20 favorite restaurants

1. Gemelli Fine Foods

8.6

115 E Main St, Babylon, NY

Grocery Store · 13 tips and reviews

Catherine Pappas: For dessert, try their flourless chocolate cake. Fantastic!

Southside Fish & Clam is one of 20 favorite restaurants.

2. Southside Fish & Clam

8.0

395 W Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY

Seafood Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

Catherine Pappas: The Fisherman's Combo is the best on the menu!

Beachtree Restaurant is one of 20 favorite restaurants.

3. Beachtree Restaurant

166 W Main St (at Suffolk Ln), East Islip, NY

American Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

Catherine Pappas: Perfect place to host events!

The Sea Grille is one of 20 favorite restaurants.

4. The Sea Grille

290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY

Seafood Restaurant · 4 tips and reviews

Catherine Pappas: Delicious seafood!

Gurney's Montauk Resort and Seawater Spa is one of 20 favorite restaurants.

5. Gurney's Montauk Resort and Seawater Spa

8.9

290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY

Hotel · 46 tips and reviews

Catherine Pappas: A perfect place to getaway for the weekend. Beautiful spa and seaside activities for the entire family and gorgeous night dining!

Milk and Sugar Cafe is one of 20 favorite restaurants.

6. Milk and Sugar Cafe

49 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY

Café · 36 tips and reviews

Catherine Pappas: A wonderful environment for the whole family! Plus, they have exciting weekly events. Tuesdays-Thursdays offer a three course meal and wine tasting!!