Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Must-visit Pizza Places in Milwaukee

Must-visit Pizza Places in Milwaukee

Creator Avatar
Created by Alicia B. • Updated On: February 7, 2012
Classic Slice is one of Must-visit Pizza Places in Milwaukee.

1. Classic Slice

9.0
2797 S Kinnickinnic Ave (at S California St), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Bay View · 74 tips and reviews

kimberly j.kimberly j.: Ridiculously amazing slices of pizza Prehistoric sized portions. Worth the drive and the wait. Yum!!

Rustico Pizzeria is one of Must-visit Pizza Places in Milwaukee.

2. Rustico Pizzeria

223 N Water St (at Chicago St), Milwaukee, WI
Wine Bar · Historic Third Ward · 56 tips and reviews

Brittany F.Brittany Farina: Happy Hour Specials 1/2 off drinks and apps from 4-6 pm

3. Brick 3 Pizza

7.7
1107 N Old World 3rd St (Highland Ave), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Kilbourn Town · 33 tips and reviews

Brian S.Brian Searl: Excellent New York style pizza that actually manages to pull it off.

TransferMKE is one of Must-visit Pizza Places in Milwaukee.

4. TransferMKE

9.1
101 W Mitchell St (at 1st St.), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Clock Tower Acres · 115 tips and reviews

Transfer Pizzeria CafeTransfer Pizzeria Cafe: Check out our Foursquare Offer $5.00 OFF your $20.00 Food bill if you check in at Transfer!

5. Dick's Pizza

5.0
730 N Milwaukee St, Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Juneau Town · 32 tips and reviews

Alicia B.Alicia B.: Three floors of awesomeness!

CRISP Pizza Bar & Lounge is one of Must-visit Pizza Places in Milwaukee.

6. CRISP Pizza Bar & Lounge

1323 E Brady St (btwn N Arlington Pl. & N Warren Ave.), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Lower East Side · 92 tips and reviews

Alicia B.Alicia B.: Order the breadsticks. They are amazing!

Ian's Pizza is one of Must-visit Pizza Places in Milwaukee.

7. Ian's Pizza

8.1
2035 E North Ave (btw Farwell & Prospect), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · Lower East Side · 110 tips and reviews

AugustAugust: The mac'n cheese dude, the mac'n cheese. You need it in your life.

8. Vitucci's Pizza

14185 W Greenfield Ave, New Berlin, WI
Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Alicia B.Alicia B.: A hidden (literally, it's pretty much tucked away on the corner of a shopping center in New Berlin) gem of the Milwaukee area suburbs. Yummy pizza with that home-style feel. Affordable and friendly!

9. Filippo's Pizza

2330 N 124th St (at W North Ave), Milwaukee, WI
Pizzeria · 6 tips and reviews

Alicia B.Alicia B.: The large pizza can feed an army (or at least a very hungry family)! Plus, Filippo's never skimps on the toppings!