- spoon bread
- sweet potato muffins
- spoonbread
- seafood
- vanilla ice cream
- (7 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Eric StankovitzJune 30, 2016I ordered the seafood Fricassee and it was amazing. It featured shrimp, scallops and lobster in a sherry sauce tossed wit penne. Sweet potato muffins were amazing & delicious as was the dinner rolls.
- Joe P.June 16, 2012Had a great dinner! The seafood stew was great. I ordered a cup for myself. Then had to order 2 more for the others at my table. "Mrs. Campbell" stopped at our table to chat. It was fun.
- Christian AlvarezApril 26, 2019Absolutely everything was heavenly! Of special note is the spoon bread, sweet potato bread, and fried chicken. The sweet potato bread was the most moist bread I’ve ever had!
- Matthew PhillipsOctober 12, 2014Like other taverns in Colonial Williamsburg, they offer decent but not exceptional food in a unique atmosphere and with great service. Spoonbread was very good. Crab cakes were pretty good too.
- Gail RankinDecember 6, 2014Watermans seafood feast with tender salmon, yummy crab cake and shrimp! Includes sweet pot muffins, spoon bread and Amish ice cream for dessert! More than we could eat!!
- xinaOctober 14, 2016Don't miss the homemade vanilla ice cream atop Apple crisp. Try w/ a glass of Madeira
- MaryJanuary 2, 2014Delicious seafood and a funny, informative chat with Mrs. Campbell. The Seafood Fricassy, Rum Cream Cake, and Spoonbread are fantastic!!
- John ReynoldsAugust 28, 2010Everything is good here :-) unique included sides such as homemade Cole slaw, spoon bread and fabulous sweet potato muffins
- Emona SDecember 29, 2013I'm from EU but am not too pretentious on food. The only good thing I tried was the cabbage side. The others were terrible and pretty pricey. The atmosphere and the candle light maybe worth seeing it.
- Melannie HayAugust 5, 2012Stay away from the Rummer unless you are Black Beard! The seafood is fantastic, but grab dessert somewhere else.