Gatsby's On The Bay

(Now Closed)

New American Restaurant$$$$

Stapleton, Staten Island

Save

Gatsby's On The Bay

13 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Jeremy VerderaNovember 9, 2017
Great vegetarian options!! Easy to find parking, and great atmosphere. Definitely a must for an intimate date night. Looking forward to coming back here with my wife when there's live music.
Jen PSeptember 20, 2015
Extensive drinks menu in a printed book that lists all the ingredients of each drink. The mahi mahi was perfectly cooked. Great price and great service
Melissa QJuly 22, 2016
I had lunch here with my Mom and our co-worker. The Bourbon Burger medium-well was delicious, as were its sides. I would return here for dinner to watch the entertainment.
Dr Mike MaroonMay 10, 2015
Cheese and balsamic bread is delicious. Penne Pasta with Italian Sausage, Swiss Chard, roasted peppers and E. V. O. O. is superb. Nice find on Staten Island.
Sam JDecember 25, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Come and enjoy our extraordinary food and unforgettable ambiance... Gatsby's doors are always open for you.
Sabrina MarieAugust 10, 2014
Love the homemade butter. It is delicious. Can't wait to go back.
Karen DaloiaOctober 27, 2013
Order the sweet potato and crab soup special. You will not be disappointed.
Dr Mike MaroonMay 10, 2015
Pistachio crusted Brie is outstanding.
Lizzie BordenJanuary 29, 2016
Great new young chef makes rounds
WilhelmSeptember 23, 2013
Savory menu, great atmosphere.
Lizzie BordenJanuary 30, 2016
Really good pre fix
Christopher RyanFebruary 21, 2014
Bar tender Tara is awesome!!
Bill LoveSeptember 13, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Great night

73 Photos