Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Magic Fountain Ice Cream
Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
Mattituck
"Great little shop that isn't too far out on the North Fork."(2 Tips)
"rocky road, oreo and honey cinnamon are must haves."(2 Tips)
"You have to try a cone of the rainbow cookie."(2 Tips)
"S'mores and salted caramel ice cream are great picks"(2 Tips)
48 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- ice cream
- north fork
- honey cinnamon
- family-friendly
- cookies
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jocelyn LeavittOctober 14, 2013Amazing weekly special flavors. This week: fig and honey, sweet corn and coconut avocado.
Ali is one of the sweetest people- to match his icecream, the favours here are amazing! exotic seasonals like peppermint, eggnog, kulfi, cocoachili guiness, and more, Im a local and I love it!
Brandon F.October 18, 2019Friendly staff and delicious ice cream. Whenever I come back into the area, I’ll definitely be visiting again.
Ron GoldinSeptember 22, 2012Probably one of the best ice cream places I've ever been to. Caramel Apple and Kulfi are the prize.
Jonas BlankJune 19, 2017Blackberry is great. Everything is great. Awesome ice cream, ice cream cakes, service.
Best ice cream! Always new flavors and big scoops! Birthday cake is a fav- Courtney ThompsonNovember 4, 2012Great little shop that isn't too far out on the North Fork. Big variety of ice cream -- try the pumpkin
- Ashley RoseAugust 11, 2015DELICIOUSLY scooped ice cream. You have to try a cone of the rainbow cookie.
Christina TAugust 25, 2019Ice cream is delicious... when it’s not crawling in cockroaches. On 2 separate occasions I got greeted by a roach when grabbing a spoon and napkin. They can work on overall establishment cleanliness- David AmbroseFebruary 18, 2019rocky road, oreo and honey cinnamon are must haves. super creamy and full of flavor.
Michael G.May 19, 2021Delicious ice cream! And a lot of fun flavors. The goat cheese tastes like cheesecake
Elysia MannJune 23, 2016Good mix of classic and interesting flavors. Kids working here are very patient with samples....
Lucy CeeSeptember 24, 2014Very good. Only problem...the "no sugar added" is also fat free. Ih well. Still delicious.
Maria K.September 4, 2011If it's your first time, you have to try the soft serve. It's much better than Carvel.
Derek SpencerSeptember 27, 2012The malt mania ice cream was a let down and I forgot that waffles cones are gluten intensive so double fail. Most of the stuff they make us delicious though.
Caitlin LentzJanuary 31, 2012Try having one scoop of red velvet and one of chocolate chili! So good together!
TomMarch 19, 2010Amazing seasonal ice cream flavors. Just after St. Pstty's day and there is Guinness, Irish Cream, Kulfi, mud pie, and many more.
Alexis TiradoNovember 4, 2011You haven't lived life unless you tried the Cookie Monster flavor. End of story.
109 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Family owned and operated, Magic Fountain specializes in delicious homemade ice cream made fresh from local ingredients.
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(631) 298-4908
Features
Outdoor Seating
Yes
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Magic Fountain Ice Cream
- 8.1
"There are a lot of stores between all three sections. You could find just about anything. Everything from clothing and jewelry to cookware and office supplies. You need to shop here at least once."
Michele Dowling - 9.3
"Pies are fantastic! If there's a line, don't worry because it moves fast"
Cynthia Lin - 7.7
"Beautiful for a sunset walk along the inlet."
Dan Spinosa
Appears on 79 lists
Created by Yucca Frita
16 items • 2 followers
A Weekend Away in North Fork, Long Island
Created by Foursquare City Guide
19 items • 164 followers