Pizzeria Sirenetta
(Now Closed)Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria$$$$
Upper West Side, New York
35 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Delicious food, wonderful hospitality. They seat you, let you wait at your table for rest of your party to arrive.Risotto croquettes, citrus salad, linguinette with Meyer lemon and ricotta👏Bravo
One of my faves in the neighborhood since it opened in the last year. The fennel sausage and onion pie is the bomb. As is happy hour where all pies are $10!- Cat Meirelles BuchatskiyJuly 25, 2017$10 pizzas at happy hour! Great price for high quality Neapolitan pizzas. Crust was amazing - so soft and doughy.
Anne SinsheimerNovember 24, 2016Sit at the bar, Christie is great...happy hour prices and selection are really good. Came for the first time Wed before Thanksgiving and coming back Friday after
L. S.December 5, 2016Solid pizza joint. It's not a dive nor too upscale but perfectly in the middle for ambience and above average for food. Service = great and who doesn't love a free dessert.
Pizzas are absolutely solid. Love the spinach/garlic/fontina/hot pepper pizza, chopped clams pizza and fennel sausage pizza.
Trae FJune 5, 2019Good for a pizza and pasta fix. The octopus is great too! Pass on the olive oil cake though
- Michael Fox-RabinovitzJune 5, 2016Great neighborhood place, focus is on creative pizza and pasta, super friendly staff
CarissaDecember 6, 2018amazing mushroom pizza and antipastas (grilled octopus, burrata/tomatoes, cauliflower).- Garrett BaileyApril 15, 2017Pea salad fantastic, the pizza crust and sauce were perfect, highly recommend!
SMay 15, 2016Nice atmosphere, we had the mains which were a bit of a miss. Will go back to try out the pizza.
Daniel PowellFebruary 6, 2016Fennel sausage pizza was very good and the rigatoni was cooked just right. Great complement to Mermaid Inn.
- Jessica KremenDecember 29, 2016Delicious pizza - especially the crust..very chewy. Service was not as good.
ChrisOctober 22, 2018Les pizzas sont hors de prix (entre 17 et 22 dollars ) et pas beaucoup de choix .la pizza blanche n’avait pas de goût . Service pas top .
61 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
a pizzeria serving Neopolitan pizzas and rustic Italian fare
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon, Sun
- Noon–10:00 PM
- Tue–Sat
- 12:30 PM–10:30 PM
(212) 799-7401
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.9
"You'd never know about this place unless you were walking by. Quaint and romantic spot for date night. The waiters are super friendly and have great recommendations. Try the carbonara!"
Nicolette Romero - 9.0
"Olive oil tasting and olive oil cake are delicious"
Elizabeth Burstein - 9.1
"The hulking veal parm is amazing. Worth it."
Jordan Fox
Appears on 254 lists
Created by Dani Aaron
231 items • 6 followers
Created by Courtney Tincher
136 items • 8 followers
New York City's Hottest Pizzerias, Summer 2016
Created by Eater
11 items • 84 followers
