Best Italian - Elks Plaza
Italian Restaurant$$$$
Gatlinburg
"Chicken Broccoli Alfredo is yummy!!"(2 Tips)
"The calzone is HUGE and delicious"(6 Tips)
"Their rolls and supreme pizza are delicious!!"(11 Tips)
"Bloody Mary's were Awesome!"(5 Tips)
71 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- chicken broccoli alfredo
- calzones
- Bloody Marys
- garlic rolls
- good for groups
- (8 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Leona FosterOctober 15, 2013Awesome food and service. Rolls are some of the best ever!!!! We dine here each time we are in Gatlinburg.- Quentin HendricksJuly 28, 2015The garlic rolls are quite possibly the best I've ever had. I got the stuffed shells for dinner, and was extremely happy with my order. Good portions, fair pricing.Upvoted 1 week ago
Chad StarlingDecember 28, 2011Even though only a medium and large is listed on the menu at dinner time, they'll make a small (12") pizza if you ask!! Good pizza and lasagna - don't miss the garlic rolls, either!!
Jan FreemanAugust 24, 2016Our server was horrible. But the owner was great. The food is delicious. Salads are fresh. Reasonable prices.
James WalkerNovember 8, 2019I always come here for pizza when I’m in Gatlinburg. The knots are amazing
Crystal BrookshireMarch 10, 2013Best place ever for italian food. Garlic rolls are to die for!! Cookie is the greatest person and will take care of you!!
Nick EasterFebruary 22, 2015I agree with previous reviews on the slow service, but the people are ok and the food is good. Definitely try the garlic rolls.
One of our favorite family stops in Gatlinburg. Their garlic rolls are the best.
Mary FirsdonAugust 10, 2012Was there this week...the service at nite is great...service during the day not so great. Garlic Rolls are`AWESOME!
VisitMySmokiesMay 8, 2012Best Italian is the best Italian in the Smokies! Read more on our blog
Collin MesserSeptember 30, 2013A bit expensive for dinner, better to go for lunch or even at 3pm to get good service with little crowd. Good food though.
Ric MorganFebruary 23, 2010Great Italian food at reasonable prices. The pizzas are WONDERFUL...very big and lots of toppings. Dine-in or carry-out, but no delivery. There is limited parking. Read more
Melissa TeterSeptember 23, 2012Calzones are definitely big enough to share! Burgers are huge too! Yum.
Ron RollisonDecember 30, 2011Don't let the cheesy name fool you. This place rocks. The sandwiches are huge and very good.
Lila WilsonMay 26, 2012It truly is the BEST Italian food that I have ever had! AWESOME garlic rolls!
Brian FriesenSeptember 5, 2011You have to have the garlic rolls. Heaps of garlic and cheese piled on top. Yum!!!
Jacob HollandApril 25, 2012baked ziti is ridiculous. For only $6.99, i have lunch for tomorrow too!! so good!
SamanthaDecember 2, 2012Rolls and dinner was so very good, service was very slow and not super friendly. Atmosphere was very loud
Jill HackJuly 1, 2012Very slow. No AC. Nice employees, however my food was overcooked & extremely expensive for what it was. The only good thing was the employees were nice. Garlic rolls everyone was raving about no good.- Collin MesserSeptember 30, 2013Limited parking available for customers. But an easy walk from anywhere.
Amy RandallMarch 11, 2014Very long wait, food was sub par, waiter got orders wrong, waiter is treating customers badly, and they all speak very quietly. Avoid if possible.
Matt LoftisMay 14, 2012Food is alright not the best but not the worst either. The only really bad note is the service is horrible. If you want a quick lunch sorry.
135 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Doing New York-style Italian right since 1976. Join us for classic pizza, famous garlic knots, enormous calzones, the city's best bloody marys, & more.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(865) 430-4090
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Best Italian - Elks Plaza
- 8.9
"as someone who is underage it was a cool place to watch them make it and see all the flavors. They also have several others such as delicious jellies,salsas, and sauces that were available to try"
Laken Berry - 8.1
"You have to get the salty caramel whiskey. Their best! The season pumpkin pie was good too."
Grayson Shuler - 8.8
"Great underwater tunnel, plenty of big sharks and Sawfish. Good afternoons viewing, $25+tax for adults. Plenty of coupons available if you get them ahead of time."
Martin
Appears on 12 lists
Created by Aimee Fenton
13 items
Created by Isabella Downey
274 items • 4 followers