I must agree with the others, best chicken tikka masala in the city. If you like garlic, the garlic naan is a plus to dip in the leftover sauce. BTW they do not serve alcohol.
Tied for 1st w/LK for most authentic + rich Indian/Pakistani food in the city. Perfect amount of spices. The dhaal, kofta, makhani, all YUM. Also, they offer brain masala on their menu.
Last night there was a small bent metal NAIL or staple in my okra. I had gotten takeout. Luckily I saw it. Needless to say this was my last of many happy visits to Shalimar.
RUDE AND OFFENSIVE We tried to reserve a table over the phone before closing time. They told us that they were closed once we got there 20 minutes before. DON'T BOTHER MAKING THE SAME MISTAKE WE MADE!