See all
147 photos

Gotham City Diner - Fair Lawn

Restaurant$$$$

Fair Lawn

Save

7.9^/10

237

ratings

"One of the best diners in Bergen County!"(2 Tips)
"Carolina Omelette is amazing!!"(2 Tips)
"Best brown gravy and fries."(5 Tips)
"And I agree, Amanda, great Red Velvet Cupcakes!"(2 Tips)

63 Tips and reviews

Filter:

breakfast food
diners in bergen county
carolina omelette
french fries
family-friendly
sandwiches
good for groups
red velvet desserts
turkey soup
stuffed peppers
brunch food
pork sausages
good for working
casual
potato skins
chicken wraps
good for a quick meal
good for a late night
healthy food
diner food
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Robin SalantDecember 5, 2015
The salads are fantastic! Russian dressing is house-made & the best I've ever had. If you like buffalo wings, try the Buffalo Chicken Salad. My favorite is the Gotham salad with Russian dressing.
AlisonMarch 15, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Absolutely love gotham. Everything on the menu is delicious! You'll get seated quickly if you go, but they also deliver for orders over $10 within a certain vicinity! Can order online too!
Richard RevillaJune 4, 2017
Awesome diner. Great selection of food and the service was awesome.
Peter DelucchiDecember 23, 2015
Been here 25+ times
No better breakfast value. Their bacon, pork sausage and chorizo are great. They used to have a great chorizo hash, but they changed it a couple months ago and now it's mediocre.
Daren BrownJune 7, 2015
Good food and huge menu chicken wrap in had was slamming and the mai tai soo good...however a few like fruit flies were annoying us...nothing to complain about but watch your food
AceAugust 29, 2010
Been here 10+ times
One of the best diners I've been to. Great NYC-centric diner with decor to boot. Try the Carolina omelette. BBQ BEEF BRISKFT, onions, and cheddar! Say hi to batgirl while you're here too.
Fami MolinaOctober 11, 2014
Everything I've ordered here has been uh-mazing! Best diner ever!
Janice RosenthalApril 3, 2015
While living in The Hyatt Place across the road I frequent Gotham City Diner often. Tomight was to take out some gelato.
Robin SalantDecember 5, 2015
Favorite soups are Onion (not French) & the Lobster Bisque - smooth broth with deep lobster flavor, not heavy.
jimJuly 27, 2022
I had the Reuben. Good was excellent. Nice place. Clean.
Amanda SchaeferNovember 11, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Good diner food and large menu, something for everyone
Hollie SickJuly 30, 2016
Great diner and the dessert is excellent. Try the red velvet cake
AmiyrahNovember 17, 2012
Had the lamb shank special. It was perfectly cooked and HUGE!
Don BrownFebruary 3, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Fabulous Cream of Turkey soup on Sunday & amazing Stuffed Peppers on Tuesday as the dinner special
Brian TaylorNovember 10, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Try my personally made-up burger...extra American cheese with sautéed peppers and onions. Yummo!!
Myrrah GreyMay 2, 2013
I love their salad choices or make your own salad. Good service.
Lenny GalloJanuary 22, 2024
While the service was good, the food was just plane awful. One of the driest chicken sandwiches I’ve ever had.
Kelsey CDecember 22, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Every time I come to this diner I ask for medium rare. This time I asked for rate. This is what constitutes "rare."
Alexis TaiJune 3, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Try the electric lemonade.. It is divine
Denise D.April 1, 2019
Went there for dessert on a late Saturday night. The service was good but the dessert was not a fave. Other entrees smelled more appetizing
Seth HammermanDecember 21, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Can't beat the Breakfast Specials! Just get here before 11am
Mor YonaJuly 10, 2012
Waldorf Chicken Wrap- no tomato and balsamic vinaigrette dressing with sweet potato fries!!
NK PatelFebruary 17, 2013
Carolina dry rub wings taste like they were sprinkled with Lays Barbecue chips. Amazing.
Vee C.February 23, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Can't beat the $4 weekday breakfast deal here. Huge plate of food served by Chris- she's the best!
John N.February 23, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Great food for the price & great service also.
Terri MedinaJune 18, 2016
Cheese fries
Tom SauerMarch 27, 2017
Nacho Fries.
Josephine P.November 16, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Try the Gotham Express...messy but super felish!
Fern DickeyAugust 18, 2010
Really cute venue - very NYC - lots of subway signs and photos. And I agree, Amanda, great Red Velvet Cupcakes!
OwlMay 26, 2018
The food is good. Waitress are nice.
KaitAugust 13, 2014
Carolina Omelette is amazing!!
George GatewoodJanuary 30, 2011
Been here 25+ times
view menu on Gotham's website and order for pickup, or take them up on their free delivery offer
Rocco G. NazzaroJuly 8, 2022
Been here 10+ times
Their salads are huge!!
Neal SchafferJune 29, 2013
This place is the bomb!!!
Nick RinaldiJune 6, 2011
Been here 100+ times
The pueblo chicken sandwhich is no longer on the menu but you can still order it if you ask.
Michaela CovinoApril 11, 2013
The potato skins are delicious!!
jmeMarch 15, 2014
Been here 5+ times
BBQ chicken Cobb salad - amazeballs!!
Mark LouieJune 19, 2011
The place mats are reversed to a blank plain side with the other side saying "Season's Greetings."
Jacqueline OlsonApril 30, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Flatbread margherita is actually personal pizza, not a wrap.
Duane Snyder, ODNovember 29, 2014
Waitress was great. Good atmosphere. Disappointing food.
Stacy BarrettJanuary 13, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Best diner in Bergen county!!
Deleted DeletedSeptember 26, 2011
Been here 10+ times
One of the best diners in Bergen County!
Jason FeinmanSeptember 8, 2012
Best brown gravy and fries.
Evelyn morrisApril 12, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Rosie's Favorite! Do it.
Lynn GiguereApril 12, 2017
Good food!
Chris SoongMarch 30, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Try the special sandwichs they r the bomb
Debra ParmaAugust 31, 2018
I don’t think I’ve ever experienced this level of atrocious service. Maybe consider talking about your customers where they can’t hear you?
Daniel FalzoneJuly 9, 2012
Cleanest diner I've ever been to.
Michaela CovinoMarch 16, 2013
Best diner EVER!!
Steven DausterMay 27, 2012
Better than every other dinner in fair lawn

1 2

147 Photos

Gotham City Diner - Fair Lawn

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Gotham City Diner - Fair Lawn

Appears on 32 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.