See all
481 photos

The Rathskeller

German Restaurant$$$$

Downtown Indianapolis, Indianapolis

Save

The Rathskeller

8.7^/10

362

ratings

Ranked #5 for authentic places in Indianapolis
"The jaegerschnitzel is delicious as well."(4 Tips)
"And really fun polka band called Polka Boys :-)"(4 Tips)
"atmosphere in the biergarten"(10 Tips)
"Probably the best place for authentic German cuisine downtown."(3 Tips)

77 Tips and reviews

Filter:

German food
polka
jaegerschnitzel
beer
pretzels
live music
good for groups
German potato salad
pork tenderloin
great value
chicken cordon bleu
spicy food
happy hour
tarts
outdoor seating
cider
mustard
big portions
discounts
dinner
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

SarahNovember 24, 2014
Get the hot wurst platte to share! It is a TON of food, so you might not even need an entrée. The mustard is super spicy but tasty! The jaegerschnitzel is delicious as well.
Upvoted Nov 19
Erik RowleyJanuary 16, 2017
A must dine while visiting Indy, this Bavarian themed restaurant is housed in a beautiful, ornate structure with moose heads adorning the walls. The jaegerschnitzel is fantastic!
SarahOctober 14, 2017
Definitely worth the price. You get a ton of food, and there are PRETZELS in the bread baskets! The mustard that comes with is VERY spicy horseradish. Delicious. Apple strudel for dessert!
ISC ChicagoJuly 7
ROULADEN (Beef rollup filled with bacon, onions, spicy mustard and tart pickle wedge slowly cooked for tenderness and topped with homemade brown gravy), with sauerkraut, German potato salad
Amy Brockway-JacklAugust 7, 2016
The Ayinger Celebrator Double Bock is a don't-miss for dark beer fans! Authentic German atmosphere and dishes but plenty of non-German food for any diners who are mostly there for the drink.
Erik RowleyJanuary 16, 2017
Be careful dipping your pretzel, this stuff is extremely spicy! The Rathskeller also has a phenomenal German and European beer selection.
Patrice JimersonDecember 23, 2014
The haute wurst plate, Mager Cider, and Rathskeller Amber were all wonderful!!! Beware of spicy mustard -- is delicious but hot!!! The tables in the back of the restaurant are lovely!!
Jim LewisApril 8, 2016
They need to take one of the two tops out of the bar. I have fat dude behind, can't fit in his own space, so I have to put up with his every move Telegraphing into the back of my chair!
ArdvaarkAugust 2, 2015
The bar tenders in the beer garden are frequently wrong about their stock of some of the more exotic imports. Visit the bar inside for the real story.
Men's Health MagNovember 17, 2011
The Germans, as it turns out, know how to make a hell of a crisp brew. Saddle up in the bar attached to this German restaurant, and order from its wide range of unpronounceable German beers.
ISC ChicagoJuly 7
OCHSENSCHWANZ SUPPE (A GERMAN TRADITION MADE WITH OX TAILS, ONIONS, MUSHROOMS AND PORT WINE)
Ross RobertsonMay 9, 2018
Never actually have come here for a meal, but the beer garden is a nice spot to make new friends. Always a good time.
Deborah HollowayAugust 25, 2012
My husband took me here for our first date, I really enjoyed everything the meal, the music, (the company) and even going up on the roof...
Ryan G.August 14, 2013
Best wienerschnitzel outside of Germany. Also, the trick to dealing with the mustard is breathe in through your nose and out through your mouth.
Sasha GMarch 30, 2014
Dinner price was quite pricy. Listen to the waitress when she says the mustard is hot. Enjoyed the beer esp German ones. Fun place to visit.
Michael CJuly 26, 2019
An absolute stunner of a German-American restaurant, biergarten, and unique piece of Indy history.
Zymurgy MikeJuly 7, 2013
Great food with huge portions. Outdoor biergarten cannot be beat.
Chris SmithAugust 16, 2010
Been here 10+ times
The schnitzel cordon bleu, jaegerschnitzel & regular schnitzel are really great, just different arrangements of toppings/sauces. Very spicy mustard. Bread & pretzels are suberb. Doppelbock to drink!
Ryan RoudebushMay 11, 2018
Been here 25+ times
The atmosphere in the biergarten makes for a perfect spring/summer/fall night!
David LeszcynskiJuly 19, 2016
Such a beautiful venue. Love going here for events and drinks both.
Erik NagelJune 26, 2017
Go every night. Such a fun environment and the live music is always great.
Christina DuryJanuary 25, 2013
The Schlackt Platte is amazing! Paired with red cabbage and German potato salad - just the perfect pairings.
Kyle AdamsJune 26, 2017
Probably the best place for authentic German cuisine downtown.
Patrick HarrahJuly 19, 2013
Get the Chicken Cordon Bleu fingers and the pork tenderloin. They were delicious.
Nancy Quincy McDermottFebruary 3, 2013
Great venue for live music. Get there early to get a seat.
Chris RJuly 2, 2017
Decent German food. Enjoyed the jaegerschnitzel with a hefeweizen.
Zach SteinerAugust 31, 2014
Beer garden in the summer to private parties upstairs.
Andrea TownsendJuly 14, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Wayne and Mike rock it behind the bar. Some of Indy's finest and unmolested bartenders.
William BackhoffAugust 13, 2012
Great beer, great locale, awesome vibe and exquisite food!
Ricky PottsApril 2, 2011
If you are looking for an authentic German experience, try this place. From entrees to beers they are legit.
MujtabaSeptember 3, 2011
The only beer garden in Indy and they have excellent pretzels and outdoor area.
ArdvaarkAugust 2, 2015
The mustard is delicious, but hot. No, really, I'm serious.
David BrunstingJanuary 14, 2012
The Fikadelle is on the Super 46 Sandwich List
Dave ShulseAugust 5, 2010
If your in Indy, this beer drinkin and wurst eatin historic restaurant and pub is worth the visit. Check it out! Read more
Mike MilivojevicNovember 3, 2012
Try the parmesan pesto french bread appetizer!
Ashley BearMarch 31, 2012
Amazing mustard!!!!! And really fun polka band called Polka Boys :-)
Erin CAugust 10, 2014
Been here 50+ times
Go to the Biergarten. Just do it.
ISC ChicagoJuly 7
Bread Service
Johnny RamoneJanuary 20, 2013
Great food, great beers, great environment.
Jodi MasseyMarch 23, 2013
Chicken poppers and sausage and kraut balls...yummmmmm!!!!
Matt SheeheMarch 7, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Get the potato pancakes. Know the potato pancakes. /Love/ the potato pancakes.
Terry PottengerJuly 12, 2013
Wayne is the best Bartender in Indianapolis!
Eric DamonAugust 22, 2014
Kristy 's company summer party. Polka Boys on stage.
Will SearsNovember 20, 2010
The spicy mustard is disgusting! I don't see the hype. I literally teared up when I ate it. The beer here is amazing, though!!!
Hank SchoemehlMarch 17, 2018
Awesome place
Liz EAugust 8, 2014
Biergarten is great!
Michael TresslerMarch 25, 2011
Been here 5+ times
For German food, the place is a joke. For beer and good times, it's always a good choice. Stick with the brats though.
Shivaughn P.February 24, 2012
I should have read the tips first. That mustard will clear out your sinuses.
Rapa PutyJune 12, 2012
Ask for the Rapaputy Discount!!!
Kaitlin (Irish) GrateSeptember 3, 2011
Get the sausage/brautwurst platter! Non non :-)

1 2

481 Photos

The Rathskeller

Related Searches

Places inside The Rathskeller

You might also like

Places people like to go after The Rathskeller

Appears on 109 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.