Daniel G. • July 20, 2022O atendimento é cordial e rápido. Recomendável fazer reserva antes. A pizza Colony é bem apimentada.
Polina W. • December 30, 2023One of the best pizzas in the village. Usually has a line, but it moves quickly.
Carlos • May 30, 2016Authentic and genuine pizza bar. Great, awesome, but they are not the best pizzeria.
Jon M. • May 26, 2019Great pizzeria in a lovely neighbourhood. Nothing fancy, just real good pizza 🍕
I K. • March 25, 2023As of 2023, this is the best pizza in NYC. The crust is perfect, thin, slightly burned, the cheese is incredible. I rarely order a Margarita pizza and this time we did - so, so good!
Eric A. • March 17, 2023Very delicious pizza!!!! Chicago style but not deep dish - Tavern thin crust is their specialty
Serious Eats • March 14, 2013We love the plain slice, the fresh mozz Nonna, and the square Grandma slice. An icon of New York's classic pizza culture.
Brian M. • February 13, 2015Cute little pizzeria with great pizzas
Megan M. • June 6, 2018This pizza is on the same level (if not better) than the pizza I had when I was in Italy. Delicious!!!
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.