- Ranked #3 for American restaurants in Williamsburg
- peanut soup
- game pye
- norfolk pottage pye
- dish of beef
- desserts
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- ChrystieOctober 29, 2014Authentic traditional colonial food and entertainment. Go for 3 course meal, portions are moderate. Peanut soup is delish. Beef tenderloin perfectly cooked. Make reservations. Worth the experience.
- MaryJanuary 2, 2014We dined at their special holiday breakfast. The food was delicious. I had the Eggs Benedict and although one egg was soft boiled instead of poached, it was still delish!!
- Melissa MassengillMay 4, 2013This place was delish!! We shared a cheesemonger & everyone got something different. My parents sandwiches looked really good, but my Norfolk Pottage Pye was the best!! Service was outstanding too!!
- Lawrence CalablasterApril 2, 2017The prices have gone up over my years of visits, but the food is still nice for a tourist trap. I had the chicken pot pie as a young boy on my first trip & I've remembered it fondly ever since.
- Avery ChipkaJuly 31, 2015If your eating here for lunch skip the adult menu and order from the kids menu. The prices are more reasonable, and the servings are larger!
- Benno KaiserMay 23, 2013Larry the waiter is the best! try the peanut soup, really good! and Mr. Purdy's home brew is really good!!!
- Andrew HogueAugust 19, 2013For dessert, don't sleep on the Syllabub. Wine-laced frothed cream, garnished with lemon. Delicious.
- Alejandro Rodriguez MannJanuary 2, 2013The peanut soup was really good! I ordered the game pye and enjoyed it but i would have preffered the meat my mother had!
- Billy OttoAugust 23, 2013Get the Peanut soup, the dish of beef, and the peppermint ice cream with chocolate sauce and a couple of pints of old stitch.
- Dana DisboroughNovember 12, 2012Mrs. Votes full course meal is excellent! Each portion was sooooo good -- the peanut soup through the peppermint ice cream!
- Shawn AlthouseOctober 15, 2013The cheese plate is overpriced and served cold. The game pie is tasty get the brown nut ale to go with it.
- Roy BlancoAugust 11, 2011The lunch menu has the BEST fried chicken. Love it with a nice mug of nut brown ale.
- Erik GibertiAugust 1, 2011You'll get a history lesson while your here - definitely worth it. The real tip is to order desert first.
- Mikael MerrittAugust 4, 2018Not a place you will want to take toddlers or kids 5 and under because menu isn’t tailored for them.
- Hector GuerreroDecember 14, 2013Overrated. They won't take you for dinner if you're a walk-in. They only accept reservations.