Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Western NY Haunted Sites
The Winery at Marjim Manor is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

1. The Winery at Marjim Manor

8.0
7171 Lake Rd, Appleton, NY
Winery · 9 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: This winery was featured on the television series "Ghost Hunters" and on the Travel Channel series "Most Terrifying Places in America".

Cozumel Grill is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

2. Cozumel Grill

153 Elmwood Ave (at North St), Buffalo, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Allen · 14 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Say hi to Angelo, the ghost who supposedly haunts this site.

Roycroft Inn is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

3. Roycroft Inn

8.7
40 S Grove St (Main St), East Aurora, NY
American Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: The Roycroft Campus has a local reputation as a haunted site and is often featured on ghost tours.

Ghostlight Theatre is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

4. Ghostlight Theatre

7.1
170 Schenck St, North Tonawanda, NY
Theater · 4 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: If you walk into the basement (staircase behind the pews, under the balcony) and all the way to the back, there's a bulletin board with pictures and history of the theater's haunted reputation.

USS The Sullivans is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

5. USS The Sullivans

Buffalo Naval Park, Buffalo, NY
Boat or Ferry · Waterfront · 2 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: This ship was named after the five Sullivan brothers who were killed in WWII on the same destroyer. Ask about the paranormal experiences reported on this ship.

Buffalo Psychiatric Center is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

6. Buffalo Psychiatric Center

6.1
400 Forest Ave (at Elmwood Ave), Buffalo, NY
Mental Health Clinic · 4 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: The stuff horror movies are made of! Ghost stories abound in this historic building, mostly relating to the historically hideous methods of "curing" mentally ill patients.

St. Mary's School for the Deaf is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

7. St. Mary's School for the Deaf

2253 Main St (at Dewey Ave), Buffalo, NY
Education · Parkside · 2 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: St. Mary's has reportings of ghosts wandering the halls. There are also legends of the old (now broken) bell ringing, though obviously most students don't report hearing that one. Try the ASL classes.

Shea's Performing Arts Center is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

8. Shea's Performing Arts Center

9.3
646 Main St (at W Tupper St), Buffalo, NY
Performing Arts Venue · Central Business District · 49 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Ghost sightings of a white-haired, mustachioed man asking theater-goers "Isn't it magnificent?" - then disappearing. Could it be the ghost of Michael Shea admiring his handiwork?

9. Cold Springs Cemetery

6937 Chestnut Ridge Rd, Lockport, NY
Cemetery · 3 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Legend is that a young female hitchhiker was killed near this site, and her ghost still haunts the cemetery! As with all cemeteries, please respect the site when ghost-hunting.

Devil's Hole State Park is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

10. Devil's Hole State Park

8.4
Niagara Scenic Pkwy, Niagara Falls, NY
State or Provincial Park · 9 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: According to legend, if you remove a rock from this site, you will be CURSED FOREVER! I have mine on my mantel.

Mighty Taco is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

11. Mighty Taco

2309 Eggert Rd (at Sheridan Dr.), Tonawanda, NY
Taco Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: According to several local ghosthunters, the walk-in cooler at this site is haunted with an evil presence. Try the cherry empanadas.

12. Goodleberg Cemetery

11963-12299 Goodleberg Rd, South Wales, NY
Cemetery · 2 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Local reputation as a haunted site, relating to a questionable doctor in the 1800s who buried babies there. Reports: eerie fog, baby footprints, baby ghosts crawling. Plz respect the site.

Christ the King Chapel is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

13. Christ the King Chapel

2001 Main St (at Canisius University), Buffalo, NY
Church · Hamlin Park · 3 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Ghost hunters report unearthly voices in the confessionals and basement of this site.

Kenan Center is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

14. Kenan Center

433 Locust St (at Willow St), Lockport, NY
Event Space · 4 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Visitors and ghost hunters report strange white lights and apparitions.

Lancaster Opera House is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

15. Lancaster Opera House

7.6
21 Central Ave (Clark St), Lancaster, NY
Opera House · 8 tips and reviews
Town of Grand Island is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

16. Town of Grand Island

Grand Island, NY
Town · 3 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Campers & hikers report malicious supernatural experiences on Grand Island, like unearthly growling noises and feelings of doom. Theory is that ancient animals haunt this island. Watch out!

Buffalo Central Terminal is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

17. Buffalo Central Terminal

495 Paderewski Dr, Buffalo, NY
Event Space · Broadway - Fillmore · 8 tips and reviews
KeyBank is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

18. KeyBank

6.1
4467 Main St (at Harlem Rd), Snyder, NY
Bank · No tips or reviews
Fort Niagara State Park is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

19. Fort Niagara State Park

9.0
Route 18F, Youngstown, NY
State or Provincial Park · 6 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Old Fort Niagara abounds with ghost stories, including one about a soldier who literally lost his head in a duel over a woman. Tour guides are happy to fill you in. A great ghost-hunting site!

The Mansion on Delaware Avenue is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

20. The Mansion on Delaware Avenue

7.9
414 Delaware Ave (at Edward St), Buffalo, NY
Hotel · Allen · 12 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Built in 1869, guests & staff at this now-hotel report doors opening & closing by themselves, lights turning on & off. Most prevalent reporting is a "little girl ghost", who often haunts room 406.

Old Fort Niagara is one of Western NY Haunted Sites.

21. Old Fort Niagara

8.3
102 Morrow Plz (in Fort Niagara State Park), Youngstown, NY
Historic and Protected Site · 17 tips and reviews

Courtney I.Courtney I: Most famous for "The Headless Frenchman", killed in a duel over an Iroquois maiden, beheaded and his head thrown into the Niagara River.