- Ranked #3 for pizzerias in St. Augustine
See what your friends are saying about Carmelo's Marketplace.
- pizza
- great value
- casual
- chicken parmigiana
- Caesar salad
- (9 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Amanda C.December 16, 2015This place is great. Ordered a calzone and thought it was a bit pricey..until our food came out. It was HUGE and delicious, had enough left over for two meals at home. Owner is very nice.Upvote2Downvote
- B JacobiApril 20, 2015Best pizza@ worth it price! Always great service though we usually take out. Morphed yet fully functioning gas station in downtown St Aug. A local kind of place. Gotta love it.Upvote2Downvote
- Best pizza EVER! Love the chicken parm dinner..huge portion, you will have leftovers for lunch the next day. .yummmmmUpvoteDownvote
- Best pizza in North Florida and the service is awesome.Upvote4Downvote
- Everything. ..best pizza..and the chicken parm dinner is delish!Upvote2Downvote
- Dorothy HollandJune 26, 2019Pizza was delicious and large slices, but we didn't care for the wings. We ordered "hot" and there was no heat, mostly sweet.UpvoteDownvote
- Charissa FaireApril 15, 2015An update on my previous tip: they stopped doing delivery (last I checked! If they start again, do let me know.)UpvoteDownvote
- Marie PittsJuly 8, 2013You can get full with 2 slices and drink for $10. The food is so fresh and delicious.Upvote3Downvote
- Charissa FaireJanuary 27, 2012Good delivery, *enormous* pizza. And they have green olives as a topping, which is a big selling point for me.Upvote1Downvote
- Charles BargerSeptember 26, 2014Great food no matter what. But the pizzas are the best.Upvote1Downvote
- Get a pepperoni and green olive pizza! So freaking good!Upvote1Downvote
- Best Pizza in St Augustine, great drink selection too.Upvote1Downvote
- Bob CroyleOctober 30, 2011Good pizza..be nice to see the by the slice selection before you pick like other places thoUpvote2Downvote
- Worth going in just to see Big Mack. What a charmer!UpvoteDownvote
- JD BrayFebruary 16, 2010Gotta love a 24-hour gas station with smoothies, hummus, beer, and a restaurant.Upvote4Downvote
- Matt sure is one sexy beast of a cashier.UpvoteDownvote
- Stephen HardisonJune 12, 2011Great pizza but very rude service on the carry out side. Called them twice and both times they were extremely rude and impatient.Upvote3Downvote