaukee, WI
Gastropub · Juneau Town · 67 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Great food with craft beers and craft cocktails (an impressive lineup of brown liquors for sipping, too) make this a downtown destination, popular before and after shows.

Graffito is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

6. Graffito

102 N Water St (at E Erie St), Milwaukee, WI
Italian Restaurant · Historic Third Ward · 42 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Graffito's food is better than ever under chef Joseph McCormick; the pillow-like gnocchi in spicy red sauce are contenders for the best in town.

Tony & Mia is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

7. Tony & Mia

515 Wells St, Delafield, WI
Italian Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Braised beef ravioli is a signature dish, and rightly so; cod is lovely with an acidic note from caper emulsion, served with white asparagus, caper berries and a crisped cake of delicate capellini.

Sanford Restaurant is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

8. Sanford Restaurant

8.4
1547 N Jackson St (at E. Pleasant St.), Milwaukee, WI
New American Restaurant · Lower East Side · 22 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: The emphasis for this menu always has been on seasonal ingredients and world flavors, and while it's refined, it can be downright playful.

Hinterland Gastropub is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

9. Hinterland Gastropub

222 E Erie St, Milwaukee, WI
Gastropub · Historic Third Ward · 28 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: The house charcuterie is fantastic; in a region where summer sausage is king, you'll find none finer than the one at Hinterland, served on crackers made with 5-year-old Wisconsin cheddar.

Umami Moto is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

10. Umami Moto

718 N Milwaukee St (btwn Mason St & Wisconsin Ave), Milwaukee, WI
Asian Restaurant · Juneau Town · 33 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Pick any unbeatable dessert by pastry chef Kurt Fogle, like chocolate and peanut butter, a creamy, crispy, giddy delight.

Harbor House is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

11. Harbor House

9.0
550 N Harbor Dr, Milwaukee, WI
Seafood Restaurant · 60 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Dishes come and go, depending on the season. Lobster potpie is extravagant and comforting at once. Meat eaters aren't forgotten here; the veal cutlet with Marsala demi-glace is a pleasure.

Meritage is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

12. Meritage

5921 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI
American Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Tapas nights (Tuesday and Wednesdays) are great deals: several ever-changing tapas at $5 each are enough for two (or more) to share.

Lagniappe Brasserie is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

13. Lagniappe Brasserie

7.3
17001 W Greenfield Ave, New Berlin, WI
Café · 5 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: I find chef-owner Andrew Tenaglia's dinners an extraordinary value; well-crafted entrées include salad or soup.

La Merenda is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

14. La Merenda

8.5
125 E National Ave (S 1st St.), Milwaukee, WI
Tapas Restaurant · 70 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Chef-owner Peter Sandroni's casual tapas bar has made itself easy to love by looking around the world for its international menu while incorporating ingredients from close to home.

Dream Dance Steak is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

15. Dream Dance Steak

7.7
1721 W Canal St, Milwaukee, WI
Steakhouse · Menomonee River Valley · 11 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Bone-in ribeye boasted deep, beefy flavor and a sturdy crust; salmon fillet embellished with nuggets of salmon pancetta, snap pea-red pepper-couscous salad, and dill-mascarpone sauce ties it together.

Bartolotta's Lake Park Bistro is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

16. Bartolotta's Lake Park Bistro

9.3
3133 E Newberry Blvd, Milwaukee, WI
French Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: The rustic French food is a delight, with openers such as changing charcuterie like intensely rich duck rillettes, and coquille St. Jacques, the scallops sweet among artichoke, fennel and olives.

The Union House Restaurant is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

17. The Union House Restaurant

8.5
PO Box 216, Genesee Depot, WI
Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: The rustic wood-paneled dining room makes me want to order a Wisconsin classic, roast duck with wild rice, and it's perfect, crisp skin and all. Chef John Mollet's short ribs are moist as can be.

Eddie Martini's is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

18. Eddie Martini's

8.9
8612 Watertown Plank Rd, Milwaukee, WI
Steakhouse · 25 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: A classic appetizer of shrimp de Jonghe, in garlic butter and topped with panko crumbs for extra crunch, is made superlative with best-quality shrimp.

Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993 is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

19. Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993

8.4
7616 W State St, Wauwatosa, WI
Italian Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: There are classics such as pappardelle with duck ragu or brick-roasted chicken, but I'm always eager to try chef Juan Urbieta's seasonal menu, available prix fixe or a la carte.

Pastiche Bistro & Wine Bar is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

20. Pastiche Bistro & Wine Bar

3001 S Kinnickinnic Ave (E Rusk Ave), Milwaukee, WI
French Restaurant · Bay View · 24 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Duckling breast with chorizo and orange is juicy and tender, the flavors in harmony. The flatiron steak with crisp fries and shallot butter is an admirable rendition of steak frites.

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

21. Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne

8.8
724 N Milwaukee St (btw Milwaukee St and Mason St), Milwaukee, WI
Steakhouse · Juneau Town · 33 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Traditional appetizers get modern embellishments: tuna tartare is topped with a jewel-like quenelle of wasabi-flavored tobiko. Nicely browned brussels sprouts make a fine side dish.

Bacchus is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

22. Bacchus

8.9
925 E Wells St, Milwaukee, WI
American Restaurant · Juneau Town · 28 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Careful service and a 900-bottle wine list make this a choice spot for celebrations.

Maxie's is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

23. Maxie's

9.1
6732 W Fairview Ave (at S 68th St), Milwaukee, WI
Southern Food Restaurant · Bluemound Heights · 116 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Maxie's puts its spin on Southern regional dishes, with hearty entrées such as pulled pork in eastern Carolina-style vinegar sauce with slaw and beans, or shrimp in tasso sauce over creamy grits.

Mr B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

24. Mr B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse

8.6
18380 W Capitol Dr, Brookfield, WI
Steakhouse · 21 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: The filet from chef Brent Perszyk's kitchen is classic, a very good balm for a red-meat craving. Nicely done potato purée and sautéed mixed mushrooms on the side, and you're set.

Jake's Restaurant is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

25. Jake's Restaurant

8.1
21445 Gumina Rd, Brookfield, WI
Steakhouse · 15 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: Bone-in ribeye, like all the steaks here, is Angus and aged for 24 days or longer; the flavor is true beef, and it's cooked a perfect medium-rare. Ordering seasonal specials is highly recommended.

Zarletti is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

26. Zarletti

8.4
741 N Milwaukee St (Mason St), Milwaukee, WI
Italian Restaurant · Juneau Town · 29 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: If the night's ragu della casa happens to be ground lamb in creamy tomato sauce, don't hesitate. Breaded veal cutlets, crispy at the edges, carry the bright note of lemon.

Crazy Water is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

27. Crazy Water

8.8
839 S 2nd St (Walker), Milwaukee, WI
American Restaurant · Walker's Point · 32 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: The menu presents world flavors in combinations that are bold but make perfect sense. If you like your parties quieter, angle for a table in the small back room or on the lovely patio.

Le Reve Patisserie & Cafe is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

28. Le Reve Patisserie & Cafe

9.1
7610 Harwood Ave (State St), Wauwatosa, WI
French Restaurant · 59 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: It's not a trip to Le Reve without one of the intricate pastries for dessert, such as hazelnut-chocolate cake, copious cream, ganache and pleasure.

Three Brothers Bar & Restaurant is one of Carol Deptolla's Top 30: Best restaurants for 2012.

29. Three Brothers Bar & Restaurant

7.4
2414 S Saint Clair St, Milwaukee, WI
Eastern European Restaurant · Bay View · 16 tips and reviews

Tap MilwaukeeTap Milwaukee: When you order veal breast, it's not the trim little bundle that other restaurants present; no, this is a huge slice of the breast, fat and all, and the meat is gloriously rich.