See all
611 photos

Cafe Fiorello

Italian Restaurant, Pizzeria, and Breakfast Spot$$$$

Lincoln Square, New York

Save

Cafe Fiorello

8.3^/10

447

ratings

Ranked #9 for Italian restaurants in the Upper West Side
The experts at The New York Times and Serious Eats recommend this place
"Always great at Lincoln Center"(4 Tips)
"The fried artichokes are GREAT!"(5 Tips)
"Margherita Pizza and Chocolate Mousse = perfection"(10 Tips)
"Amazing thin crust pizzas - the meat supreme is out of this world."(6 Tips)

134 Tips and reviews

Filter:

lincoln center
chocolate mousse
good for dates
desserts
fried artichokes
good for groups
lemoncello tart
brunch food
cookies
muffins
pancakes
salads
bar
Aperol Spritz
scenic views
meringues
breakfast food
outdoor seating
cake
dinner
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

ᴡ FleysherJune 6, 2015
Get the Tiramisu but make sure to share it. It's huge!
João de Lorenzo NetoJanuary 3, 2014
The lasagna is incredible served in a different format from what we are used to. It's too big though and now they charge a sharing fee which is bullshit in my opinion.
DougJanuary 23, 2011
Favorite place to eat is the far end of the bar where you have a great view of the staff and patrons while eating spectacular food.
Jonathan ZSeptember 18, 2011
Chocolate mousse and cream! Comes out in buckets. They stop when you say when!
Joseph BartelsJune 24, 2018
Avocado toast with scrambled eggs (instead of poached).
Emilie SchwenkJuly 31, 2011
We had water spilled on my bag and phone without so much as an appology. The service is usually great, but today is was very very off. Great profiteroles
Lisa SApril 14, 2016
Love the charm and ricotta pancakes :)
N AvedisJanuary 12, 2019
In love with the quality of their food!
Alex WallJuly 9, 2013
The best shrimp dish I have ever had! Highly recommended
Charlotte ChanApril 9, 2016
Went here for dinner on a Friday night. Service was quick and the staff was friendly, the was okay but for its quality, I personally think it's over priced.
Teresa Weaver MilnerAugust 14, 2013
Stanley Tucci was dining when we were there. He's quite the Italian chef, so that says a lot about this restaurant.
Parcy SantosJuly 16, 2013
Good Italian food at a reasonable price With a great waiter staff
Helen LinMarch 31, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Try the Baked Lasagna - #omg #baked #lasagna
Dmytro AnopchenkoApril 13, 2013
The best place for Saturday breakfast ever - if you are near the Central Park
Julia ArtamonJuly 25, 2015
Try their meatballs and seafood risotto! 👍🏻
Yaqui NunezApril 1, 2015
The torte lemon is to die for.
Samantha SmithMarch 24, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Sit at the bar. Get the antipasto.
Noëlle DevlinJanuary 7, 2018
The fried artichokes were incredible!
Clare M.October 10, 2021
Been here 10+ times
Everything is fantastic here!
Adam NowickiApril 14, 2014
Super food and service great for vegetable lunch
Shahi HMay 20, 2013
I don't even like chocolate mousse but theirs is to die for !
Scott Jacobs, REALTOROctober 30, 2013
For breakfast, try the lemon & ricotta pancakes. Yum!
Chris KapovNovember 2, 2013
Don't leave your anything at the bar if you go to the bathroom. You'll have to prove it's yours to get it back from the manager.
Amanda MeccaJune 21, 2012
The spaghetti carbonara is amazing!
Björn JóhannssonDecember 20, 2016
The meatball and ribs pizza 👌
Bo ChangJanuary 18, 2011
The yellow fin tuna with a balsamic reduction is to die for!!! And also the Italian meats tray! :-)
The Tiny TieRantJanuary 31, 2012
Try the Chicken Pepperoni Parmagian - Possibly one of the best combos ever!!
Jonathan GoldbergSeptember 16, 2011
Chocolate mousse is awesome! Between November & December they have an amazing truffle pizza
Joe OblonDecember 23, 2011
The lemoncello tart now ranks as a top dessert of all time - don't leave without some!
Bethany TownesApril 2, 2012
Absolutely amazing customer service! Be sure to get Joseph as your waiter!
David DunhillNovember 8, 2014
The pizza is very good, though only available after 8. Like everything on this menu, it's about 30% overpriced.
Bruna MartinelliOctober 21, 2013
Pizza + chocolate mousse are awesome. Service, not so much.
Montserrat LópezOctober 15, 2011
The service is great! You should definitely try the cheescake!!!
FAHIM MOHAMEDMay 16, 2013
Your pizza style is amazing , wish to have same over here .
Sasha HuezoFebruary 8, 2011
The seafood Risotto is a perfect balance of seafood flavors and risotto tomato flavors.
Alaaddin AkkayaJanuary 10, 2015
Best pizza!
Caitlin ClementsFebruary 10, 2013
Margherita Pizza and Chocolate Mousse = perfection
Alice Sue DevinMarch 23, 2018
Always great at Lincoln Center
Dee MyaMay 1, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Fried calamaris the only good thing here.But when is calamari not good.n I got crab steak when I wanted crab cakes n it was horrible.Plus the drinks r undrinkable.Lol but my parents like the pizza tho
Chris BruciaDecember 29, 2012
Terrific service. Very friendly wait staff
Michael MeltzerMarch 18, 2014
They give free refills on soda!!!!
Valerie De La RosaJanuary 28, 2012
Light snacks pre-opera. Best part: surprised with muffins for tomorrow morning. Cute.
Mathieu LanssensMay 27, 2017
Just avoid this place. Tourist trap. Worst pasta carbonara I've eaten in NYC. Overcooked, almost no bacon and the egg on top...I didn't touch it. Enough said.
TaraNovember 8, 2010
Mozzarella mista and roman style fried artichokes are MUST have appetizers!
George BockMarch 9, 2011
Great food, great service! Try their lasagna, you will not regret
Alaaddin AkkayaJanuary 10, 2015
Pizza is great.
Zach MartowskiDecember 23, 2011
Lemoncello Tart was fantastic! Highly reccomended
SarikaOctober 12, 2012
They have gluten free pasta options!
Adrian AlonsoMarch 29, 2015
Lasagne! Really nice!
Nishant BhattAugust 16, 2014
Excellent service!!!

1 2 3

611 Photos

Cafe Fiorello

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Cafe Fiorello

Appears on 278 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.