Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Cayuga Lake Creamery

Cayuga Lake Creamery

Ice Cream Parlor and Dessert Shop$$$$
Interlaken
Save
Share
Cayuga Lake Creamery
8.9/10
93
ratings
  • Tips
    Chelsea M.
    "Great ice cream, even had a doggie sundae!"(2 Tips)
    Elliot V.
    "Love the Seneca Salt Caramel."(2 Tips)
    Devin S.
    "Waffle cones are out of this world!"(3 Tips)
    Russell C.
    "Salted caramel and pumpkin cheesecake are great"(3 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon27 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • ice cream
  • waffle cones
  • pumpkin cheesecake
  • outdoor seating
  • sea salt caramels
  • (7 more)
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Alyssa B.heart icon on user image
    Alyssa B.July 8, 2021
    Ice cream and custard plus lots of food choices like burgers hotdogs sandwiches and sides. The kahlua ice cream was yum. Friendly staff
  • Devin S.heart icon on user image
    Devin SwaderJuly 21, 2020
    The crunchy grasshopper was amazing! Waffle cones are out of this world! A hidden gem!
    Upvoted 6 days ago
  • Hao C.
    Hao ChengJuly 4, 2015
    One of the best ice creams I've tried!!! Must try the Cayuga Salt Caramel flavor...
  • Tyler P.
    Tyler PooleMarch 10, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    Sea Salt Caramel is the best! If you can't decide get a tasters choice!
  • Black Majikheart icon on user image
    Black MajikJuly 4, 2019
    The ice cream is amazing!! Pet friendly, outdoor sitting area. Get the waffle cone!
  • April
    AprilAugust 14, 2013
    Been here 5+ times
    The cookie dough is amazing! All the ice cream is really good though, definitely some of the best.
  • Russell C.heart icon on user image
    Russell CaluriOctober 19, 2016
    Ice cream is awesome and cones huge. Salted caramel and pumpkin cheesecake are great
  • Alyssa B.heart icon on user image
    Alyssa B.July 11, 2022
    Also recommend the pistacchio and strawberry cheesecake
  • Phil A.
    Phil AdamsJuly 30, 2015
    If you can't choose - they let you get 2-3 flavors in a 'single' scoop. Very generous portions!
  • Elliot V.heart icon on user image
    Elliot VosJune 29, 2016
    Been here 10+ times
    Homemade hard ice cream! Love the Seneca Salt Caramel. Skip the oatmeal.
  • Alysonheart icon on user image
    AlysonFebruary 19, 2013
    The cotton candy ice cream has gummy bears in it! Out of this world.
  • Ben M.heart icon on user image
    Ben MackeyJuly 5, 2014
    Super popular! The red raspberry ice cream was delicious.
  • vivian w.heart icon on user image
    vivian wongOctober 2, 2018
    Apple cider float and pumpkin cheese cake ice cream
  • Jess C.heart icon on user image
    Jess ColemanApril 9, 2016
    Rated by USA Today as the best ice cream in New York. Well deserved.
  • Catherine D.
    Catherine DigginsJanuary 21, 2012
    The sea salt caramel is awesome. I always splurge for a hand packed quart when I'm here, it's worth the drive.
  • Chelsea M.heart icon on user image
    Chelsea McDevittFebruary 13, 2015
    Great ice cream, even had a doggie sundae!
  • Amanda T.heart icon on user image
    Amanda ThauAugust 25, 2016
    Not sure what you want? Ask for a taste!
  • Ada L.
    Ada La AuuMay 22, 2012
    Should ask for some samples first. They also split up to 3 flavors for 1 scoop!
  • Phil A.
    Phil AdamsJuly 30, 2015
    Seneca salt caramel. Waffle cone. Perfection.
  • Andrew S.
    Andrew StantonJune 22, 2013
    Good ice cream, but most disorganized service ever. Almost twenty minutes to get three things. Order in one line, wait in a mob for piecemeal completion of the order.
  • Ezmerelda77 H.
    Ezmerelda77 HAugust 11, 2012
    the pretzel cone was unique and really added to the flavor.
  • Amy@GoPetFriendly
    Amy@GoPetFriendlyMay 26, 2010
    They make a great "doggy sundae" here! Vanilla soft-serve with a dog treat. Our boys loved it!
  • Terry T.heart icon on user image
    Terry TusherSeptember 20, 2014
    Gianduia is awesome
  • Devan
    DevanAugust 26, 2011
    The tiramisu is to die for
  • Gina
    GinaJuly 28, 2010
    Try the key lime pie ice cream. You won't regret it.
  • Clark H.
    Clark HoskinDecember 12, 2012
    Love their ice cream.
  • Daniel B.
    Daniel BirnbaumSeptember 2, 2011
    Sea salt caramel is amazing!!!
Photos64 Photos

Related Searches

  • cayuga lake creamery interlaken •
  • cayuga lake creamery interlaken photos •
  • cayuga lake creamery interlaken location •
  • cayuga lake creamery interlaken address •
  • cayuga lake creamery interlaken •
  • cayuga lake creamery interlaken •
  • clc (for staff) interlaken •
  • the clc (for staff) interlaken •
  • the clc for staff interlaken •

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
Cayuga Lake Creamery
8421 State Route 89
Interlaken, NY 14847
United States
Get directions
Information icon
Family & pet friendly setting to enjoy delicious ice cream or a light meal. Traditional flavors & unique surprises like lavender, maple bacon or Seneca salt caramel. Sorbets, gluten free, soy-based & other options available. Signature wine sorbets & ice creams continually created.
Clock icon
Closed until Noon tomorrow (Show more)
  • Mon–Sun
    • Noon–7:00 PM
Phone icon
(607) 532-9492
World Wide Web icon
Facebook icon
CayugaLakeCreamery
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after Cayuga Lake Creamery

Appears on 26 lists

See all
United States » New York » Seneca County » Interlaken »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.