Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Planning a trip to Tampa?
Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.
Yoder's Restaurant
American Restaurant, Bakery, and Pie Shop$$$$
Sarasota
Ranked #2 for American restaurants in Sarasota
"Peanut Butter Pie!!!!!!! Simply the BEST ever!!!!!!!"(15 Tips)
"Also save room for pie - strawberry rhubarb is amazing."(3 Tips)
"My favorite is the Butterscotch banana cream pie."(3 Tips)
"Chicken fried steak and hraby was awesome."(5 Tips)
123 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pies
- breakfast food
- desserts
- casual
- room for pie
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Kim DavisAugust 6, 2016Their broasted chicken and famous peanut butter pie made Man vs Food's Sarasota episode! Closed on Sunday, of course. Produce stand is also great.Upvoted 4 weeks ago
patrice fabregueAugust 21, 2015Everything! Had the chopped steak with fries and cole slaw. The chopped steak tasted like steak not a fancy burger. I go once a week, and never go wrong. Stay away from the deserts they are addictive.
Eric HessDecember 31, 2017The food is amazing. Amish cooking at a great price with large portion sizes. If you have a small appetite start with desert first. The rubarb & stawberry and apple pies are great.
Erich KJuly 4, 2016This is as close to great home cooking away from home as you can get! Very reasonably priced and save room for dessert. The pies are out of this world!
My favorite is the beefsteak w/mashed potatoes & gravy and carrot salad. The strawberry rhubarb pie is to die for. Food here never ever disappoints!!- Maggie McGinnisDecember 22, 2016Everything is good. Fresh made on premises from salad dressings to pies. My favorite is the Butterscotch banana cream pie. Sooo good.
We had Fried Chicken and Meatloaf. Food was warm and tasty. Excellent service. Loved Key Lime pie.
Anders SjöstedtNovember 3, 2012Come hungry, prepare to wait in line. Fairly authentic Amish ladies (who all seem to favor Reeboks) will bring you piles of prime comfort food. Marvel at the Amish chick-flick books by the entrance!
Deborah FrancoApril 28, 2018All the entrees are delicious. They have a well deserved reputation for awesome desserts. An elderly Mr Yoder functions as a door ban when the restaurant is busy.
Kyra KilianApril 9, 2023Fried chicken and Amish noodles are really good. The mashed potatoes and gravy are also really good. DH did not care for the Amish potato pancakes- Anders SjöstedtDecember 26, 2012A central gathering point for Sarasota's Amish population (yes). Come hungry, as plates of meat loaf and apple pie are HUGE. Marvel at the Amish romance books in the shop. Who knew? Prepare to queue.
Phillip W.August 3, 2013When homesick for the great culinary delicacies of Pennsylvania, Yoder's provides a quick mouthful of resolve with the familiar tastes of home. Everything made from scratch as it should be.
Robin JozaitisJanuary 27, 2014Eat like a local! You get SO much food! No reservations taken ....so either get here early or wait in line. It's totally worth the wait.- Cameron BorrielloDecember 30, 2015Try the southern fried steak or the fried chicken - the Yoder's sauce is great. Also save room for pie - strawberry rhubarb is amazing.
Mike HildrethApril 12, 2013Ya gotta love a place that has homemade Apple Butter in a squeeze bottle right on the tables!! Outstanding! Food is out of his world!
Deb PaigeApril 4, 2013You can't go wrong with anything on the menu here. THad to get our pie "to-go", for later. The Whoopie pies are equally amazing and delicious!
Travel ChannelNovember 7, 2011Their homemade cherry, shoofly, and peanut butter cream pies are must-haves! As seen on Travel Channel’s Man v. Food Nation.
Larry - Magician - Realtor - real estate investor MasonOctober 26, 2012If you like pies you'll LOVE Yoders. If you can afford the calories, buy a whole pie to take with you. One of the reasons why locals call Sarasota paradise!
Melisa RoyNovember 2, 2013Delicious strawberry cream pie&grilled garlic chicken,Bad meatloaf. Don't bring anyone who loves to add eggs to a meal unless it is breakfast time they refused to make an egg at dinner..REALLY ;( why?
Johnathan WilliamsFebruary 20, 2017Chocolate-peanut butter pie, fried chicken, sweet tea, pie, chocolate cake, baked goods, fried chicken BLT
Have a great breskfast, quickly if you need to go and prices are low plus your plate is more than full!!! You have to have lunch or dinner here and be sure to ask for daily specials because the YODER'- John KNovember 20, 2014Love the fried chicken....Shoofly pie like my mom used to make....also love the blueberry crumb top pie!
Lynda Judevine LeslieFebruary 9, 2016A quaint cozy Amish restaurant go for the broasted chicken but save room for the amazing pie!
April CApril 13, 2012Oh my.... Their pies are amazing! Had the Yoder's Key Lime & the Peanut Butter. So good. They are super creamy with mounds of fresh whipped cream!
Tony HartzellNovember 24, 2018The outside seating is pretty great, if you don't care about our planet.
Seth Maw-NaingMarch 24, 2012After their large entre portions, try a pie taster portion there and a full slice to go. You als get to try more flavors that way.
Nicole NelsonMarch 13, 2013Get the fresh veggies Benedict, it's incredible! Ask for hollandaise on the side though. The mom's sweet roll is to die for!
Derek MarcosNovember 26, 2013Chicken and dumplings were to die for. Make sure to save room for dessert. Try the banana cream pie!!
barbie princessMarch 20, 2013YES! The pies REALLY ARE that GOOD! The line is wrapped around the building at 4:30 on a Wednesday afternoon!
Kayla AnFebruary 24There pies, corn bread muffins, homemade bread and mashed potato’s and noodles are fantastic
Lola JuarezDecember 15, 2014The best cooking, no main entree is over $18.00 the food is great, service is top rate, famous for their chicken.- Walter SchneiderJuly 19, 2015Chicken fried steak and hraby was awesome. Mom's egg custard pie for dessert. Yummy!
- Deborah FrancoApril 28, 2018All the entrees are delicious. The desserts are fabulous. Portions are large.
Make sure to save room for the famous & delicious pies! Peanut butter cream pie was featured on Man vs. Food tv show
The sticky bun is insanely good. Share it if you want to eat anything else.
I always always get the egg custard pie but I'm trying blueberry tonight.
Crystal MartinMay 18, 2012My Great Uncle Amos is the best host! Awesome food, amazing pies, and great service! ;)- Kayla SchultzJuly 7, 2010This is a family-owned Amish restaurant, marketplace, etc. The food portions are supposed to be HUGE and they are rumored to have the best pie on the planet. Sign me up!
Love the baked chicken on Saturdays. Ask for a side of cranberry to go with it. It's like Thanksgiving.
328 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 6:00 AM Monday (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 6:00 AM–8:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 6:00 AM–9:00 PM
(941) 955-7771
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 8.3
"Get the Bone In Ribeye and the house made Worcestershire"
Broc Smith - 8.0
"Enjoy a casual meal including many different sandwiches and burgers. Nice site on bay to watch sunset and boat traffic."
Derek Hoffer - 7.7
"Great upscale pub food. Def don't miss happy hour everyday and $5 burger Mondays for a great deal. Also, open later than many places in the area."
Annie Alfstad
Appears on 156 lists
Travel Channel 101 Tastiest Places
Created by Jason Gilmore
103 items • 32 followers
Created by Foursquare City Guide
50 items • 221 followers
Created by Travel Channel
69 items • 1,856 followers