Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Real NY style food in Gilbert area.
Prima Pizza is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

1. Prima Pizza

3651 E Baseline Rd, Gilbert, AZ
Pizzeria · Lakeview Village · 8 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: Padro is the real deal. 2 slices and a soda $3.50 at lunch. All he would have to do is put it on a white paper dish and a wax Coke cup and you would think your in NY

Bashas' is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

2. Bashas'

6.1
99 S Higley Rd (at E Elliot Rd), Gilbert, AZ
Grocery Store · 6 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: This is the only place that has wedge rolls with seeds. The loaf bread is real good also. Closest thing to NY. This is also the ONLY place that can slice cold cuts thin and layer them like in NY.

Sprouts Farmers Market is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

3. Sprouts Farmers Market

8.8
2582 S Val Vista Dr (at E Williams Field Rd), Gilbert, AZ
Farmers Market · Spectrum at Val Vista · 14 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: Sausage!!! Fresh made every day!! Most ties it is on sale for $2.99.And wile you are there, get some peppers and onions for wedges!

Jimmy's of Chicago is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

4. Jimmy's of Chicago

884 E Williams Field Rd Ste 102 (Williams Field and Lindsay), Gilbert, AZ
Italian Restaurant · 42 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: Even though they are from Chicago, and the pizza sucks, the food is the real deal! The Alfredo ROCKS!Stuffed mushrooms to die for! Stuffed with a mix of cheese, spices and sirloin!

Baci Italian Bistro is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

5. Baci Italian Bistro

8.1
8830 E Germann Rd, Mesa, AZ
Italian Restaurant · 24 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: This is another non "COMMERCIAL ITALIAN OUT OF THE BAG" restaurant. The people are great! Like family!Italian ricotta cheesecake to die for!

Crazy Buffet is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

6. Crazy Buffet

1859 S Stapley Dr #101 (NE Corner Stapley & Baseline), Mesa, AZ
Chinese Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: Pot stickers! Closest to NY! Clean!! The even have "Duck Sauce"

AJ's Fine Foods is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

7. AJ's Fine Foods

8.4
1836 S Val Vista Dr (at E Baseline Rd), Mesa, AZ
Grocery Store · 31 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: Great Bakery items! Bagels like NY (or close)You can get specialty Italian items including San Marazano tomatoes from Italy and even a Panatone!

BoSa Donuts is one of Real NY style food in Gilbert area..

8. BoSa Donuts

1016 N Arizona Ave (at E Ray Rd), Chandler, AZ
Donut Shop · 14 tips and reviews

David M.David Mitchell: Kick Ass!! enough said........