See all
175 photos

Toby's Public House II

(Now Closed)

Pub and Pizzeria$$$$

NoLita, New York

Save

Toby's Public House II

58 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Sara AlissaAugust 10, 2013
I really enjoyed the whole experience! Small salads are huge and pizza is Devine. Wine can be pricey but house wine during happy hour is $2 off! Delicious. Strongly recommended.
David GreenbergerSeptember 12, 2014
One of a few good places to grab a beer outside in Soho. $2 drafts (house brew) during Happy Hour
Brendon BattersonAugust 4, 2013
Awesome little pizzeria, some of the best wood oven pizza in the city. It's out of the way, and not many people know about it so it's never horribly busy.
Richard HollidayAugust 21, 2013
Currently has the Hofbräu Sommer on draft, which is hard to find. Nick is competing for The Most Interesting Bartender in the World and has a good shot at it.
doug jaegerNovember 27, 2014
Tartufata = amazing! The pizza was sick! Also the baked cookie dessert was amazing. Lots of really great draft beers.
Shane S.December 17, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Great local spot, nothing bad on the menu and good beers on tap. Make a friend who is part of the "beer club" and get the "G" mug.
Lindsey LNovember 9, 2012
Been here 5+ times
They support The Toby Project, which runs mobile spay/neuter vans & "in-neighborhood" clinics to provide free & low-cost spay/neuter to communities that surrender the most animals to city shelters.
Shane S.February 23, 2013
Been here 25+ times
New chef, same great food. Can't go wrong with a pizza and craft brew.
Matt RestivoApril 6, 2013
great spot for pizza and beers. reasonably priced. get the bufalina pizza and the spinach is good too.
Steve B.November 10, 2012
The Mushroom Ravioli with truffle oil is absolutely absurdly good. I am no foodie, but this blew my mind. Get it.
Linda AppelqvistSeptember 22, 2013
Delicious "real" fire oven-baked pizza. Taste as a real Italian pizza 🍕👌
Sorina S.June 5, 2013
Check in for the first time and you get 2 for 1 drinks. Great selection of beers and woodfire pizzas! Cheers!
prince of ArroganceMay 4, 2014
Have to say this place was fantastic. The pizza is excellent would definitely go back.
Laura ChinAugust 7, 2014
Surprisingly awesome pizza. Great beer list. Ask about the beer and wine club!!
Eric FriedmanJune 13, 2012
Great casual spot to grab a drink and brick oven pizza. Cash only, but there is an ATM in the back.
Edward FabilaApril 13, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Pizza's are delish! Don't forget to visit the bathroom--gorgeous vintage magazine covers!
William RMay 7, 2013
Been here 5+ times
The "Toby's Cheap" beer is an excellent choice. Enjoy with awesome pizza!
Tyler BrandtJune 6, 2014
Great selection of beers on tap, really generous with tastings :)
Megan ChiuJune 14, 2014
Truffle pizza is the best thing I've eaten since returning from Italy.
Patrick DezortMay 25, 2014
Get the table near the window or wherever Chad is working. He is very pleasant, helpful and sweet.
ThrillistMay 16, 2012
The prosciutto, crimini & black truffle cream sauce "Tartufata" is quite delicious. Read more
AmandaMarch 2, 2013
Loved the tea cocktail, infused with earl grey. Refreshing and clean.
Shane S.March 28, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Just expanded to 24 taps. More than double the craft brews to try!
Alan PetrilliDecember 30, 2013
Pizza is well worth the trip, and Sara behind the bar is awesome!
JD HarringtonDecember 27, 2012
Been here 10+ times
The bathroom is wallpapered with super awesome vintage Playboy pages. Totally worth a look.
Ryan BiasDecember 18, 2013
Bartender Tyler is a very nice man, and Toby the dog was prolly a very nice dog.
Lindsey LJuly 2, 2012
Been here 5+ times
The pizza is good. The atmosphere is fun. Go on now, honey. Get yourself some.
Emilio VitoloDecember 30, 2014
Good brick oven pie for an Ale House .. Beer selection is great
JC Martinez-SifreMarch 28, 2013
Refreshingly unrefined and homey in a way that is untouched by any "consulting agency." It's real.
Monti BrayApril 18, 2014
The fries appetizer is a definite no-go, but the pizza is delish.
Rex HarrisJune 29, 2013
Run, don't walk in the opposite direction. The 14 dollar pitcher of their cheapest beer was the highlight of this experience.
Premo SarJune 15, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Try the Agave Wheat and you won't regret it!
CarmsJune 14, 2014
The jalapeño poppers might sound really good, but you're better off trying something else.
Andrea RosenApril 13, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Try the "Bexo": a mug of wine and endless grief from the bartender.
Toby's Public House IIOctober 10, 2013
We are switching over to our Fall Beer selection and Fall Menu. Come in and see what's changing.
7th.ListMarch 21, 2012
This South Slope bar and pizzeria has opened a Little Italy location. Read more
Jan JongeneelDecember 26, 2013
the thin crusted pizza tartufata is to die for
Sara AlissaAugust 10, 2013
Also, this place is no longer cash only. Full bar & accept visa, MasterCard & Amex
💎TDecember 31, 2014
Their truffle pizza is a must.
Terry DanielDecember 8, 2013
Italian sausage pizza kicked ass and so did our server, Kelli!
Bobby KennedyOctober 16, 2014
$2 off drafts and cheap pizza during happy hour.
Cary RankinFebruary 6, 2014
Best tiramisu I've ever had.
RosalineMarch 3, 2013
Redhead waitress was terrible. Out of 2 beers we ordered but didn't know what they had left. Ordered a Bloody Mary and asked what vodka. She said "house". For party of 5 at noon, she included 20% tip!
Lara Latshaw NcmgJanuary 11, 2015
Toby's cheap beer is pretty good!
tineJuly 25, 2013
Meat&cheese boards are a real treat!
Jerry ChristalMay 9, 2012
They just got their liquor license today! Try the Black Garlic Pizza.
Alex SouquetMay 4, 2015
Amazing pizzas
PizzaSnobo pizzasnobo.comMay 28, 2012
Pizza, pub and sports. Nice combo.
Benjamin HabbelNovember 25, 2014
Pizza margherita
John CallousMay 25, 2012
Been here 50+ times
We have beer and wine. No liquor...yet.

1 2

175 Photos

Places people like to go after Toby's Public House II

Appears on 84 lists

DOWNTOWN drinks
Created by Leigh Tucker
124 items • 9 followers
2013 Beerathon
Created by Michael Danahy
26 items • 4 followers
StreetEasy SoHo Lunch List
Created by Zack🍕🍕
62 items • 14 followers

See all

United States » New York » New York » NoLita

Dining and Drinking » Bar » Pub

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.

Toby's Public House II

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Toby's Public House II

Appears on 84 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.