Genuine Roadside
(Now Closed)American Restaurant$$$$
Hell's Kitchen, New York
49 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Serious EatsDecember 5, 2013At almost $10, the Buttermilk Battered Chicken Sandwich is definitely overpriced, but if you're looking for something juicy and crunchy and fried to satisfy your hunger quickly, look no further.
Lived near Shake Shack in MadSqPk so of course I miss those Shack Burgers. However, the burgers here hold their own! Paired with a "lagerita," and fries, you have a pricey, but delicious meal.
Claire J SongJune 1, 2015the Classic Burger, $8 As evocative of California as Meyer lemons and fish tacos, this Gotham West beaut is loose and juicy and well seasoned, not to mention properly dressed.
Ranu RajkarnikarNovember 8, 2014Ahi tacos were tasty, so were the fried pickles. Pick ranch as your side dip. Get a pitcher of beer and call it a day.
Simon SteadmanApril 12, 2017I liked this place. The fried chicken burger was good, almost on par with shake shack. Cheeseburger was average, but will return. A fine addition to HK.
- Burgerspotting .seNovember 11, 2014"The double stacker", a really good hamburger. Great meat, good bread, incredibly good cheese and I also love their special dressing. Rating 9 out of 10.
April Kate 🍴October 6, 2014Mahi magi tacos are mediocre - there's more coleslaw and radish than fish. Get the buttermilk battered chicken sandwich - amahzing! Dill fried pickles are good but a little too much batter for me.
Alberto J S Moreau DMarch 30, 2016I loved the food, really different and tasty. Also loved the pictures at the wall with car emblems, as a car lover I loved them
Great Blue Marble ice cream shakes that are small enough to not feel too guilty over. Get items with the fried green tomatoes in them like the BLT.
June CarriganMay 28, 2015LOVE, love, love this place. Get the chicken sandwich, sweet potato fries and the fired green tomato sandwich. yum.
Colleen McAndrewAugust 17, 2014Dill pickle fries are more like fired pickle spears, but they are crunchy and have a delicious breeding!
Harumi UOctober 18, 2014Inside Gotham West Market. While it is not the cheapest find, food is fun souther food and they make (at least when I ordered) all ordered from scratch.
Bae Burger BlogJuly 8, 2015Burgers that don't try to be more than just a good burger. Keeping it simple and keeping it Murcia.
- June CarriganNovember 24, 2013Big, big fan. Favs: ceviche tacos (super fresh), buttermilk battered chicken and the nutty buddy shake.
Will KivinskiDecember 19, 2015Buttermilk Battered Chicken Sandwich and Mexican Chocolate Milkshake. Boom!
Gary EggersFebruary 5, 2014For anyone looking to recapture the memory of eating a Flintstones Push Pop, be sure to order the Push Up milkshake.
Rebecca ChadwickAugust 26, 2015Expensive, but very good chicken sandwich and sweet potato fries. Cool decor too.
Mike PanNovember 20, 2013Wait was a little long since it was a grand opening event and packed with people. But overall the food was good, but nothing extraordinary. Will have to try their other items to make a full critique
Christopher AyresNovember 20, 2013Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich melts in your effing mouth. Side of pickle fries. BOOM.
Leah HammerschlagMay 1, 2015Loved the burger. Honestly though, didn't think the fried chicken sandwich had much flavor.
Jaycob BurnsSeptember 21, 2014The fried chicken sandwich with the apple coleslaw is good, but def not good for you
Pickle fries? Yeah. Fried pickles. That's right. Go get 'em, tiger.
Pricey and mediocre. The food looks better than it tastes. They run out of things all the time. Bonus: the fries suck.
146 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Genuine Roadside
600 11th Ave (btwn W 44th & W 45th St)
New York, NY 10036
United States
New York, NY 10036
United States
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 582-7941
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
No
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 8.8
"Short rib hash was amazing, as were the eggs Benedict, and egg sandwich club. If you're in the West Village you can't go wrong here"
Sam Madden - 8.8
"Yes it's one of the best burgers in Manhattan, but also one of the best plates of fries. Be warned: their preference is to undercook a bit."
AmateurConcierge - 8.7
"Definitely get the panna cotta for dessert. It's amazing!"
Alanna Y.
Places people like to go after Genuine Roadside
Appears on 98 lists
Created by Kobie West
70 items • 2 followersCreated by deestiv
200 items • 3 followers
Created by 🍔 Pete 🍔
122 items • 5 followers
