Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
The best of the Eatontown area
Kanji is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

1. Kanji

8.4
980 Shrewsbury Ave (State Route 35), Tinton Falls, NJ
Japanese Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: If you're looking for dinner and a show - literally - try sitting at the hibachi table. Hibachi is available at the regular tables as well.

The Americana Diner is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

2. The Americana Diner

7.5
1160 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ
Diner · 28 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Easily the best place in the area for breakfast. You won't go home hungry.

Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

3. Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream

8.1
462 Shrewsbury Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 16 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Warning: very addicting. The flavors change regularly and are made fresh daily. Best ice cream joint in the area.

Ruby Tuesday is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

4. Ruby Tuesday

Rt 35 At Wyckoff Rd (at Monmouth Mall), Eatontown, NJ
American Restaurant · 11 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Free refills on their teas and lemonades. Highly recommend the rasberry iced tea.

Salt Creek Grille is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

5. Salt Creek Grille

8.0
4 Bingham Ave, Rumson, NJ
Seafood Restaurant · 44 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Pricy, but worth it. Never had a dish here I didn't enjoy. Watermelon salad is an amazing starter.

6. Five Guys

7.6
747 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ
Burger Joint · 13 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Everything is made to order. If you don't ask for it, it won't be on your burger!

7. Sal's Original Deli

1075 Shrewsbury Ave., Shrewsbury, NJ
Deli · 6 tips and reviews

Johnny M.Johnny Mac: Try the Turkey London Broil!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

8. The Cheesecake Factory

8.7
3710 US Highway 9 (at Freehold Mall), Freehold, NJ
American Restaurant · 66 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Huge portions! Expect to take leftovers home ;)

9. Mumford's Culinary Center

8.5
33 Apple St, Tinton Falls, NJ
New American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: A nice local place. Small and cozy. Give their breakfast a try.

Lusty Lobster is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

10. Lusty Lobster

7.7
88 Bay Ave (Kay Street), Highlands, NJ
Seafood Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Need fresh seafood? Unless you catch it yourself, it doesn't get more fresh than this. Come early for the best selection.

11. Rook Coffee

8.8
705 Branch Ave (Sycamore Ave), Little Silver, NJ
Coffee Shop · 19 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: If you're catching the train, this location doesn't get much better. If you want to try what the locals drink, this is one of their rapidly increasing locations.

12. Teak

8.4
64 Monmouth St, Red Bank, NJ
Japanese Restaurant · 43 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: For a different take on sushi, try Teak. Reservations are highly recommended, as are sunglasses. No blinds/shades inside.

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard is one of The best of the Eatontown area.

13. Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

6.6
76C Highway 35, Eatontown, NJ
Ice Cream Parlor · 8 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: If ice cream from Ryan's isn't your thing, try the ice at Rita's. Flavors change daily. However, they are not open year-round like Ryan's.

14. Sickles Market

8.9
1 Harrison Ave (Rumson Rd), Little Silver, NJ
Market · 19 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Pricier than some of the nearby chain markets, but the quality is often worth it. Come early as it gets very crowded on weekends!

15. Wegmans

9.2
1104 State Route 35, Ocean Township, NJ
Supermarket · 43 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Weber: Wegmans isn't your typical grocery store and its layout and selection reflects that. It can get just as crowded as the Costco down the street so come early and grab a pre-made lunch while you're here.