See all
74 photos

Goodfellow's

Wine Bar and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Mackinac Island

Save

Goodfellow's

6.2^/10

ratings

"Excellent Pizza!"(2 Tips)
"Best French fries on the island!"(2 Tips)
"Buffalo chicken"(4 Tips)
"easily the best place to get food and beer on the island."(2 Tips)

31 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
potato soup
loaded potatoes
Italian food
beer
chicken
island
vodka
sausage
lunch
dinner
appetizers
(7 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Jerri McClenthenMay 14, 2013
The first night we ate @ Goodfellow's the food and service were fantastic! We went back the next afternoon and the service was aweful!!! The food was still good though.
Jococo CMay 8, 2013
Buffalo chicken flatbread, fully loaded potato soup and sausage tortellini with vodka saucer were amazing. Warm rolls were served with homemade pesto sauce, must try. Best restaurant in the entire MI
Marisa KendraJuly 5, 2014
Prime rib sliders 7/10 (real good with the horseradish sauce, a little fatty), butternut squash was good 7/10, scallops were decent 8/10, the bread dipping oil was really good (has parmesan in it).
Scott AlexanderJune 25, 2018
Get wings and fries. You’ll be happy that you did.
David MurrayAugust 31, 2012
If you are a fan of Lobster or Alaskan King Crab then this is the place. Been here three times and I've never been dissapointed.
April MartinAugust 22, 2017
We weren't treated very well here. Server was not attentive at all. We do however love the chicken gnocchi.
Jennifer PhelpsOctober 26, 2013
Locals sit @ the bar. Good people, great stories. Good food!
Harvey TomJune 24, 2015
Wife and I ordered a pizza and very hot and cheesy. Burned the roof of my mouth because I couldn't wait to eat it. Defiantly need to wait to cook before eating.
Ken WhitingerSeptember 29, 2013
Pepsi products. One of the few on the island. Thumbs up.
Jenny StangeJune 15, 2012
Been here 10+ times
OMG there are hooks under the bar for your purse/coat/shopping bags. Best idea ever!
Loni HillAugust 11, 2011
Fish and chips are wonderful! Service is great too.
Jenny StangeJune 15, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Nikki at the bar will always give good service. :) That woman is everywhere!
Travis BoucekAugust 23, 2015
From the Gordon Food Service can to your plate.
Sarah QuadeJuly 9, 2011
Come with an empty stomach! Portions are huge and delicious!
StacyJune 12, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Excellent wine list
Pamela BennettAugust 5, 2013
Calamari is an awesome appetizer
Eddie RMay 5, 2013
easily the best place to get food and beer on the island.
Jeff AJune 22, 2012
Shots come in a chilled rocks glass! Nice!
Justin LipinskiSeptember 9, 2011
Try the Goodfellow's Ale. It is surprisingly good.
Shelly TaberskiJune 21, 2013
Best French fries on the island!
Shawn GallusMay 22, 2014
Good drinks from what I remember lol
Edgard PortelaSeptember 25, 2011
Worst service I have ever seen. Walked in a group of 11 people, waiter was our manager, told him we'd take care of him, asked if we could split bill into two and he flipped out... Bad, bad, bad. Rude.
Victoria LeonardJuly 13, 2013
Excellent Pizza! V = D
John BeckwithMay 23, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Niki is the best bartender!
Murphy BoisvenueMay 31, 2013
Expensive but good.
Jason SpencerAugust 1, 2011
Buffalo chicken salad ;)
Ricca SirivetMay 26, 2013
Great location, Horrible service! Go elsewhere!
Buda HitsJuly 24, 2011
Full full full full nice
Shelly TaberskiJune 21, 2013
They only have Pepsi products, no Coke :(
Fernanda MachadoAugust 18, 2013
Bad food, bad service. Eat chocolate fudge instead.
Nathan RJuly 1, 2012
Good but overpriced.

74 Photos

Goodfellow's

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Goodfellow's

Appears on 4 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.