Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.Goodfellow's
Wine Bar and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Mackinac Island
"Excellent Pizza!"(2 Tips)
"Best French fries on the island!"(2 Tips)
"Buffalo chicken"(4 Tips)
"easily the best place to get food and beer on the island."(2 Tips)
31 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- good for dates
- loaded potatoes
- potato soup
- Italian food
- beer
- (7 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Jococo CMay 8, 2013Buffalo chicken flatbread, fully loaded potato soup and sausage tortellini with vodka saucer were amazing. Warm rolls were served with homemade pesto sauce, must try. Best restaurant in the entire MI
Jerri McClenthenMay 14, 2013The first night we ate @ Goodfellow's the food and service were fantastic! We went back the next afternoon and the service was aweful!!! The food was still good though.
Marisa KendraJuly 5, 2014Prime rib sliders 7/10 (real good with the horseradish sauce, a little fatty), butternut squash was good 7/10, scallops were decent 8/10, the bread dipping oil was really good (has parmesan in it).
Harvey TomJune 24, 2015Wife and I ordered a pizza and very hot and cheesy. Burned the roof of my mouth because I couldn't wait to eat it. Defiantly need to wait to cook before eating.
David MurrayAugust 31, 2012If you are a fan of Lobster or Alaskan King Crab then this is the place. Been here three times and I've never been dissapointed.
OMG there are hooks under the bar for your purse/coat/shopping bags. Best idea ever!
April MartinAugust 22, 2017We weren't treated very well here. Server was not attentive at all. We do however love the chicken gnocchi.
- Nikki at the bar will always give good service. :) That woman is everywhere!
Edgard PortelaSeptember 25, 2011Worst service I have ever seen. Walked in a group of 11 people, waiter was our manager, told him we'd take care of him, asked if we could split bill into two and he flipped out... Bad, bad, bad. Rude.
74 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 8:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 8:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 8:00 AM–9:00 PM
(906) 847-0260
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Goodfellow's
- 7.8
"The French Dip, fish tacos, and sweet potato fries are good. I love the scenery."
Danielle Zwerg - 6.2
"We had the best service here. The food was very good. Get the White Bean Chili - if you are into chili."
Jerri McClenthen - 8.1
"Great falafel! The sweet potato fries are excellent as well. Some of the best and most reasonably priced food on the island."
Bjørn
Appears on 4 lists
Mackinac Island Dining Guide for Dummies
Created by Victoria Leonard
21 items • 6 followers
Created by Steve Severino
33 items • 3 followers