See all
269 photos

Tortuga's Lie

Seafood Restaurant, Bar, and Caribbean Restaurant$$$$

Nags Head

Save

Tortuga's Lie

8.3^/10

278

ratings

Ranked #5 for seafood restaurants in Nags Head
"The sauce for the Coco Loco chicken is delicious!"(5 Tips)
"The Cayman Conch Fritters are awesome!"(10 Tips)
"Go for the shark attack, bloody mary, fish tacos and jerk chicken."(20 Tips)
"A must go if you venture to the OBX, the Jerk Burger is a classic!"(3 Tips)

113 Tips and reviews

Filter:

conch fritters
casual
chicken
great value
trendy
chili
red curry
grits
beach
lunch
coconut
dinner
soup
parking
bacon
tires
good for special occasions
rice
chips and salsa
black beans
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

JoschkaMay 20, 2013
The Hummus and Fish Tacos are amazing! Also try the House Margaritha and ask for their specials, the Salmon Salad we got was great as well! Nice staff and reasonable prices.
Kelsey✨July 24, 2019
Everything we tried was great! Go for the shark attack, bloody mary, fish tacos and jerk chicken. The homemade hot sauce is also killer.
Just Spray It Power Washing Just Spray It Power WashingOctober 8, 2017
Excellent service, seated quickly, staff was very polite, food was "off the hook!!" Definitely added to our regular places to eat. Great staff and great food, you run a fantastic restaurant Richard.
Adriana SheckJanuary 1, 2019
Teriyaki burger is so yummy! This place also has great tortilla chips and salsa. Fries are alright, but they put a lot of salt and pepper on the fries. Ask for none or to go easy on seasoning.
Trader ScottOctober 19
Been here 10+ times
Black Bean and Fish Burrito. Always solid. And those fries… We dream about those fries.
Fraz NayyarJuly 22, 2011
Fish tacos and the jerk burger were both good. Fries here are quite unique (in a very good way). Unsweetened ice tea (the only way they serve it) was good too. Will be visiting this place again!
Tony ChangAugust 4, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Try the Roasted Red Pepper Artichoke Crab Dip - roasted red pepper - artichoke heart crab dip topped with jumbo lump crab meat. served with toasted pita points. (via @Foodspotting)
Visit North CarolinaSeptember 21, 2011
A local favorite. Seating is limited but the conch, crab, clams and more are worth the wait. While here, take a trip around the world by exploring the license plates that cover the walls and ceiling. Read more
EmmaMay 7, 2016
The CocoLoco Chicken is great!! So is the bacon wrapped shrimp and grits as well as the beans and rice.
Ashley StewartJuly 7, 2012
Holy hell!!! Amazing fish tacos and steamed shrimp! Great atmosphere and everyone there was sooooo nice, from staff to patrons. We will definitely be back next time we're here!
Kaitlyn FreemanJune 22, 2013
Get there early for an easy wait! Jerk chicken, fish tacos, and Bajan burger are all amazing
Travis ConteJune 7, 2015
Great beachy cocktails and definitely get the fish tacos. Very cool little place.
Pete B.August 9, 2013
Salsa had a bit of a spice kick. Had to wait an hour to be seated (unless you go to the open bar) but this is during vacation season. Jerk chicken was packed with flavor. Service great!
Lauren MorrisonJuly 5, 2012
Far and away the best place on the beach. Fish tacos are bomb. Always a long wait so post up at the bar for a drink while you wait for your table. Banging sushi, but only on Wednesday's.
Tony ChangAugust 1, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Try the Four Cheese Artichoke Crab Dip - four cheese, baby spinach, artichoke and crab dip with toasted pita points (via @Foodspotting)
VixenOctober 4, 2012
My favorite beach restaurant by far! Small and cozy, great atmosphere, good food, and all sorts of great beers (imports) on TAP.
The Outer Banks pageJuly 21, 2011
They have some of the best steamed, spiced shrimp on the beach. Parking is limited, but there is a public beach access nearby folks use for overflow parking and walk.
Kevin SAugust 31, 2017
Great Beer selection and fresh steamed seafood choices!!
Tony ChangAugust 4, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Try the Creamy Red Curried Crab & Portobello Soup - creamy red curried crab and portobello soup (via @Foodspotting)
Tony ChangAugust 1, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Try the Chili Wings - chili wings ~ chili garlic glazed wings with chopped peanuts & scallions (via @Foodspotting)
Clayton TaylorSeptember 20, 2019
Been here 5+ times
A must go if you venture to the OBX, the Jerk Burger is a classic!
Emilie MoseleyJune 3, 2016
Been here 10+ times
HUGE fish tacos. I couldn't eat more than 1 at lunch. Conch fritters were excellent.
Brian FanzoJune 11, 2012
Authentic local seafood... Amazing tuna and great little local atmosphere... Not great for big groups so get their early!
✨Naveena Abodha✨October 29, 2016
Tasty seafood, nice atmosphere
Eleanor PriceJanuary 5, 2014
Been here 5+ times
I have never had a bad meal nor have I had bad service here, both during the busy summer season and the off season!
Heather VandermydeApril 1, 2011
Love tortugas,my favorite spot when looking for good fresh food.awesome fries and great salad specials.they make my favorite hot sauce ever.
Monica EhrsamJuly 8, 2012
Best food on the Outer Banks. Get your name in early cause they fill up fast. Fish tacos and BBQ Cluck sandwich are amazing!!
Conner WilbergerJune 9, 2013
Sunshine Margarita Grande is a must, especially if mamma needs a refill! Nachos are always # 1 for appetizers & a BOFF is a given
Dale AndrewsSeptember 7, 2015
Fish tacos! Rice and beans were excellent, just a bit spicy. Amazing.
Tony ChangAugust 1, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Try the Conch Fritters - conch fritters ~ loaded with conch, lightly fried (via @Foodspotting)
Rrawat FelknerSeptember 1, 2020
The only thing good here was my drink Lost Tortuga (Light rum & Spiced rum, Creme de banana, Orange & pineapple juice). The food was meh. Anything in the menu w/jerk seasoning was bland.
Ashley CookAugust 5, 2013
Worth the wait! Get the island fries. Delicious. Very friendly and accommodating.
HeatherAugust 8, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Go for sushi Wednesday - it's fantastic! Get there very early to get a seat!
Kathy MartucciJune 25, 2014
Fish tacos are yummy! Tortuga's Lie jot sauce is no joke. It will melt your face off.
Blakeley NewbillAugust 30, 2011
Uh, amazing scallops, fish tacos, fish burrito, oh the sushi, by FAR the best restaurant on the beach!!
Tim DraperOctober 10, 2014
Tried the Chicken Coco Loco, definitely something to get when you visit
Desiree ColonnaJune 19, 2015
Don't even look at the menu. Just get the fish tacos. You can thank me later...
Tony ChangAugust 4, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Try the Cayman Conch Fritters - cayman conch fritters (via @Foodspotting)
Brian RennJuly 4, 2013
Great place for drinks and food and cool people. The real deal!
Jameson BeatesJune 18, 2012
Get the Baja Fish Tacos... Flat Tire is also on tap!
Janell FitchMarch 9, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Best fries! Always get the special and you will never be disappointed
Scott O'ConnorSeptember 15, 2011
Steamed spiced shrimp, coco loco, any tuna special and a cold Pacifico and you cannot go wrong.
Jon hoffmanJune 6, 2014
Really great fish tacos and good beer selection
Caleb HollandJuly 17, 2011
This place is amazing! Fries are great and the chips and salsa are a great alternative too
Melanie GeorgeJuly 14, 2014
Delish Fish Tacos and Coco Loco Chicken :)
Brandon W.August 3, 2011
Coco Loco Chicken (coconut breaded chicken breast with black beans, rice & a killer lime sauce) is the bomb!
Carey SullivanAugust 20, 2011
Great place to eat anytime, kid friendly. Quiet and full of locals in the off season.
travis oastAugust 21, 2011
Was pretty good. Little tight on the inside if it is packed and it will be packed. I would go again.
Angela A.October 3, 2014
Been here 10+ times
The tomato clam bisque is heavenly!
Aaron RashOctober 30, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Baja fish tacos with tuna is the best ever... Everything here is awesome

1 2 3

269 Photos

Tortuga's Lie

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Tortuga's Lie

Appears on 96 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.