Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016
Emmy Squared is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

1. Emmy Squared

9.0
364 Grand St (at Marcy Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 168 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The pizzas are baked in pans and resemble Sicilian-style pies. Options include the Deluxe (sauce, mozzarella, sausage, peppers, mushrooms) and the Lou-Wow (sauce, mozzarella, spicy pineapple, ham). Read more.

Pasquale Jones is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

2. Pasquale Jones

8.7
187 Mulberry St (btwn Broome & Kenmare St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · NoLita · 108 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The new restaurant from the Charlie Bird crew features pizzas cooked in wood-fired Stefano Ferraro ovens. The menu features a classic Margherita, and a clam pie. Read more.

Covina is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

3. Covina

127 E 27th St, New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Rose Hill · 101 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The pies are in the Neapolitan model, with topping combinations like house-roasted red peppers with fior di latte, and Brussels sprouts with béchamel. Read more.

Speedy Romeo LES is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

4. Speedy Romeo LES

63 Clinton St, New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Lower East Side · 81 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The new location features a few additions, like a pie topped with Katz's pastrami. During brunch, Speedy Romeo offers a grilled pizza topped with gravlax, ricotta, red onions, and capers. Read more.

Scarr's Pizza is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

5. Scarr's Pizza

9.1
35 Orchard St (btwn Canal & Hester St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · Chinatown · 78 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The pizza is NYC street-style, offered in both regular and Sicilian permutations, but the flour is reportedly milled in house and the cheese and ingredients are all sourced locally. Read more.

Pizzeria Sirenetta is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

6. Pizzeria Sirenetta

568 Amsterdam Avenue (W 87th Street), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 35 tips and reviews

EaterEater: Located just down the street from Abrams's Mermaid Inn, the pizza option includes a clam and cream pie, and another topped with spinach and hot peppers. Read more.

PN Wood Fired Pizza is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

7. PN Wood Fired Pizza

2 W 28th St (5th Avenue), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · NoMad · 24 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The conceit is that the flour is all organic and imported from Italy. While the toppings are fairly standard, there is usually a selection of different doughs available. Read more.

L'Amico is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

8. L'Amico

8.6
849 Avenue of the Americas (at W 30th St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Chelsea · 83 tips and reviews

EaterEater: This pizzeria offers pies approximate Neapolitan style but with a puffier crust and a more deliberately charred exterior. Topping include clams with guanciale, and white mushroom with truffle paste. Read more.

Double Zero is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

9. Double Zero

8.2
65 2nd Ave (at E 4th St), New York, NY
Pizzeria · East Village · 47 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The menu is all plant-based and entirely meat and dairy free. Cheese made from nuts serves as a substitute for mozzarella. Toppings include smoked carrots, and sausage made from faro and fennel. Read more.

Joe's Pizza is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

10. Joe's Pizza

9.0
216 Bedford Ave (btwn N 5th St & N 6th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Williamsburg · 83 tips and reviews

EaterEater: West Village slice legend Joe's Pizza has branched out to Williamsburg, bringing classic NYC pizza to Bedford Avenue. The ovens, ingredients, and menu are the same as at the two Manhattan locations. Read more.

Bono Trattoria is one of New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016.

11. Bono Trattoria

9.0
3658 Broadway (West 151st St.), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Harlem · 20 tips and reviews

EaterEater: This Washington Heights trattoria serves doctrinaire Neapolitan style pizzas out of a wood burning oven for only $10 a pie. Read more.