Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Reloading results...

Suggestions for New American Restaurant near Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn

Filters:
    • 8.3
      New American$$$$View Menu
      72 Henry St (Orange St at Henry St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • M T.

        M T. • March 15, 2015Excellent service, penne lobster rich and creamy goodness, goat cheese salad delish, crab cakes amazing, and fried chicken has a hint of cinnamon- not my cup of tea but pretty good.

    • 7.8
      New American$$$$
      185 Atlantic Ave (btwn Court & Clinton St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Annabelle E.

        Annabelle E. • November 24, 2016We loooved the octopus, lasagnette, sea bass and cocktails! Plus the deconstructed cheesecake which was gluten-free

    • 8.9
      New American$$$$View Menu
      1 Water St (at Brooklyn Bridge), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Miguel

        Miguel • May 24, 2014They have the perfect formula to make your tastebuds dance. Great atmosphere. Great food. Go for the oysters and salmon app to start

    • 7.9
      New American$$$$View Menu
      55 Water St, New York
      Save
      • Jan R.

        Jan R. • June 23, 2019Chillout area made for me

    • 8.9
      New American$$$$View Menu
      320 Atlantic Ave (btwn Hoyt & Smith St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • F. B.

        F. B. • July 29, 2015Distinctive, seasonal food. Friendly service. Gorgeous garden. Solid cocktails. Not too pricey. Open all day. An all around classic.

    • 8.0
      New American$$$$
      252 Schermerhorn St (at Bond St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Rajat

        Rajat • September 11, 2022very surprised by the lamb ribs. Delicious!!

    • 9.3
      New American$$$$
      28 Liberty St (btwn Nassau St & William St), New York
      Save
      • Amanda R.

        Amanda R. • October 29, 2018Great addition to Fidi! Food was amazing. Gratuity already included. Must get the vanilla soufflé! Views are incredible from both sides.

    • 8.0
      New American$$$$
      215 Columbia St, Brooklyn
      Save
      • Lina Y.

        Lina Y. • December 19, 2023Excellent double smash patty burger and fries!

    • 8.1
      New American
      364 Atlantic Ave (btwn Hoyt & Bond St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Brad K.

        Brad K. • February 27, 2022Fun vibes, friendly bartenders, great draft list, specialty cheese dog (basically gourmet pig in blanket) is amazing. New local spot!

    • 9.0
      New American$$$$View Menu
      138 Division St, New York
      Save
      • Alissa W.

        Alissa W. • October 25, 2013After careful review of the LES, this might be my new go to. Amazing fries, quesadillas & a nice spicy margarita. Don't miss this hidden gem!

    • 7.3
      New American$$$$View Menu
      11 Fulton St, New York
      Save
      • Paige K.

        Paige K. • December 22, 2017Very impressed! The food was amazing and the vibe was fun. A bit loud though. Spicy Calamari is the best I’ve ever had

    • 8.5
      New American$$$$View Menu
      166 Dekalb Ave (at Cumberland St), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Lucy M.

        Lucy M. • April 24, 2014The chicken and waffles are worth the fuss. Great oysters too.

    • 7.1
      New American$$$$View Menu
      213 Front St (btwn Beekman St & Peck Slip), New York
      Save
      • Rebecca M.

        Rebecca M. • July 30, 2015Great fried fish! Staff is very friendly as well.

    • ?
      New American$$$$
      1 Old Fulton St (at Pier 1 Gatehouse), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Ian T.

        Ian T. • August 31, 2011Ask for the watermelon gazpacho. It is a tasty and mildly spicy treat.

    • 7.2
      New American$$$$View Menu
      88 5th Ave (btwn Prospect & St. Marks Pl), Brooklyn
      Save
      • Paul

        Paul • September 18, 2012The skirt steak with mashed sweet potato and sautéed garlic. So good. Simple salmon next time.

    • 7.1
      New American$$$$View Menu
      2 West St (at Battery Pl.), New York
      Save
      • The Corcoran Group

        The Corcoran Group • March 18, 2011Excellent service and magnificent food. You must try the Mac ‘n Cheese. Other worthy options are the Lobster Bisque, Crab Cake and Tuna Tartare.

    • 5.9
      New American$$$$
      78 South St (Pier 15), New York
      Save
      • christina m.

        christina m. • June 1, 2013Tough opening night but they made up for it in free cocktails. Watermelon press cocktail great, tasty hot dog with bacon. Will give it some time to settle in but welcome addition to the neighborhood.

    • 6.1
      New American$$$$
      42 Broadway, New York
      Save
      • Brittney P.

        Brittney P. • November 26, 2019In and out during lunch rush. Nice variety for food selection. I did build your own salad with shrimp, corn, avocado, cheese, with balsamic. Husband had their chicken Alfredo pasta. We were pleased!

    • Category icon
      ?
      New American$$$$
      138 Willoughby St, Brooklyn
      Save
    • 5.6
      New American$$$$
      19 Fulton St (Front St), New York
      Save
      • Brian P.

        Brian P. • September 6, 2020dog-friendly, socially distanced, provides masks, hand sanitizer, no-touch menus, contactless payments. Spicy Caesar, Shrimp Po’Boy, Strawberry Rum Punch, and Lavender Lemonade— all were delicious.

    • Category icon
      ?
      New American$$$$
      126 Pearl Street, New York
      Save
    • ?
      New American$$$$
      9 Chatham Sq, New York
      Save
      • Cole K.

        Cole K. • November 16, 2024Such a gorgeous space. Everyone is ordering the comté tarte and smoked eel dumplings, as should you, but don’t skip the cured tuna or tête a cochon, either!

    • 4.4
      New American$$$$View Menu
      89 South St (at Broadway & Church), New York
      Save
      • celia c.

        celia c. • September 14, 2011$5 Frozen Drink specials - $4 Draft Beers

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.