Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.Aunt Polly's Pizza
Pizzeria$$$$
Southeast Indianapolis, Indianapolis
"The hot ham &cheese subs out of this world super great breadsticks"(2 Tips)
"Best ribs and pizza I've had in a long time."(11 Tips)
"We live nearby, but they do citywide delivery!"(4 Tips)
"superb and bread sticks"(3 Tips)
13 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- cheese subs
- delivery
- ribs
- chicken wings
- (5 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- SarahDecember 11, 2016We got delivery last night. Only took about an hour on a busy Saturday! They do party cut pizza with plenty of toppings. The breadsticks were excellent. We live nearby, but they do citywide delivery!
Carrie HartFebruary 26, 2014Best ribs and pizza I've had in a long time. Fast delivery and the food was fresh and hot. I work hard for my money and aunt Polly's is well worth my money when I'm hungry at 2:30 am when I get off
Nichole B.October 9, 2014Everything I've had so far was wonderful , the pizza was superb and bread sticks soft and just the right amount of garlic butter. And their tenderloin best in town .
david sniderJanuary 10, 2014hi i'm david snider owner & ceo of aunt pollys pizza where we been making real homemade pizzas and wet wings for 44 years and we do have a new phone number (317) 638-3663 or 638- food- Carrie HartDecember 20, 2014This is the best pizza in nap town so if you want fresh hot pizza and good food call Aunt Pollys Pizza. Its the onky way to go.
Melanie HollcraftApril 21, 2014Yes, they are open on Sundays....(they did close for Easter). They are normally open seven days a week from 3p until very late at night. I love there food.
alissa BishopFebruary 7, 2017EVERYTHING This place has on the menu is great hot and made to order. Not mushrooms though but i dont like anybodys mushrooms. And they deliver really late too.
Some of the BEST pizza in Indy. Great sauce and crust.
9 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Aunt Polly's Pizza
5339 English Ave (emerson ave. & english)
Indianapolis, IN 46219
United States
Indianapolis, IN 46219
United States
This is "The Original" Aunt Polly's Pizza - Established 1970!
Open until Midnight (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- Midnight–1:30 AM
- 3:00 PM–Midnight
- Fri–Sun
- Midnight–3:00 AM
- 3:00 PM–Midnight
(317) 638-3663
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
See More
You might also like
- 7.4
"Great breadsticks with spicy cheese sauce"
Michelle Stone - 7.1
"I always order online. The crew is friendly, and the pizza is great. Even great when it's cold in the morning. I get thin crust, ranch in the middle, & 1/2 pepperoni and mushroom on top."
Chris Smith - 7.7
"The deep dish is really just a thicker crust pizza. Both the salad bar and pizza were pretty good."
Elandra Wurm
Appears on 4 lists
The Pizza to Seek Out in Indianapolis
Created by Qatadah Nasaaj
51 items • 81 followers
Food lovers guide to Circle City's Sandwich Joints
Created by Qatadah Nasaaj
99 items • 41 followers
