Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

1. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

9.1
5646 E Washington St (at N Audubon Rd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Irvington · 112 tips and reviews

Qatadah N.Qatadah Nasaaj: The eggplant garlic parmesan pizza w/Italian Beef & spinach will make you a believer for life,kids! You SO must try it!!!!!!!

2. South of Chicago Pizza and Beef

619 Virginia Ave (Virginia & College), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Fletcher Place · 43 tips and reviews

Candace N.Candace Nicholson: If you get the deep dish, you'll be full for a week. :-) Seriously, I think it could feed a family of 6 easy.

Bazbeaux Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

3. Bazbeaux Pizza

8.9
329 Massachusetts Ave (at E New York St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 101 tips and reviews

JackalJackal: Get the Tchoupitoulas! Best ever

Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria- 49th and Pennsylvania is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

4. Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria- 49th and Pennsylvania

7.7
114 E 49th St (Pennsylvania), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Meridian Kessler · 33 tips and reviews

Michael T.Michael Tressler: The simple Margherita pizza was better than the pepperoni + prosciutto. Keep it simple!

California Pizza Kitchen at Circle Centre is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

5. California Pizza Kitchen at Circle Centre

49 W Maryland St Ste 104 (at Illinois St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 33 tips and reviews

Qatadah N.Qatadah Nasaaj: Artichoke & spinach pizza, Thai Chicken pizza, veggie pizza with Japanese Eggplant, or the Jerk Chicken pizza... Any of the pizzas here are quite good!

Bebop Pizza Kitchen is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

6. Bebop Pizza Kitchen

6.8
705 E 54th St (at College Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Meridian Kessler · 5 tips and reviews

7. Marco's Pizza

805 West 10th St. (btw University Bl & Paca St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 10 tips and reviews

chuck s.chuck shepherd: Try the BBQ pizza and the lunch buffet is a great deal!

Maria's Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

8. Maria's Pizza

6.8
1106 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Fountain Square · 11 tips and reviews

Thomas H.Thomas Holt: The Sauerkraut Pizza is really good

HotBox Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

9. HotBox Pizza

7.4
30 E Georgia St (at S Scioto St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 13 tips and reviews

Mike M.Mike Magan: The breadsticks MUST be purchased! Make sure to get Cheese AND tomato.

Enzo Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

10. Enzo Pizza

6.9
149 N Illinois St (at Ohio St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 5 tips and reviews

Gregory G.Gregory Goodin: If you are looking for a slice, Enzo is the place to go!

Byrne's Grilled Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

11. Byrne's Grilled Pizza

7.3
5615 N Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Butler - Tarkington · 7 tips and reviews

Qatadah N.Qatadah Nasaaj: They have excellent pizza here! If you see them, should stop and get some.

Pizza di Tito is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

12. Pizza di Tito

7.6
115 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 5 tips and reviews

Patrick F.Patrick Flanagan: Get the 2 slices and a drink deal for $5. Good cheap NYC style pizza. Tito, the owner is there everyday so say Hi. He's a nice guy and cares about his family owned and operates business.

Jet's Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

13. Jet's Pizza

7.2
2464 Lake Circle Dr, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · College Park · 10 tips and reviews

Jay A.Jay Allen: 8 corner pizza is the way to go

Giorgio's Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

14. Giorgio's Pizza

8.1
9 E Market St (at Monument Cir), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 37 tips and reviews

Kaila G.Kaila Garrison: Best lunchtime restaurant on the circle - great NY style pizza and amazing service.

WB Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

15. WB Pizza

6165 Allisonville Rd (62nd St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Eastwood · 15 tips and reviews

Wanda S.Wanda S: Excellent Crostini- toasted rounds of french bread w/spread of finely diced tomatoes, basil,spices & garlic- delish!

Barlo's is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

16. Barlo's

5051 Kentucky Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Valley Mills · 7 tips and reviews

Erin B.Erin B: The Asian Invasion (which has teriyaki chicken) is amazing! Give it a try.

17. Shebella's Pizza & Deli

7035 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Castleton · 1 tip

Julie S.Julie Sawyer: Tasty buffet, coupons on Coupons4Indy.com! Try the NY Giant meat lovers pizza it is amazing.

Donatos Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

18. Donatos Pizza

5.8
825 W 10th St (at University Bl), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 6 tips and reviews

Stuart W.Stuart W.: Chicken strips are good if you aren't wanting pizza.

Jack's Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

19. Jack's Pizza

3709 E Washington St (in Sherman Commons Shopping Center), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Near Southeast · 4 tips and reviews

Qatadah N.Qatadah Nasaaj: Get the Jackpot! You won't be sorry!

ZA Pizzeria is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

20. ZA Pizzeria

801 Broad Ripple Ave (at Carrollton Ave), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Broad Ripple · 13 tips and reviews

Andy C.Andy Cunningham: BBQ Chicken pizza with creme fraiche is staggeringly good!

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

21. Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

8.9
65 E Pearl Street, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 57 tips and reviews

Grant J.Grant Jenkins: Best pizza dt for sure! Great salads and beers too. Awesome ownership.

Magoo's California Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

22. Magoo's California Pizza

8.4
4919 W 38th St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Eagledale · 23 tips and reviews

Chad R.Chad Richards: Try the Chicken Tikka Pizza

Brozinni Pizzeria is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

23. Brozinni Pizzeria

8.7
8810 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · 43 tips and reviews

Douglas K.Douglas Karr: The servings are so big that you may be tempted to eat too much... save room for the cannoli's, though! Read more.

24. Piezanos

5616 Georgetown Rd (62nd), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Snacks - Guion Creek · 3 tips and reviews

Angela E.Angela Emery: Get the taco pizza

25. Puccini's Pizza Pasta

7.8
3944 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Castleton · 11 tips and reviews
Iaria's Italian Restaurant is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

26. Iaria's Italian Restaurant

8.0
317 S College Ave (Btw Lord And Harrison), Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Fletcher Place · 32 tips and reviews

James K.James Kuester: The Around The World pizza is great!

27. Luca Pizza

6020 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Castleton · 1 tip
Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

28. Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta

7.9
7755 E Washington St (at I-465, exit 46), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Raymond Park · 4 tips and reviews

Joshua "LEGO" l.Joshua "LEGO" lohrman: Try the meatlovers with BBQ sauce also the service is great

The NY Slice is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

29. The NY Slice

7.4
(Downtown), Indianapolis, IN
Food Truck · 10 tips and reviews

The NY Slice Pizza TruckThe NY Slice Pizza Truck: Add Sriracha to your slice and make it spicy :)

UNO Pizzeria & Grill is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

30. UNO Pizzeria & Grill

7.8
4740 E Southport Rd, Southport, IN
American Restaurant · 29 tips and reviews

Tamara S.Tamara Sullivan: Try the Pizza Skins...they're fab!

MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

31. MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub

7.7
4939 E 82nd St (Allisonville Rd and 82nd Street), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · 52 tips and reviews

Bob B.Bob Burchfield: Pizza for sure, but also a full service restaurant with scratch kitchen and a wide variety of menu items besides pizza.

Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

32. Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub

8.0
13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy (at Hazel Dell, behind Starbucks), Carmel, IN
Pizzeria · 59 tips and reviews

sara m.sara mcguyer: Go with a group of people so you can try different types of pizza. The crust is holy wow.

Humble Pie is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

33. Humble Pie

Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Near Southside · 2 tips and reviews

Qatadah N.Qatadah Nasaaj: Pepperjack breadsticks!

Some Guys Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

34. Some Guys Pizza

9.2
6235 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Italian Restaurant · Eastwood · 28 tips and reviews

Pete B.Pete B: Basil, meatball, caramelized onion, gouda.. Do it!

New Bethel Ordinary is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

35. New Bethel Ordinary

8.0
8858 Southeastern Ave (Northeastern Avenue), Wanamaker, IN
Pizzeria · 17 tips and reviews

Madison E.Madison Erickson: Amazing pizza great burgers nice place to just sit and relax :)

36. Datsa Pizza

6.6
907 N Pennsylvania St (at E 9th St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · St. Joseph Historic Neighborhood · 11 tips and reviews

Sarah S.Sarah Schmidt: They have the best pizza! If you're looking for something different ask for olive oil instead of pizza sauce:)

Johnny Bueno's Pizzeria is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

37. Johnny Bueno's Pizzeria

1506 Main St, Speedway, IN
Pizzeria · 12 tips and reviews

Brad S.Brad Shoemaker: Best Pizza in the Indy Area. Awesome family owned business and the quality of the ingredients and dough, not to mention they don't skimp on the toppings, is unmatched.

38. Perugini Pizzaria

3350 N High School Rd Ste M (34th Street), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · 2 tips and reviews

Andrew E.Andrew East: Their 5 dollar pizza is A LOT better than Little Caesars. Support a local company. Also the owner is very very nice, talk to him!

39. Sister Leah's Pizzaria

Indianapolis, IN
Café · University Heights · No tips or reviews
Union Jack Pub is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

40. Union Jack Pub

8.3
921 Broad Ripple Ave (at Winthrop Av), Indianapolis, IN
Pub · Broad Ripple · 55 tips and reviews

Jeff F.Jeff Fox: Very good pizza. Love the Pesto pizza.

Aunt Polly's Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

41. Aunt Polly's Pizza

7.8
5339 English Ave (emerson ave. & english), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Southeast Indianapolis · 13 tips and reviews

Ben R.Ben Risinger: Some of the BEST pizza in Indy. Great sauce and crust.

Tony Sacco's Coal Oven Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

42. Tony Sacco's Coal Oven Pizza

1251 US Highway 31 N (County line road), Greenwood, IN
Pizzeria · 10 tips and reviews

Shayna A.Shayna Adelman: Try the Marco Polo pizza. Unique and delicious.

Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

43. Napolese Artisanal Pizzeria

8.1
30 S Meridian St (at W Maryland St), Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 19 tips and reviews

Chris S.Chris Sublett: Great pizza here today, the special was good and the girls loved the smoked salmon pizza.

Mellow Mushroom is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

44. Mellow Mushroom

8.2
2340 E 116th St (Keystone Avenue), Carmel, IN
Pizzeria · 30 tips and reviews

Matt P.Matt P: You can get a calzone like any of their specialty pizzas. Just be sure to ask for the matching sauce (BBQ for Funky-Q Chicken, Thai chili for Thai Dye, etc), cuz they all come w/ a side of marinara.

Xtrodinary Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

45. Xtrodinary Pizza

5.8
7639 Southeastern Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · 4 tips and reviews

Bill S.Bill Striby: Pizza, thick lots of topping its hard to eat two pieces

Greek's Pizzeria is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

46. Greek's Pizzeria

15 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 6 tips and reviews
Adams Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

47. Adams Pizza

2226 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Near Southeast · 4 tips and reviews
Good Fella's Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

48. Good Fella's Pizza

6.9
9641 Olio Rd (96th St.), McCordsville, IN
Italian Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews
Crust Pizzeria Napoletana is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

49. Crust Pizzeria Napoletana

12505 Old Meridian St, Carmel, IN
Pizzeria · 11 tips and reviews
Blaze Pizza is one of The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis.

50. Blaze Pizza

9.0
913 Indiana Ave,, Indianapolis, IN
Pizzeria · Downtown Indianapolis · 12 tips and reviews