Not sure why Foursquare rating is low. I'm like a foodie/food critic basically and I loved the food! Had grilled fish with fettuccine and it was awesome. Maybe a little expensive, but I'm on vacation!
If it's in season, get something that features the grilled fish of the day. It's incredibly fresh, juicy, and tasty, and you can't get any more local than something caught by the fisherman next door!
Cute nautical-decor touches-like fish carved into the chairs-, great view, and excellent fish dishes. The extra-dill tarter sauce and housemadevinaigrette are particularly memorable.
The herringroecaviarappetizer w/ dill sauce and crackers is a home run. Rich, not overly salty, balanced, novel, and legitimately tasty - plus local as it gets. Read more
They do a lot of "interesting" things to be friendly to the environment. Like, smaller cloth napkins, only tap beer, no bottles or cans, recycled boxes for the menus.
You can't go wrong here: fresh, local, sustainable, organic. I highly endorse the Grilled Fish of the Day Dinner with Wild Rice. And the Trout Chowder is exceptional. One of my favorite places to eat.