Eddie and Sam's Pizza
Pizzeria$$$$
Tampa
This pizzeria is famous for their pizza. It's one of the most popular in the city!
"Truly the best NY style pizza in Tampa"(7 Tips)
"Best NYC style pizza in the Bay area, maybe the state of Florida.."(12 Tips)
"The pizza is the best in tampa bay!!"(4 Tips)
"lasagna pizza is so delicious"(6 Tips)
See what your friends are saying about Eddie and Sam's Pizza.
By creating an account you are able to follow friends and experts you trust and see the places they’ve recommended.
orSign up with email
92 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- tampa bay
- gelato
- casual
- lively
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Raffaele RuggieroMay 7, 2016Phenomenal pizza !! I grew up in the Bronx with 4 pizzerias in the neighborhood. Believe this is authentic NY pizza and better!
Upvote7Downvote
Karen GrahnMay 28, 2013the garlic knots are good, and big. the 20" can easily feed 4 people. I'm from NY, and it's easily with in my top 5 pizza places. If i lived closer i'd go back, (and gain a hellof alot of weight) :)Upvote4Downvote
Ca BaApril 6, 2015I like the white pizza (Bianca) and the veggie pizza, always have a hard time deciding between the two. Love stopping here for a quick slice or two or ordering a pie to go. Best pizza aroundUpvote1Downvote- Karen GrahnMay 28, 2013their garlic knots are big, and good. we got a Lasagna pizza got a 20in. it could've fed 4 people easily. a good place to go to. I'm from NY, it was amazing pizza.. :) I'd definitely go back :)Upvote2Downvote
- J BarnettMay 11, 2017Best NYC style pizza in the Bay area, maybe the state of Florida.. They truck in real NY state spring water and NY state flour for the crust!!UpvoteDownvote
Heather NelsonMarch 3, 2016You want real deal NY pizza...this is the place to come...the biggest pies and slices, you can't go wrong.
Upvote1Downvote
Vernon JonesJanuary 14, 2016Pizza was very good and garlic knots were very good. So the family and I will definitely be going back again soon! 👍👍👍UpvoteDownvote
I'm from Long Island ,I consider myself a pizza purist. The water as simple as it sounds makes a huge difference.The simple atmosphere ,extraordinary pizza is a slice right out of the Big Apple!Upvote6Downvote
Kathy LoveDecember 18, 2011Coming from a Brooklyn girl, this is the best pizza Tampa Bay has to offer. It 99% NY flavor! The garlic knots are massive and delicious...best part they're only 50 cents!Upvote3Downvote
What makes their Pizza the best New York Style is their water. They have water shipped from the New York Springs. That is what makes the dough so tasty and just right!!Upvote1Downvote- Heather NelsonFebruary 13, 2016Best NY Style pizza in Tampa. This place is a treasure, I love NY style pizza. And their XL...it's HUGE!UpvoteDownvote
Get their special! 2 slices of cheese and a drink for $5.99. Such great pizza, nice space and always friendly staff. Best pizza in Tampa!Upvote3Downvote
Nelson IrizarryDecember 21, 2014The pizza is the best. Im in Riverview we take a special trip just to go and stuff our faces.. The staff very friendly☺UpvoteDownvote
Pretty close to an average slice NY pizza, definitely fun to have while in Tampa. Get the chicken parm slice 👌UpvoteDownvote
Todd WicknerFebruary 18, 2020The last two times I can’t say that I enjoyed my pizza. Had the eggplant parm which was only like warm and a sausage and pepperoni that was soaked with grease.UpvoteDownvote
Kevin KrauterJanuary 30, 2016It's very good pizza and it's reasonable price. Kind of reminds me of a NY City type restaurant.UpvoteDownvote
Seriously good NY style pizza. Lots of choices and gelato in the same building! What's better?Upvote2Downvote
Albert VidalApril 20, 2013This place brings the heat! Easily the best pizza in Tampa. The garlic knots are unbelievable. So is everything else...Upvote1Downvote
All the desserts are top notch including the chocolate peanut butter cream pie, gelato, and cannoli.Upvote1Downvote
Ceci TricoliNovember 3, 2016Lasagna slices are out of this world! Best pizza in all of Tampa Bay!UpvoteDownvote
Drew CoffmanMarch 20, 2015Grab a couple of slices of a classic like pepperoni and grab a soda from their Coke Freestyle machines.UpvoteDownvote
Pizza by the slice, huge slices. All that we tried were delicious.UpvoteDownvote
Susan BuchananJune 16, 2019Best pizza we’ve had since moving to Tampa and away from Matas pizzaUpvoteDownvote
- Dee EvansNovember 24, 2018Literally everything is good here. Never had a pizza I didn't like hereUpvoteDownvote
Kimberley AsanteJuly 4, 2014Freaking amazing pizza.. Garlic knots were bigger than my face. Extremely satisfied!UpvoteDownvote
Brotha K.September 1, 2013Cheese and pepperoni is the choice you should make. Garlic knots are big for price.UpvoteDownvote
RobJune 15, 2013Oh my goodness! The Gelato is amazinggggggg. Strawberry Chip was deliciousUpvote1Downvote
Danielle PAugust 26, 2013Garlic knots are huge! And only pizza around Tampa that can compare to ny pizzaUpvoteDownvote
Ryan CarrollJanuary 22, 2015Who gives a F where they import their water from!? Great Za!!!!Upvote1Downvote
Albizu AcevedoApril 27, 2012One of the best NY Pizzerias in the Tampa Bay Area(toss up between them and Paci's)UpvoteDownvote
Katie GisonniNovember 26, 2015The white pizza here is AMAZING and the pieces are giantUpvoteDownvote
Great Pizza and Spag. & Meatballs. I don't just eat any spaghetti neither.Upvote1Downvote
Lizzy GravelleJune 6, 2014Got the tv by the television... And was watching tv... But really great pizza place!!!UpvoteDownvote
Lasagna pizza and the campfire gelatoUpvoteDownvote
223 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Tue–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(813) 229-8500
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Parking
Street, Public Lot
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Eddie and Sam's Pizza
- 9.3
"Always something going on when the weather is fair, playground for kids and large field for sports with friends. Community yoga on sunday afternoons."
Kaitlyn Watson - 9.3
"Great service and seating. Beautiful, gorgeous place! Great for a night alone or on a date!"
Carolyn Reid - 9.2
"Saw rent here had orchestra seats, very good view. Quite intimate seating. The venue itself is quite beautiful, if a bit small. Just enough space in the lobby very few concessions stands/bars"
Nae Hinton
Appears on 100 lists
Created by justen f
22 items • 4 followers
Created by Ross
104 items • 7 followers
Carlos Eats Downtown Tampa Dining Guide
Created by Carlos Eats
10 items • 9 followers
