Horse & Plow
Hotel Bar and American Restaurant$$$$
Kohler
"Great choice of Wisconsin craft beers on tap."(6 Tips)
"Best cheese curds I've had in Wisconsin!"(7 Tips)
"Try the beer & cheese soup (sans bacon if you're like me)."(6 Tips)
"Delightful pub and eatery at the fabulous American Club Resort."(2 Tips)
47 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- wisconsin
- cheese curds
- cheese soup
- american club resort
- sandwiches
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Eric AndersenJune 23, 2017The Beer & Cheese soup is the quintessential Wisconsin starter — and it's absolutely delicious!
The Curds are always excellent but my new favorite is the Bacon Buffalo Bites (aka Rib Tips or Pork Belly with BBQ and Buffalo sauce). You can go wrong with either or both as a gentleman would!
Julie KubschDecember 31, 2013Fun place if staying at resort. Lots more going on here than in Wisconsin Room or bar in library outside of Wisconsin Room. Try the 3 Sheeps beer brewed in Sheboygan!
- Pamela CarpenterOctober 28, 2014Try the beer & cheese soup (sans bacon if you're like me). And an order of the cheese curds.
Olle CarlbarkApril 10, 2018The staff, the beer, the food, the atmosphere yes a very good place to relax and be part of the family as foreigner!
getmejeff Jeff ArenaAugust 28, 2013Casual, open late, a little loud...and with a menu full of classics like a fantastic club sandwich. This is laid back but well done.
Sam WilsonOctober 30, 2013Highlights: chicken nachos and beer cheese soup. Two of the best reasons I can think of to come back as soon as possible!
Domenica SchiroApril 9, 2012It's a delightful place hidden inside the Forbes Five-start & AAA Five Diamond American Club Resort. Good wines selection. $$$
Get the cheese curds! Lightly battered, enormous creamy curds, absolutely delicious.- Best cheese curds I've had in Wisconsin! A must order.
LornaDecember 27, 2011The 30-minute business lunch is massive. No need for appetizers. Wasn't crazy about the grilled cheese but the salad was top notch!
Domenica SchiroOctober 3, 2011Delightful pub and eatery at the fabulous American Club Resort. Happy hour is a goodie.
Ashley MNovember 8, 2014Small menu. The service is great. For a picky person doesn't offer very much. And it's very small portions. Unless it comes to a burger.
- Domenica SchiroApril 15, 2013Food: good, nearly back to high standards. Redesign? Harder for servers to move; the rear booths:reflective. Barroom lights too bright. Fixtures block TV's from tables.Decor where BIG TV was? Boring.
114 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Horse & Plow
419 Highland Dr (btw Greenfield & Lower Falls)
Kohler, WI 53044
United States
Kohler, WI 53044
United States
Casual pub fare with amazing selection of micro-brews and premium beers. Located inside The American Club.
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(920) 457-8000
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
Other places inside The American Club Resort
- 8.0
"Great coffee with a beautiful room to enjoy it!"
Lili Liaskas - 7.2
"Most pleasant surroundings coupled with conscientious personnel, food presentation par excellence. Our rack of lamb was perfect, done as ordered as well as requested changes to the menu.👌"
Dave & Barbara Reinbold - 7.6
"If it's not too busy in the restaurant, ask if you can order off the full dinner menu at the bar. Usually this is not allowed. The scallops and the cheeses are amazing."
Prashant 🚀 Agarwal
You might also like
Places people like to go after Horse & Plow
Appears on 15 lists
Created by Caroline Zager
20 items • 1 follower
Created by Holly Klover
26 items • 1 followerTop 10 dinner spots in Sheboygan, WI
Created by Domenica Schiro
11 items • 3 followers