BurgerFi
(Now Closed)Burger Joint and Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
Yorkville, New York
88 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
JeffreyAugust 31, 2014There are “urban fries” (Parmesan, herbs, garlic aïoli), plus six different toppings for regular fries. Most surprising of all, you can ask for your spuds cooked “well done” or even limp.
Brigitte PerezMarch 9, 2015AMAZING blu cheese & bacon burger with parmesan fries. The cashier was super friendly and helpful being it was our first time.
Trisha BonolloSeptember 19, 2019Finding this place was serendipity! The veggie burger was fabulous and my boyfriend said the ceo burger was delicious too! We also liked the hand cut fries, v tasty! Also, the staff has been v kind!
Carly HeitlingerFebruary 11, 2015The burgers are great, the french fries are amazing, and the custard is out of this world.
ChelseaJuly 11, 2013New York Magazine Cheap Eats issue says, "The house cheeseburger is noteworthy - on the hefty side with 2 expertly melted, strategically positioned slices of cheese, possessing a deep, beefy flavor."
Roger RJune 10, 2016Basically an attempt to copy Shake Shack. They fries are way better than SS, but the burgers aren't quite there. Get the Brisket burger it's the best thing on the menu!
Paige CSeptember 12, 2016Their manager is wonderful. He handled the customers so well and really defined what good customer service means! Makes such a difference when you eat somewhere.
Veggie burger was delicious! Seriously one of the best I have ever had. Ever. Staff was super friendly as well!
I get my weekdays lunch here. Make your own burger with lettuce instead of of bun. Tasty burgers and good beer, soda selection- Michael OSeptember 14, 2014The burgers are good (Not big like what you get normally get at Five Guys) and the side are large. Still great food
MkimmlJune 30, 2013Not a bad place for a burger fix...fries are great and the veggie burger is far superior to then Shack's shroom burger. Burgers are pretty good. Solid, if unspectacular, burger option in the hood.
Nikki VargasJuly 5, 2013Half way between Five Guys and Shake Shack. The fries are awesome, especially the urban (Parmesan and herbs covered fries slathered with an aioli sauce).
1/2 stack green style!!! Double the patties, double the crunch, double the flavor. You don't need to love quinoa to be crazy about this combo.- Brad GaroonMarch 15, 2013The music is loud. You've been warned. The Coke machine has every flavor combo imaginable. The burgers might not look huge, but if you feel hungry afterwards you should see a doctor.
Get the veggie burger & $5 wine for a delicious inexpensive meal 🍔🍷 or the burger topped with a veggie burger!
Pierre van MedgeAugust 20, 2014Well, the burgers here are not quite as good as at Shake Shack in my opinion. Reasonable size. The fries are delicious. Nice selection of draft beer.
Adrian HannahOctober 29, 2014Have a BurgerFi cheeseburger with bacon and wash it down with a Key Lime Concrete
Veggie Burger is amazing. The white cheddar and aioli sauce is a great so I always have it as is. The staff is friendly.
Cappy PoppJuly 2, 2013Brisket burger not worth it. Ideally skip this place walk a bit to go to JG Melon and have one of the best burgers in NYC for cheaper.
Nicole SerratoreJune 6, 2015I'm a sucker for the make your own flavored soda machine. A diet cherry caffeine free coke option is amazing.
Onion rings are humongous, Shake Shack fries better imo, but the burgers and shakes are comparable. It's a decent imitation if you don't feel like walking the extra 4 blocks.
Jeanette Ttsp SullivanMay 3, 2013Best veggie burger on Long Island, hands down! Get the Cajun seasoning on the fries, it's amazing.
Josh CollinsApril 14, 2014Had a pretty good craft beer tap list. Burgerfi burger and fries were good, but the beer-battered onion rings were on point
Jessica Densky @ NextStopNYMarch 16, 2013Veggie burger good, fries good, shake good. However, the burger is kiddie sized and the large fry is enough for several people. Maybe they need to proportion the burgers to be more like fries.
BEST VEGGIE BURGER I have eaten. Better than the normal burgerfi burger. Definitely worth a try
The burgers are delicious, but the onion rings are amazing.
Ryan EickFebruary 20, 2017Just as good as Shake Shack, but there are less lines. Can't go wrong with that!
The onion rings are intimidating, but the burgers aren't great. They don't taste like they are 100% beef. They have an unnatural sponge-like quality.
Emily MannOctober 30, 2018Try the all you can eat breakfast burger for an early dinner make sure to check out the menu
Quinoa veg is one of the best I've had...and the onion rings are not messing around. No sir!
Best veggie burger EVER. And you can get it with a lettuce bun!
Ben ZweigJune 15, 2015If you get a fried egg, make sure to specify how runny you want it to avoid a mess.
Nathaniel RuppleMarch 14, 2013They have the new Coca-Cola Machine that allows you to choose any Coke product in any flavor - boo-ya.
Randall StemplerSeptember 5, 2013Better quality sundaes than 16 Handles even if not as many flavors and you can't make it yourself. Seems less expensive too.
Jason BrewJuly 12, 2013Skip the crazy lines at the overrated Shake Shack. Burger-Fi is every bit as good as far as burgers and has better fries.
John McLaughlinMay 20, 2013The Veggiefi burger is so much better than that cheesy heat explosion at Shake Shake. Great beers too.
Karen ChuMarch 26, 2013Not as good as shake shack! Different fry variations (with chili, Parmesan herb) but not very impressive. Walk the 3 blocks to shake shack.
RogMay 12, 2013I don't drink soda, but the soda machine is epic! I wanted to serve everyone's drinks.
The onion rings are not so good; the French Fries are AWESOME!
NYCeleb💋👏👏March 25, 2013If you want to eat fast food burger stick to Shake Shack... Burger FI is a bad imitation of Shake Shack I give it a 3 out of 10
174 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Your local BURGERFI isn’t some industrialized fast food giant. They were started in a gourmet kitchen, by gourmet Chefs. Not knowing fast food, the back of the house is built to be less burger joint, more five-star restaurant. When they needed a sauce, the Chefs didn’t call a food supplier...
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(646) 684-3172
View menu on https://burgerfi.com/menu
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine
See More
You might also like
- 8.1
"Best burgers in mid-town. And my favorite wings anywhere."
Roger V - 8.7
"Eater: Only 4items on menu - 2burgers, an Impossible burger, &fries. Burger is one of best in town, juicy &compact, w/sauteed onions &cheese, & patty bigger than the bun. Not fussy, but delicious."
Marc - 8.2
"Bison and elk burgers wth special sauce are amazing 😍😍"
Menna Khalifa
Places people like to go after BurgerFi
- 8.6
"lil britt special: 50/50 vanilla/peanut butter froyo, lots of kitkat pieces, generous helpings of marshmallow and peanut butter sauces"
Britt - 7.7
"Love love love. Their cookies are served warm too. We had their chocolate peanut butter, peanut butter, s'more (my fav), and chocolate chip cookie all delicious! Also, they are opened late !"
Brittney Potter - 8.6
"Eggs baked in tomato sauce is the best brunch. So much goodness 😍"
Mary-Jane Rewa
Appears on 188 lists
Created by Matthew
187 items • 51 followers
Grub Street's 101 Best (New) Cheap Eats, Ranked
Created by Ariel
94 items • 48 followers
Grubhub "The 101 Best (New) Cheap Eats" June 2014
Created by John Sjölander
106 items • 87 followers