See all
90 photos

Buttercooky Bakery

Bakery and Café$$$$

Floral Park, NY, Floral Park

Save

Buttercooky Bakery

8.9^/10

183

ratings

90 Photos

Main Menu 21

Main Menu

Breakfast Pastries

Danish

Cheese, Raspberry, Apricot, Prune, Cinnamon Raisin, Pecan

Muffins

Corn, Bran, Apple Crumb, Blueberry Crumb, Chocolate Chunk, Double Chocolate Chunk, Carrot, Orange Cranberry

Breakfast Pastries

Rugelach

Cheese Danish

Open, Closed or Closed with Almonds

Pecan Raisin Danish

With icing or without icing

Cigars

Chocolate or Raspberry

Crumb Turnovers

Cherry, Blueberry or Apple

Raspberry Crumb Cake

Pretzel

Croissant

Plain, Chocolate, Nutella, Almond, Raspberry and Cheese

Rugelach

Chocolate, Raspberry, Apricot, Cinnamon Raisin

Hamantashen

Prune, Apricot or Raspberry

Puff Pastry

Blueberry, cherry, or pineapple

Cinnamon Raisin Danish

Fruit Danish

Strawberry, Cherry, Pineapple, Blueberry, Lemon, Apricot, Prune, or Raspberry

Large and Small Turnovers

Cherry, Blueberry or Apple

Crumb Cake

Almond Horn

Plain or chocolate dipped

Cake Flavors & Fillings

At Buttercooky Bakery we offer wide selection of different flavored cake fillings and icings. With hundreds of combinations available, we can insure that we can please any palate. If there is a flavor that is not listed, please feel free to contact us with your request. Buttercooky Bakery is certified Kosher by the United Kosher Supervision. We offer a variety of options to accommodate your dietary needs. Buttercooky Bakery has a selection of dairy-free, gluten-free, sugar-free and eggless cakes, fillings, and icings. We also offer a variety of baked goods that do not contain nuts, however we ARE NOT a nut free environment and cannot guarantee that there has be no interaction with peanuts or tree nuts. When making your cake flavor and filling selection please keep in mind that we do not offer fresh fruit fillings on any of our tiered or fondant-covered cake designs

Cake Flavors

Our moist, light and fluffy cake comes in the following flavors:

Vanilla

Classic Sponge Cake

Red Velvet

Chocolate Almond Cake

Almond

Classic Sponge made with Almond Flour

Napoleon

Traditional Puffed Pastry Layered with Vanilla Custard topped with Hard Icing

Chocolate

Classic Chocolate Sponge Cake

Carrot

Traditional Carrot Cake with Raisins

Hazelnut

Classic Sponge made with Hazelnut Flour

Cake Fillings

Our rich and decadent fillings come in the following flavors:

Fresh Fruit Salad

Our signature filling - vanilla custard with a mix of banana, strawberry, peach and pineapple

Fresh Strawberry / Custard

Strawberry Preserves

Dulce De Leche

Cannoli Cream

Cherry

Pineapple

French Cream

A mix of vanilla custard and vanilla buttercream

Chocolate Fudge

Vanilla Custard

Sweet Cream Cheese

Fresh Strawberry / Banana

Fresh Banana / Custard

Raspberry Jam

Tres Leches

Black Forest

Chocolate Whipped Cream with Black Cherry

Lemon

Crème Brule

Buttercream

Vanilla, Chocolate, Mocha

Chocolate Pudding

Bavarian Cream

A mix of vanilla custard and whipped cream

Mousses

Ice cream fillings are also available by request

Chocolate

Pistachio

Raspberry

Caramel

Strawberry

Passion Fruit

White Chocolate

Grand Marnier

Praline

Hazelnut

Mango

Cappuccino

Cake Icings

Our creamy and delicious icings come in the following flavors:

Buttercream

Vanilla, Chocolate, Mocha

Chocolate Whipped Cream

White Chocolate Ganache

Chocolate Hard Icing

Whipped Cream

Chocolate Ganache

Vanilla Hard Icing

Rolled Fondant

Requires Buttercream

Cakes

Fresh Fruit Salad

Vanilla Cake/Fresh Strawberries, Bananas, Peaches and Pineapple filling/Whipped Cream Icing

Cannoli Cake

Vanilla Cake/Cannoli Cream Filling/Vanilla Buttercream Icing

Black Forest Cake

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Whipped Cream/Black Cherry Filling/Whipped Cream icing topped with cherries and chocolate shavings

Mocha Cake

Vanilla Cake soaked in Coffee Syrup/Mocha Buttercream

Shadow Cake

Vanilla and Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Buttercream Filling and Icing/Chocolate Ganache drizzle

Seven Layer Cake

Seven Layers of Vanilla Cake With Chocolate Buttercream filling and Chocolate Hard Icing on top

Chocolate Fudge Seven Layer Cake

Seven Layers of Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Buttercream filling and Chocolate Fudge Icing topped with Chocolate Shavings

Oreo

Chocolate Cake/Oreo Buttercream Filling/Vanilla Buttercream Icing with Oreos on top

Multi-Flower Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Pudding filling/Chocolate Fudge icing

Strawberry Shortcake

Vanilla Cake/Fresh Strawberries and Whipped Cream filling/Whipped Cream Icing

Brown Derby

Chocolate Cake/Strawberry Preserves, Fresh Bananas, and Whipped Cream filling/Whipped Cream Icing coated in chocolate cake crumbs with Fresh Strawberries on top

Carrot Cake

Carrot Cake/Sweet Cream Cheese Filling and Icing/Coconut flakes with marzipan carrots on top

Chocolate Shadow Cake

Vanilla and Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Buttercream Filling and Icing/Chocolate Ganache drizzle

Flourless Chocolate Cake

Dense and Rich Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Ganache Icing/Chocolate Flowers on top

White Fudge Seven Layer Cake

Seven Layers of Vanilla Cake with White Chocolate Fudge filling and icing topped with White Chocolate Shavings

Blackout Cake

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Pudding Filling and Chocolate Ganache Icing covered in chocolate cake crumbs

Multi-Flower Vanilla Cake

Vanilla Cake/Vanilla and Chocolate Buttercream filling/ Vanilla Buttercream icing

Marshmallow Ring

Marble Cake/Chocolate Fudge filling/Vanilla Buttercream icing/Chocolate Ganache

Pies

8″ or 10″ Diameter

Lattice

Apple, Blueberry, or Cherry

Crumb Topping

Apple/ Blueberry/ Cherry/ Coconut/ Mince/ Pumpkin/ Sweet Potato/ Strawberry Rhubarb

Pecan Pie

Key Lime

Key Lime Custard with a Graham Cracker Crust

Lemon Meringue

Traditional

Apple/ Blueberry/ Cherry/ Coconut/ Mince/ Pumpkin/ Sweet Potato/ Strawberry Rhubarb

French Apple

Pastiera (Grain Pie)

Coconut Cream

Flakey Pie Crust with Coconut Cream filling and Whipped Cream Icing with Coconut Flakes

Fresh Fruit Torte

Cake Pops

Vanilla

Vanilla Cake/Vanilla Buttercream dipped in White Chocolate Ganache

Chocolate

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Fudge dipped in Chocolate

Oreo

Chocolate Cake/Oreo Buttercream dipped in Chocolate

Red Velvet

Red Velvet Cake/Sweet Cream Cheese icing dipped in White Chocolate Ganache

Cheesecakes

Classic Ny Cheesecake

Strawberry Cheesecake

Oreo Cheesecake

Marble Cheesecake

Caramel Cheesecake

Italian Cheesecake

Butter Cookies

Chocolate Sprinkle

Classic Spritz Cookie with Chocolate filling dipped in dark chocolate and coated in chocolate sprinkles

Sugar Clovers

Clover shaped Butter Cookie with sugar on top

Turtles

Butter cookie with Raspberry preserves, chopped nuts, and chocolate fudge

Heart Cookies

Rich Butter cookie baked with candied cherry on top

Filberts

Hazelnut cookie with Raspberry Preserves

Mini Chocolate Chip

Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie

Mini Raspberry Linzer Cookies

Butter cookies sandwiched with Raspberry Preserves

Cinnamon Sugar Star Cookies

Star shaped spiced butter cookie with cinnamon sugar on top

Chocolate Checkerboard

Rich Chocolate and Vanilla Butter Cookie in checkerboard design

Nutella

Classic Butter Cookie filled with Nutella and dipped in chocolate

Dark Chocolate Lace Cookies

Filled and Dipped in Dark Chocolate

Pecan Sandies

Pecan Shortbread cookie topped with granulated sugar

White Chocolate Sprinkle

Classic Spritz Cookie with Apricot filling dipped in White chocolate and coated in white chocolate sprinkles

Apricot

Butter cookie filled and baked with Apricot preserves

Palmiers

Flakey puff pastry coated in granulated sugar

Dulce De Leche

Butter cookie filled Dulce de Leche and dipped in White Chocolate

Mini Chocolate Linzer Cookies

Chocolate Butter Cookies sandwiched with Chocolate filling

Mini Red Velvet Cookies

Red velvet cookies sandwiched with Cream Cheese icing

White Checkerboard

Rich Chocolate and Vanilla Butter Cookie in checkerboard design

Fingers

Classic Spritz Cookie with Raspberry filling dipped in chocolate

Hazelnut Meringue

Crispy and Airy chocolate meringue cookie loaded with hazelnuts

White Chocolate Lace Cookies

Filled and Dipped in White Chocolate

Large Butter Cookies

Linzer Tart

Red Velvet

Chocolate Sprinkle

Peanut Butter

Oatmeal Raisin

Sugar

Black & White

Chinese

M&Ms

Rainbow Sprinkle

Chocolate Chip

Italian Cookies

Raspberry Crumb Twists

Cinnamon Crumb Twists

Anisette

Cinnamon S-Cookies

Swirl Cookies

Chocolate Sprinkle, Chocolate Dipped or Rainbow Sprinkle

Chocolate Crumb Twists

Jumbo Fingers

Sesame Cookies

Sugar Bowties

Biscotti

Almond Biscotti

Quaresimali - authentic Italian Lenten cookies

Double Chocolate Chip Biscotti

Dark Cherry Chocolate Chip Biscotti

Cranberry Walnut White Chocolate Biscotti

Almond Pistachio Chocolate Chip Biscotti

Chocolate Hazelnut Chocolate Chip Biscotti

Almond Pistachio Biscotti

French Macaroons

Pistachio

Blackberry

Chocolate

Coffee

Orange

Blueberry

Raspberry

Lemon

Caramel

Hazelnut

Apricot

Cherry

Cupcakes

Classic Vanilla

Vanilla Cake/Vanilla Buttercream with confetti sprinkles and a cherry on top

Oreo

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake/Cookies n' Cream Buttercream with an Oreo on top

Red Velvet

Red Velvet Cake/Sweet Cream Cheese Icing with a fondant flower on top and red velvet crumbs on the side

Cookie Monster

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake dipped in Chocolate Ganache with a Buttercream drawing of Cookie Monster on top

Black & White

Vanilla Cake/ ½ Vanilla Hard Icing ½ Chocolate Ganache

M&M

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake dipped in Chocolate Ganache with Vanilla Buttercream and M&Ms

Reeses

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake dipped in Chocolate Ganache with Peanut Butter Buttercream and Reeses Chunks on top

Sports - Football Field

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Buttercream Icing

Sports - Basketball

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Buttercream Icing

Snowflake

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Buttercream Icing/Fondant Snowflake on top

Classic Chocolate

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Buttercream with confetti sprinkles and a cherry on top

Carrot

Carrot Cake/Sweet Cream Cheese Icing with a marzipan carrot on top on coconut flakes on the side

Elmo

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake dipped in Chocolate Ganache with a Buttercream drawing of Elmo on top

Spring Flower

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Buttercream with Buttercream Flowers on top

Brownie

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake dipped in Chocolate Ganache with Chocolate Fudge and Brownie chunks

Hostess

Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream filling dipped in Chocolate Ganache

Funfetti

Vanilla Cake with Funfetti Sprinkles dipped in Vanilla Hard Icing

Sports - Football

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Fudge Icing

Sports - Baseball

Vanilla or Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Buttercream Icing

Mousse Cakes

Silk & Satin

Chocolate Cake/NY Cheesecake/Chocolate Mousse/Chocolate Ganache Icing

Hazelnut Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Mousse/Hazelnut Mousse

Chocolate Tiramisu

Espresso soaked Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Mascarpone Cheese filling with chocolate chips/Lady Fingers/Whipped Cream and Chocolate Ganache with Chocolate shavings on top

Pistachio & Raspberry Mousse

Vanilla Cake/Pistachio Mousse/Raspberry Mousse

Black & White Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Mousse/Chocolate Mousse with White Chocolate shavings on top

French Strawberry Shortcake

Vanilla Cake/Fresh Strawberries/Bavarian Cream/Marzipan on top

Peach Marmalade Cake

Almond Cake/Peach Marmalade /White Chocolate Mousse

Oreo Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Oreo Mousse

Raspberry Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Raspberry Mousse/Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Mousse

Vanilla Cake/Chocolate Mousse filling/Ganache icing

Red Velvet

Chocolate Almond Cake/Sweet Cream Cheese Filling/Chocolate Ganache Icing

Traditional Tiramisu

Espresso soaked cake/Mascarpone Cheese filling/Lady Fingers/Whipped Cream on top

German Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Cake/Shredded Coconut and Pecans/Caramelized Custard/Clear Glaze on top

Grand Marnier & Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Grand Marnier Mousse/Chocolate Mousse

Checkerboard Mousse

Vanilla and Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Mousse/Raspberry Jam/Chocolate Ganache

Charlotte Royale

Vanilla Cake/Bavarian Cream/Fresh Mixed Berries on top

Tres Leches

Vanilla cake soaked in 3 milks/Dulce de Leche/Vanilla Custard/Whipped Cream icing topped with mixed fresh fruit

Double Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Mousse/Chocolate Ganache on top

Opera Cake

Almond Sponge soaked in coffee syrup/Chocolate Ganache filling/Coffee Buttercream filling/Chocolate Ganache glaze

Pastries

Ny Cheesecake

Classic NY style cheesecake with a smooth and creamy texture

Hazelnut Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Mousse/Hazelnut Mousse

Tres Leches

Vanilla cake soaked in 3 milks/Dulce de Leche/Vanilla Custard/Whipped Cream icing topped with mixed fresh fruit

Strawberry Shortcake

Vanilla Cake/Fresh Strawberries and Whipped Cream filling/Whipped Cream Icing

Silk & Satin

Chocolate Cake/NY Cheesecake/Chocolate Mousse/Chocolate Ganache Icing

Red Velvet

Chocolate Almond Cake/Sweet Cream Cheese Filling/Chocolate Ganache Icing

Oreo Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Oreo Mousse/Oreo Cookie on top

Lobster Tail

Flakey Buttery Pastry Shell with Bavarian Cream filling

Grand Marnier Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Grand Marnier Mousse/Chocolate Mousse

Crème Bruleé

Rich Custard with a hard caramel crust topped with fresh berries

Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Mousse

Charlotte Royal

Vanilla Cake/Bavarian Cream/Fresh Mixed Berries on top

Carrot Cake

Carrot Cake/Sweet Cream Cheese Filling/Coconut Flakes with a marzipan carrot on top

Classic Custard Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Creamy Custard filling and Chocolate glaze

Red Velvet Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Cream Cheese filling and Red Velvet Ganache glaze

Nutella Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Nutella Filling and Hazelnut glaze with Caramelized Hazelnuts on top

Fudge Brownie Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Chocolate Fudge filling and Chocolate glaze with Fudge Brownie Chunks on top

Black & Blueberry Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Berry Custard filling and Vanilla glaze with fresh Blackberries and Blueberries on top

Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Custard with a Graham Cracker Crust

Opera

Almond Sponge soaked in Coffee syrup/Chocolate Ganache filling/Coffee Buttercream filling/Chocolate Ganache glaze

Brownies

Plain, Cheesecake, or Pecan

Napoleon

Layers of Flakey, Buttery Puffed Pastry and Creamy Vanilla Custard topped with hard icing

Chocolate Tiramisu

Espresso soaked Chocolate Cake/Mascarpone Cheese filling/Lady Fingers/Whipped Cream and Chocolate Ganache with Chocolate shavings on top

Traditional Tiramisu

Espresso soaked cake/Mascarpone Cheese filling/Lady Fingers/Whipped Cream on top

Strawberry Cheesecake

NY Cheesecake topped with Fresh Strawberries

Seven Layer Cake

Seven Layers of Vanilla Cake/Chocolate Buttercream Filling/Chocolate Ganache Icing

Pistachio & Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Chocolate Mousse/Pistachio Mousse

Raspberry & Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Raspberry Mousse/Chocolate Mousse

Hazelnut & Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Hazelnut Mousse/Chocolate Mousse

Fruit Tart

Buttery Pie Crust brushed with chocolate and filled with custard topped with mixed fresh fruit

Classic Cannoli

Cannoli shell filled with luscious cannoli cream filling with chocolate chips, a cherry and candied orange peel

Chocolate Cannoli

Cannoli shell dipped in chocolate then filled with our luscious cannoli

Black & White Mousse

Chocolate Cake/Vanilla Mousse/Chocolate Mousse with White Chocolate shavings on top

Cappuccino Mousse

Vanilla Cake soaked in Coffee Syrup/Cappuccino Mousse

Chantilly Cream Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Chantilly Cream filling and Chocolate Shavings on top

Raspberry Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Raspberry Custard filling and Raspberry glaze with a Raspberry and a Chocolate curl on top

Lemon Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Lemon Custard filling and Lemon glaze with Crystallized Violet on top

Berry Bavarian Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Bavarian Cream filling and fresh Raspberries and Strawberries on top

Madagascar Vanilla Éclair

Light and Fluffy Pate de Choux Pastry Shell with Vanilla Bourbon Custard filling and Vanilla glaze with Chocolate Pearls

St. Honore

Classic French dessert with a circle of Puff Pastry at its base with a ring of Pate de Choux piped on the outer edge with Vanilla Custard filling and Cream Puffs and Whipped Cream on top

Sfogliatella

Fresh Baked Breads

Round

Semolina

Seeded, unseeded

Rye

Seeded, Marble, Onion

Whole Wheat

Ciabatta

Pumpernickel

Italian

Seeded, unseeded, braided

Rolls

Egg Rolls

Challah

Plain, Raisin

French Baguette

White

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. SinglePlatform is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between SinglePlatform and the listed business.

Problem with this menu?