- cake
- pastries
- cookies
- bakeries
- cupcakes
- (11 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Kenneth LindDecember 19, 2018Amazing everything. All pasties, breads are fresh. Have been coming here for years. Hasn’t changed.Upvoted 3 weeks ago
- Andrew SchusterDecember 29, 2017Everything is fantastic. Cannolis, Tarts, Cookies, the Milky Way cake is truly amazing.
- Gary BurkeMay 27, 2016You will be very happy with everything you order here. Dortoni's is my favorite bakery on Long Island. They make the best black and white cookies!
- You can't go wrong with whatever you get. Hands down, it is the best bakery! Try the rainbow cookies and Italian cookie assortment.
- First stop when I’m back on Long Island. Italian cookies are one of the many incredible items.
- Jennifer LevitanApril 23, 2012amazing cakes! got 8 of them for my daughters christening and they were all delicious. sicilian cassata was awesome! st. honore was one of the best =D
- Best bakery on Long Island. Great selection of cakes, pastries, cookies, & more! Delicious - don't go in hungry
- Ken StaffeyAugust 16, 2013Wow, this place is impressive with all the beautiful cakes and pastries! Must return.
- Explore Long IslandFebruary 27, 2013We featured Dortoni Bakery and other stores in our guide for "Great food shops on Long Island!" Read more