PxPixel
New York City's Best Piña Coladas
Maison Premiere is one of New York City's Best Piña Coladas.

1. Maison Premiere

9.0
298 Bedford Ave (btwn S 1st & Grand St), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Williamsburg · 447 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Crème de menthe and Mansinthe — a Swiss absinthe with minty elements — round out Maison Premiere's unblended Maison Absinthe Colada. Read more.

Suffolk Arms is one of New York City's Best Piña Coladas.

2. Suffolk Arms

269 E Houston St (at Suffolk St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Alphabet City · 24 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Owner Giuseppe Gonzalez’s legendary take on the piña colada includes a top-off with bitter, red Campari. It’s neither too icy nor too sweet. Read more.

Pouring Ribbons is one of New York City's Best Piña Coladas.

3. Pouring Ribbons

225 Avenue B Fl 2 (btwn 13th & 14th St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Alphabet City · 180 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: The Way of the Warrior combines two kinds of rum, pineapple, vanilla, matcha, and coconut. The addition of a bitter element to this piña colada takes it beyond vacation status. Read more.

Holiday Cocktail Lounge is one of New York City's Best Piña Coladas.

4. Holiday Cocktail Lounge

8.0
75 Saint Marks Pl (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · East Village · 64 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: The nontraditional piña colada, And His Hair Was Perfect, is made with white Caña Brava rum, Kalani coconut liqueur, fresh lime, and pineapple, then served over crushed ice with an Angostura float. Read more.

Donna is one of New York City's Best Piña Coladas.

5. Donna

27 Broadway (at Dunham Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Cocktail Bar · Williamsburg · 92 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: Donna's piña colada is called the Brancolada, because of its inclusion of minty Branca Menta. A hint of orange juice is also blended in with the pineapple, coconut cream, and Appleton rum. Read more.

Nitehawk Cinema is one of New York City's Best Piña Coladas.

6. Nitehawk Cinema

9.4
136 Metropolitan Ave (btwn Berry St & Wythe Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Movie Theater · Williamsburg · 301 tips and reviews

Village VoiceVillage Voice: With pineapple Jarritos, coconut sorbet, and Flor de Caña Silver rum, Nitehawk Cinema's piña colada float is pure vegan indulgence. Read more.