Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.Fenicci's of Hershey
Italian Restaurant, Lounge, and Pizzeria$$$$
Hershey
Ranked #2 for Italian restaurants in Hershey
"Vegetariano papardelle is amazing and comes with salad"(2 Tips)
"Percorino tortellini."(3 Tips)
"The upside down pizza is a must have!"(8 Tips)
"It was all very good Service was great."(4 Tips)
62 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- Italian food
- papardelle
- gluten-free food
- Stromboli
- great value
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Visit Hershey HarrisburgMarch 7, 2012U.S. President James Garfield loved lasagna so much it’s rumored he ate 5 tons during his 6-month tenure. If you're able to finish Fenicci’s Homemade Lasagna you’ll get a certificate upon completion! Read more
Vivian NguyenJanuary 20, 2015A slice of lasagna will earn you a certificate. Check out their Guinness world records! Your check also gets you a discount at the next door ice cream shop.
Susan EwingAugust 1, 2012Ask to be seated on the deck overlooking their lush green garden emitting a fresh basil fragrance. Try the homemade garlic bread and ask for Angie - a real sweetheart offering great service!
Joseph KulnisFebruary 18, 2019Pricey, but you get what you pay for. The best interpretation of Italian in the tri-county area. From the appetizers to the desserts. Make reservations and enjoy the taste sensations!
Manny SkouloudisJuly 7, 2019The steaks were great. So was the wine. Waitress was very courteous. Food came very quickly. Manager would come to all tables asking if everything was okay. Great restaurant!!
Edward Gable JrAugust 12, 2017Staff was very friendly. Mom and dad got spaghetti and a meatball and liked it. I got BBQ wings and a Guiness both of which were fantastic.
MicahFebruary 10, 2014This is THE Italian place in Hershey. Ignore these idiots on here complaining about dumb shit. Get an upside-down pizza and have your mind blown.
Greg WamplerNovember 25, 2011Had a wonderful lunch at Fenicci's with my mom and my sister. The italian grinder is amazing. I love the atmosphere as well as the people who work there. Paula and Meredith you are my favorite.
Michael WoottonJune 10, 2015Great quick lunch. They serve half orders of all their pasta dishes. Fast, tasty and reasonably priced. My fra diavalo was excellent!
Mike LayfieldAugust 25, 2013Outstanding place. Food is good, healthy portions, & reasonably priced. Josh Bulley was a very good waiter too. We had a terrific lunch here.- Randall ClineApril 22, 2016We had a pizza,, salad, wine and dessert. It was all very good Service was great. Reasonably priced.
Melissa SavoyJanuary 9, 2023Papardelle ala vodka was excellent. Also recommend the lasagne. Their dinner rolls are excellent as well!
Tyler WengerMay 12, 2013Italian Stromboli and Italian cheesesteaks are delicious! Service was a little slower, but it's a great atmosphere with great food!
Anthony IaffaldanoJune 30, 2015Meatballs and red sauce are delicious! Open late, and very accommodating of big parties & families.
Neena AgarwalJune 26, 2016Had a good gluten free well done Pizza and salad lunch with family after a 3 mile hike at The Hershey Hotel for father's day Sunday. Loved it!- Visit Hershey HarrisburgNovember 4, 2010Great historic Hershey restaurant featuring upscale casual dining and high-quality American Italian cuisine. Order the lasagna, in true Italian fashion - it's a pound of lasagna! Read more
Matthew FronheiserNovember 17, 2015We ordered take out for a large group of us, about 18 ppl. The service was excellent, food was all delicious
Ashley GammieOctober 20, 2013Make a reservation. They get busy. But the rolls are warm and it's a great place to carb load before the half marathon.- Visit Hershey HarrisburgFebruary 28, 2012While your smartphone is out, scan the 5 QR codes located at the bottom of your menu taking you to the official Facebook Page, website, and more!
Joel KolbJuly 1, 2014For a really good meal on a tight budget, order one of the specialty pizzas and share.
"P" is the best bartender there by far! Very knowledgable and super friendly! Can't beat $0.50 meatballs at the bar!
DawnAugust 22, 2012Casual atmosphere ... Pizza excellent. Chop salad recommend too. However do not waste your time on bread. Too hard to enjoy.
Fenicci's is *the* Italian restaurant in Hershey with a marinara sauce that has been made the same way since 1935. Great food, great service, and great atmosphere.
Food was excellent as usual. Crab Tortellini is recommended!
Lynn Bass StoverNovember 25, 2013Always good and they have gluten free pasta too. Our waitress was a little slow.
AnnaMarch 4, 2011Absolutely phenomenal italian food. I frequently get their entrees to go, and the portion sizes are pretty generous!
- J GalJanuary 21, 2019Food is okay. Caesar salad was bland. We were rushed as soon as we were seated. We were put in a room that was being set up for the next day. A lot of back and forth by the employees. Stay away.
ellen resnickApril 14, 2013Very sweet spot for a nice dinner here in the middle of no place this was a surprise...
Don't go on a Saturday evening without a reservation. And with one we still had to wait 25-30 minutes to be seated.
Resevations suggested, especially on weekends. Large parties always welcome
Christa SteinDecember 17, 2013Got the Portabella Parm. The Portabella was done to perfection, the pasta was tasteless.
119 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Hershey's Oldest Freestanding Restaurant since 1935. Home to the famous DeAngelis Spaghetti Sauces and Upside Down Pizza. Home to the Stars from the Hershey Theatre and a favorite of locals and tourists alike
Open until Midnight (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–Midnight
(717) 533-7159
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
TouchTunes Jukebox
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Fenicci's of Hershey
- 9.3
"Gorgeous historic theatre. Get the cups with lids. Nice souvenir and well-made. Not a ripoff at $4."
Slightly Perfect - 8.5
"The roasted almonds are fantastic!"
Collin Straka - 9.1
"The virtual tour ride is awesome and it’s free. The line moves fairly quickly so don’t be put off when you see a long line. Worth the experience."
Bonnie
Appears on 17 lists
Lancaster, Williamsport, Tower City & back home PA
Created by ❦ ❧Desi Stine❦ ❧
158 items • 4 followersCreated by Carol
119 items • 6 followersHarrisburg-Hershey area things to do or see
Created by Lee Stevens
58 items • 18 followers