Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Legit Mexican Food in New York
Tacombi at Fonda Nolita is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

1. Tacombi at Fonda Nolita

9.0
267 Elizabeth St (btwn E Houston & Prince St), New York, NY
Taco Restaurant · NoLita · 738 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: A "combi" is a Volkswagen Type 2 bus: made in Puebla and ubiquitous in Mexico until the mid-90s. I rode the back of a combi to pre-school every day; now you can watch your tacos made inside one.

La Lucha - Tacos & Boutique is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

2. La Lucha - Tacos & Boutique

147 Avenue A (9th & 10th Street), New York, NY
Taco Restaurant · East Village · 32 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: Excellent taco place decorated with kitschy "lucha libre" memorabilia. Ask to have some of the spicy tamarind candies on display.

Tortilleria Nixtamal is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

3. Tortilleria Nixtamal

104-05 47th Ave, Corona, NY
Taco Restaurant · 147 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: Worth the trip to Queens. Get the tamales while you're there, and bring back some tortillas so you can remember this place long after you've left.

Café Habana is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

4. Café Habana

8.9
17 Prince St (at Elizabeth St), New York, NY
Cuban Restaurant · NoLita · 625 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: Fooled by the name, many people wrongly believe this is a Cuban restaurant. Astute readers of the menu know that only Mexicans call a sandwich a "torta". Get the signature torta cubana and a cocktail.

Oaxaca Taqueria is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

5. Oaxaca Taqueria

125 E 7th St (btwn 1st Ave. & Ave. A), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · East Village · 48 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: Tucked away at the end of the tiny alley of Extra Place, this cute little taco place won't last long with the amount of foot traffic it gets. Get a steak or shrimp quesadilla; skip the sour cream.

La Esquina is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

6. La Esquina

8.6
114 Kenmare St (at Lafayette St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · SoHo · 723 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: Excellent, greasy, late-night food. Get a quesadilla de huitlacoche. It sounds and looks dirty, but I promise its delicious. Scarf it down before you ask Google what the hell you just ate.

Puebla Mexican Food and Coffee Shop is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

7. Puebla Mexican Food and Coffee Shop

47 1st Ave (at 3rd St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · East Village · 37 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: Get an agua fresca. Sandía (watermelon) is a good flavor.

Jalepeno Deli is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

8. Jalepeno Deli

1629 Lexington Ave (102nd St), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · East Harlem · 3 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: For a great Sunday brunch, hop on the 6th and get off at 103rd St. Get the tacos de barbacoa and an agua fresca de melón. If you have company, split a guacamole (comes w/avocado seed and fresh chips!)

Crema Restaurante is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

9. Crema Restaurante

111 W 17th St (btwn. 6th Ave. & 7th Ave.), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · Chelsea · 96 tips and reviews
La Palapa is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

10. La Palapa

7.2
77 Saint Marks Pl (at 1st Ave.), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · East Village · 136 tips and reviews

Jorge O.Jorge Ortiz: A "palapa" is an open-air, thatched-roof structure; they're useful common spaces on hot, sunny days. Get the jicama with lime and chile, a popular and refreshing treat for just such days.

Zaragoza Mexican Deli-Grocery is one of Legit Mexican Food in New York.

11. Zaragoza Mexican Deli-Grocery

8.2
215 Avenue A (btwn 13th & 14th), New York, NY
Mexican Restaurant · East Village · 106 tips and reviews