Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Eagles Pizza

Eagles Pizza

Pizzeria and Sandwich Spot$$$$
New Albany
Save
Share
8.2/10
53
ratings
  • Tips
    Amanda S.
    "Best flippin pizza in Central Ohio."(2 Tips)
    Craig Alan S.
    "order an All The Way or Veggie pizza ask for a well done bake"(2 Tips)
    Beth W.
    "generic ATM machine on site."(2 Tips)
    J C.
    "Get your pizza well done it tastes better"(2 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon26 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • lively
  • casual
  • good for groups
  • sandwiches
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Eagles Pizzaheart icon on user image
    Eagles PizzaMay 12, 2013
    Whether you’re hosting a Graduation, a birthday party, or a holiday event, Eagles Pizza offers catering food for every season, occasion, and theme — and at a price you can afford. Read more
  • Amanda M.
    Amanda MinniearJanuary 12, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Absolutely amazing pizza...been coming here for 20 plus years and the prices are just as great as the food. The weekly date night location. Lol
  • Craig Alan S.heart icon on user image
    Craig Alan SeveranveAugust 17, 2020
    Been here 5+ times
    If you order an All The Way or Veggie pizza ask for a well done bake to make sure the crust in the center of the pizza is baked properly.
  • Eagles Pizzaheart icon on user image
    Eagles PizzaDecember 13, 2014
    The rumors are true, after 43 years in business Eagles Pizza is excited to announce to our loyal customers that we now accept debit and credit cards. Read more
  • Craig Alan S.heart icon on user image
    Craig Alan SeveranveOctober 22, 2020
    Been here 5+ times
    Pizza great and so are the subs if you can’t eat a full sub half subs are available
  • Wayne S.
    Wayne StocksSeptember 5, 2014
    Everything! Try the taco pizza. It doesn't last long!
  • Beth W.heart icon on user image
    Beth WatkinsJune 26, 2010
    Been here 10+ times
    This place only takes cash or check, although there is a generic ATM machine on site. It is totally worth it, though, as this is some of the best pizza in central Ohio. Read more
  • Management
    ManagementSeptember 29, 2011
    Eagle Pizza 40th anniversary lunch special this week, 10:30-2:00 pm, FISH SANDWICH, FRIES & 24 OZ DRINK....$5.00! ...ends Oct.1, 2011
  • J C.heart icon on user image
    J CJuly 7, 2015
    Get your pizza well done it tastes better
  • Marty P.
    Marty PhillipsSeptember 1, 2012
    Great Pizza!! Don't forget to bring cash, but even if you do.. They have an ATM
  • Dan M.heart icon on user image
    Dan McCaslinJuly 6, 2015
    Their large pizza with pepperoni, banana peppers is awesome.
  • J C.heart icon on user image
    J CJuly 7, 2015
    The Ham and Cheese sandwich is awesome
  • William C T.
    Very consistent with the quality of their pizza.
  • Cindy S.heart icon on user image
    Cindy SantiagoOctober 20, 2014
    Vegetarian pizza is excellent! !
  • Karen B.
    Karen BryantMay 27, 2013
    Totally worth the drive from outside of New Albany.
  • Amanda S.
    Amanda SageMay 30, 2013
    Best flippin pizza in Central Ohio.
  • Cindy S.heart icon on user image
    Cindy SantiagoApril 26, 2016
    Veggie pizza! So good
  • Abbey F.
    Abbey FriendDecember 12, 2012
    Great pizza for the price
  • J C.heart icon on user image
    J CJuly 7, 2015
    And get your pizza light sauce
  • Brandon C.heart icon on user image
    Brandon ClayJuly 13, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza in town - cheap and delicious
  • Ryan S.
    Ryan SteeleJuly 22, 2010
    AWESOME Pizza!! If you come to New Albany you need to eat @ Eagle's!
  • Ryan B.
    Ryan BaileySeptember 4, 2011
    The baked spaghetti is awesome...
  • Jaroslav E.
    Jaroslav EhlMarch 15, 2012
    This pizza is really yummy :-)
  • Jeffrey P.
    Jeffrey PrescottDecember 31, 2010
    Be sure to bring cash. Eagles pizza does not take credit cards.
  • Alex R.
    Alex RuthMarch 28, 2010
    Best pizza ever, be sure to check it out
  • Lonnie M.
    Lonnie MMarch 3, 2010
    Cash or check only. Leave the plastic at home
Photos25 Photos

Related Searches

  • eagles pizza new albany •
  • eagles pizza new albany photos •
  • eagles pizza new albany location •
  • eagles pizza new albany address •
  • eagles pizza new albany •
  • eagle's villa pizza new albany •
  • eagles pizza new albany •
  • eagles villa pizza new albany •

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA