The Lobster Roll Restaurant
Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Amagansett
The lobster at The Lobster Roll Restaurant is a can't miss
"My first lobster roll in years was just as good as my very first!"(67 Tips)
"Try the puffers if in season, I hear the pie is great too."(6 Tips)
"Fun ambience with great services located right at the Montauk Hwy."(4 Tips)
"The seafood chili was amazing"(3 Tips)
110 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- lobster rolls
- montauk
- puffers
- good for groups
- lively
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
The Corcoran GroupMay 29, 2014If you're driving out to Montauk and don't stop here on the way, you're missing out. This spot has one of the best lobster rolls around, and some seriously awesome strawberry rhubarb pie.
George SpartanAugust 29, 2016Amazingly good Lobster Bisque and New England clam chowder. It's been open since 1965-Try the cold or hot lobster roll or any of the broiled or fried seafood combos shrimp-scallops, flounder or sole.
Kathleen VargasAugust 19, 2015I love this place!! Their Lobster roll is amazing and while your there grab yourself a bowl of clam chowder. It's very flavorful and has a lot of chunks of clams which I enjoyed. A must go!
Paige CAugust 25, 2017Amazing service. The staff was so welcoming and friendly. Food was awesome. I recommend the shrimp, mussels or lobster roll (of course). Dog friendly. Good for dinner too!
- Ben K.August 28, 2016Awesome lobster roll - prefer the cold, but hot is great too! Try the puffers if in season, I hear the pie is great too.
Chris CritelliAugust 10, 2015Very cool place, everything we had was really good, the hot lobster rolls, seafood chili, and tuna steak! Def looking forward to going back
EMC◾️July 13, 2022The staff is super nice. Not just 1 or 2, but all of them! They were very accommodating and sweet. It’s crazy expensive and the food is good - not amazing. But for out here it’s a good place.
Jeremy BeckAugust 6, 2013Had my first gluten-free lobster roll here! I think I'm spoiled for life. After all, they're named for them, and for good reason. The lobster was overflowing and delicious, good gluten-free bread too!
The name explains it! The Lobster roll is delicious and a must! Some of the best lobster roll I have had.
Daniel McDonoughMay 30, 2016The fried founder is a great alternative if you're not a lobster roll fan. Ask for a side of cocktail sauce.
- Chris SteeleJune 13, 2015Now featuring a robust gluten-free menu that includes some very respectable buns. My first lobster roll in years was just as good as my very first!
Jeffrey NgSeptember 29, 2012The Lobster Rolls are obviously fantastic but the real gem here is the Cole Slaw. I know it's ridiculous considering the whole menu rocks but its seriously spectacular!
Jessica J.May 31, 2013Definitely try the puffer fish. The seafood Mac n' cheese is on the smaller side but is LOADED with seafood.
Jennifer RottkampAugust 17, 2015So disappointed. Over priced. Got crab cakes as an app. $11 for ONE crab cake!! If we knew that we wouldn't have ordered it! Charged us extra for a bun to share the lobster roll then charged us $3!
Adam SiemiginowskiSeptember 7, 2013Everyone is talking bout the Lob*ter Roll. Get the Puffers and Chips! S'like... shrimp made out of fish, well, actually, it's boneless blowfish. This is outstanding!
BaturalpMay 30, 2019Warm lobster roll is the definition of perfection. Fried calamari was so fresh. Highly recommended.
Hands down the best lobster roll in the Hamptons. Get it "Connecticut style." If you are hungry, order buffalo calamari to start.
Rachel KJuly 30, 2016The best part of the meal is the strawberry rhubarb pie with cinnamon ice cream.
Julia KwanAugust 11, 2014I had the lobster bisque, fried calamari, fried oysters, mussels and lobster roll. It was all perfect.
Brian M.August 26, 2016What's NOT good here? The answer is nothing. Place is amazing and does seafood the way it's supposed to be done.
Andy AmendolaSeptember 15, 2013Would you like some lobster roll with that celery? Seriously there's way to much celery in the lobster roll here, overpowers the lobster taste. Skip it. Puffers and some other items are good!
Vince FrisinaAugust 24, 2018The hot lobster roll with butter! And don’t forget some fries to soak up the extra juice.
Alexandra FanningJuly 29, 2019This is my favorite place in the world. Get the lobster roll sit back and relax in the perfect atmosphere
Ryan GallagherSeptember 30, 2017Get the lobster roll and a beer and enjoy. You will have to wait for a seat.
Frank RimalovskiMarch 31, 2012Like it here but it is either grossly overrated or ain't what it used to be (or both). Better lobster rolls at Pearl's in NYC. Is good for families nonetheless. (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Albert RestainoJune 27, 2015It's called the Lobster Roll so try that, they're amazing. Great pies as well.- Frank RimalovskiMarch 31, 2012Like it hear but it is either grossly overrated or ain't what it used to be (or both). Better lobster rolls at Pearl's in NYC. Is good for families nonetheless. (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
LaurenMay 26, 2013Excellent lobster roll. Strawberry rhubarb is the best pie I've ever had - must order.
JillianSeptember 1, 2014Huge chunks of lobster. (Go with the classic cold lobster roll) Cole slaw was a surprise power player.
ToryBurchApril 21, 2011If you're feeling ambitious, bike here from East (or even South) Hampton for lunch. It's all about the lobster roll and fries.
- Rachel KJuly 30, 2016Vegetarians- obviously not many choices here, but the veggie burger is passable.
G LutzAugust 27, 2020We almost didn't go, but we were very pleased we did. Awesome food and service.
JasonJune 25, 2015Definitely stop in for some lobster rolls on your way to The Hamptons and Montauk!
Burk JacksonAugust 6, 2011They have an entire gluten free menu for those looking for such things, including lobster rolls and cupcakes!
438 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
The Lobster Roll Restaurant
1980 Montauk Hwy (btwn Dolphin Dr & Beaver St)
Amagansett, NY 11930
United States
Amagansett, NY 11930
United States
"This is where Summer begins."
Closed until 11:30 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:30 AM–9:30 PM
(631) 267-3740
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after The Lobster Roll Restaurant
- 9.1
"The historic Montauk Lighthouse was commissioned by George Washington and is open to the public. There's golf, spectacular state parks, great restaurants and much more in Montauk."
NY Islanders - 8.9
"White sand, lifeguards avail and very big waves (great for bodysurfing & boogie boarding)! Get here early and hit up Nick's beachside sundeck for a cold one when the crowd's arrive..."
Carmen da Silva - 8.2
"Can't go wrong with the Sweet Mary. Perfect camomile tea for a rainy day."
Ashley Specht
Appears on 288 lists
Top Family-Friendly Restaurants in the Hamptons
Created by Foursquare City Guide
30 items • 29 followers
Ultimate Summertime Lobster Rolls
Created by Foursquare City Guide
89 items • 249 followers
A Tastemaker's Guide to The Hamptons
Created by Chloe's Fruit
19 items • 48 followers