Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

1. Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

8.7
70 E Main St (Shore Lane), Bay Shore, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 28 tips and reviews

Danielle B.Danielle Beige: Blood orange margarita, guacamole, tacos, brussel sprout quest fundido

Tellers: An American Chophouse is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

2. Tellers: An American Chophouse

8.8
605 Main St, Islip, NY
Steakhouse · 27 tips and reviews

Allan S.Allan S: Zagat rated & vallet parking. What a great combination!!!

Tula Kitchen is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

3. Tula Kitchen

8.9
41 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Gina R.Gina Rose: best vegan food on long island!

Tullulah's is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

4. Tullulah's

8.5
12 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY
Tapas Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews

ericeric: This is the best place in bay shore, hands down. 13 beers on draft. Two wines. Out door sitting garden... I'm in love.

O-Co-Nee East Diner is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

5. O-Co-Nee East Diner

8.6
749 Main St (Islip Ave.), Islip, NY
Diner · 51 tips and reviews

Evan P.Evan Peoples: BEST DINER ON LONG ISLAND

Verace Restaurant is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

6. Verace Restaurant

599 Main St (Willow Ave.), Islip, NY
Italian Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Delicious cheeses and cured meats, pizzas, salads, panini and pastas such as baked stuffed shells, maltagliati Bolognese, ravioli stuffed with beef short rib, and spaghetti with house-made meatballs.

Aji 53 is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

7. Aji 53

8.5
53 E Main St (at 4th Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Japanese Restaurant · 50 tips and reviews

Natalie S.Natalie S: Paradise Roll is amazing!

Pie At Salvatore's is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

8. Pie At Salvatore's

8.1
120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Italian Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

Steve F.Steve Fog: Best pizza in Bay Shore.

Local Burger is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

9. Local Burger

8.1
62 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Burger Joint · 23 tips and reviews

Diana C.Diana Caronti-Levine: Love the quinoa burger and truffle fries. We also had the red zone burger and pulled pork sandwich. Service was excellent

fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

10. fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro

8.0
28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 28 tips and reviews

carolyn b.carolyn bos: Tuna tartar, smoked salmon and avocado salad and Mediterranean soup was outstanding. One of the best dirty martinis I've had in a while.

H20 is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

11. H20

7.9
166 W Main St, East Islip, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 4 tips and reviews

Lynn B.Lynn Bednar-Rando: Shrimp and lobster wontons, cinnamon coffee cake, seafood hash was amazing and the crab cake eggs bene was the best I’ve ever had, corn flake crusted bananas foster French toast..

The Lake House is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

12. The Lake House

7.6
135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY
New American Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

Bob C.Bob Clifton: Duck was delicious

Nickys On The Bay is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

13. Nickys On The Bay

7.5
Bayshore Marina, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

Mo K.Mo K: Newly renovated and reopened. There's a gorgeous view from that second story deck addition.

Kumo Sushi Hibachi & Lounge is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

14. Kumo Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

7.9
33 E Main St (Main Street), Bay Shore, NY
Asian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

CJ G.CJ Gleeson: Another great dinner Cucumber roll , Godzilla Roll and Yellowtail Jalapeño Roll

15. Salt & Barrel

8.3
61 W Main St (Park Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 4 tips and reviews

Ron H.Ron Hsu: The lobster pot pie is pretty amazing

Mitsui Japanese Restaurant is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

16. Mitsui Japanese Restaurant

7.6
1 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Sushi Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Shan S.Shan S: Try the dragon and butterfly rolls. Delicious.

Captain Bill's is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

17. Captain Bill's

7.9
122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY
Seafood Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Tim O.Tim ORourke: Excellent clams and oysters

Vinnie's Mulberry Street is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

18. Vinnie's Mulberry Street

7.2
42 W Main St, East Islip, NY
Pizzeria · 13 tips and reviews

Megan N.Megan N.: Hands down favorite Italian on south shore

Corks & Taps is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

19. Corks & Taps

7.6
53 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Bar · Bay Shore, NY · 10 tips and reviews

Travis B.Travis Buonocore: The food and drink selection is only surpassed by the excellent service. Highly recommended; either for a mellow place to unwind or a large gathering to celebrate. Amazing!!

Changing Times is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

20. Changing Times

7.7
29 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY
Sports Bar · 20 tips and reviews

George R.George Raab: Best bar/sports bar im bay shore. Always a good time. The bartenders are great and sociable. I always have a great times

Pico Tequila Grill is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

21. Pico Tequila Grill

7.6
19 W Main St (4th Ave), Bay Shore, NY
Mexican Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Check out Pico's Tequila Grill for a carne asada "street" taco with grilled beef, salsa verde, onion and cheese. Read more.

Treme is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

22. Treme

553 Main St, Islip, NY
Jazz and Blues Venue · 11 tips and reviews

Jimmy S.Jimmy Seibert: The service, the atmosphere, and the drinks are amazing. Everything a 10 out of 10

Maxwell's is one of Bay Shore & Islip Restaurants.

23. Maxwell's

6.6
501 Main Street (Grant Ave), Islip, NY
Sports Bar · 16 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: THE DEAL: Food is buffet or sit-down dinner. With house wine and draft beer: $31.95 Sun-Thurs, $36.95 Fri-Sat. With 3-hour open bar: $38.95 Sun-Thurs, $43.95 Fri-Sat. Read more.