Cayuga Lake Creamery
Ice Cream Parlor and Dessert Shop$$$$
Interlaken
"Great ice cream, even had a doggie sundae!"(2 Tips)
"Love the Seneca Salt Caramel."(2 Tips)
"Waffle cones are out of this world!"(3 Tips)
"Salted caramel and pumpkin cheesecake are great"(3 Tips)
27 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- ice cream
- waffle cones
- pumpkin cheesecake
- outdoor seating
- sea salt caramels
- (7 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Alyssa B.July 8, 2021Ice cream and custard plus lots of food choices like burgers hotdogs sandwiches and sides. The kahlua ice cream was yum. Friendly staff
- Devin SwaderJuly 21, 2020The crunchy grasshopper was amazing! Waffle cones are out of this world! A hidden gem!
Hao ChengJuly 4, 2015One of the best ice creams I've tried!!! Must try the Cayuga Salt Caramel flavor...
Sea Salt Caramel is the best! If you can't decide get a tasters choice!
Black MajikJuly 4, 2019The ice cream is amazing!! Pet friendly, outdoor sitting area. Get the waffle cone!
The cookie dough is amazing! All the ice cream is really good though, definitely some of the best.
- Russell CaluriOctober 19, 2016Ice cream is awesome and cones huge. Salted caramel and pumpkin cheesecake are great
Phil AdamsJuly 30, 2015If you can't choose - they let you get 2-3 flavors in a 'single' scoop. Very generous portions!- Homemade hard ice cream! Love the Seneca Salt Caramel. Skip the oatmeal.
Catherine DigginsJanuary 21, 2012The sea salt caramel is awesome. I always splurge for a hand packed quart when I'm here, it's worth the drive.
Ada La AuuMay 22, 2012Should ask for some samples first. They also split up to 3 flavors for 1 scoop!
Andrew StantonJune 22, 2013Good ice cream, but most disorganized service ever. Almost twenty minutes to get three things. Order in one line, wait in a mob for piecemeal completion of the order.
Amy@GoPetFriendlyMay 26, 2010They make a great "doggy sundae" here! Vanilla soft-serve with a dog treat. Our boys loved it!
64 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Family & pet friendly setting to enjoy delicious ice cream or a light meal.
Traditional flavors & unique surprises like lavender, maple bacon or Seneca salt caramel. Sorbets, gluten free, soy-based & other options available.
Signature wine sorbets & ice creams continually created.
Open until 7:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–7:00 PM
(607) 532-9492
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Cayuga Lake Creamery
- 7.7
"The food here us actually very good. The best view of any winery on the lake. Try the chicken liver mousse or one of the homemade soups."
Matt Carcella - 9.3
"Loved this hiking trip, it was about 5 miles from the first parking lot, easy level but lots of fun. Warmer months are great to camp."
Eduardo Carvajal
Appears on 26 lists
A Weekend Away in the Finger Lakes
Created by Foursquare Swarm
20 items • 17 followers
Created by Jenn Park
33 items • 2 followers
Buffalo Road Trip - Finger Lakes - Cooperstown
Created by Izumi
17 items • 3 followers