Mr B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse
Steakhouse$$$$
Brookfield
"Great brisk and steak Chef Chris and Brent great meal!"(2 Tips)
"The seafood bisque is also very good."(4 Tips)
"Lastly try the triple chocolate desert"(2 Tips)
"Rosemary potatoes are amazing"(2 Tips)
21 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- steak
- brent
- good for dates
- good service
- great value
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Dave McJuly 9, 2018It’s not on the menu, but the Filet Oscar is the absolute best steak on the planet, even better than Morton’s. Pair it with a Spinach salad with hot bacon dressing!
mark cobbApril 8, 2017Food always amazing, well except this time. Both wife and I had the dry aged bone in fillet. Cooked perfect and tasted great. So the problem? Very very chewy! But first time this has happened.
Steaks are phenomenal. They cost more because they're honestly worth more. For a more affordable but terrific night out, do the happy hour at the bar - great camaraderie in addition to great food.
Michelle StevensFebruary 24, 2021Everything here is delicious! My husband and I have been coming here for date night for as long as I can remember. Nothing but 5 star food and service!
Tap MilwaukeeJune 17, 2013The filet from chef Brent Perszyk's kitchen is classic, a very good balm for a red-meat craving. Nicely done potato purée and sautéed mixed mushrooms on the side, and you're set.- Brendan FarrellAugust 19, 2016Excellent steaks. The seafood bisque is also very good. Nice (if small) wine list - average priced.
ThomasMarch 30, 2013This is the beat steakhouse on milwaukee. Try the buffalo - just outstanding and Tim and bill are some of the best bartenders in town. Lastly try the triple chocolate desert- ThomasFebruary 16, 2013Don't know who the new manager is but he is awesome. Not to mention that the food is great too. The best steakhouse in MKE for the $
Alex LemanskiJune 10, 2012Buffalo steak with the brandy peppercorn sauce was fantastic. They also have I nice selection of scotch and bourbon.
The Mr. B's Filet is absolutly amazing! Around the holiday season you get a $20 rewards coupon if you buy a $100 gift card great deal for a great place!
Christine PlatzerJuly 10, 2013Good but disappointing. Steak over done. Nothing really impressive other then my red wine. Oysters Rockefeller was good. But in the end money not well spent. Worth the one time visit, won't be back.
Kaitlin HoinesJuly 12, 2012Order steak at least one temp lower than you would like. Table of 6 and all of us felt our fillets were overcooked.
Svetlana ZaharovaAugust 6, 2010the restaurant charges for each soda refills. Do not think that refills are free. I did not have stake but the clalmary, chicken and asian salad were just OK, not outstanding. Service is very nice.
New location. More convinent bathrooms, larger space, outdoor patio, larger bar area
48 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Mr. B’s features prime steaks grilled in a wood-burning oven, fresh seafood, Italian inspired appetizers like bruschetta and calamari, and salads and sandwiches. In 2013, The Daily Meal named Mr. B’s one of America’s Top 20 steakhouses.
Closed until 5:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 5:30 PM–9:00 PM
- Fri
- 5:30 PM–10:00 PM
- Sat
- 5:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Sun
- 5:00 PM–8:00 PM
(262) 790-7005
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.8
"Superb filet mignon. Try the ancho chili shrimp starter."
Victor Bauer - 7.6
"The food was really good. Had the baked cod and ahi tuna sandwich. Soups were a decent size. Service was fast and friendly."
Edgar - 9.1
"Had the stuffed pork chop with Brussel sprout (shredded!). It was excellent, as was the brownie for dessert."
Matt Terski
Places people like to go after Mr B's - A Bartolotta Steakhouse
- 9.3
"Get the pint. It's such a better deal. Also german apple streusel is delish!"
Alice Zhao - 8.4
"The Big Screen Bistro is awesome! It's great to enjoy a good movie while being served dinner. The food, drinks & service were really good."
Kathryn Hall - 7.2
"The bacon mac and cheese is TO DIE FOR. Add pork belly for extra yummy-ness"
Lauren Jensen
Appears on 27 lists
Created by MyCommunityNOW
9 items • 4 followers
Must Visit Local Milwaukee Establishments
Created by David
20 items • 6 followersCreated by Tim Sparks
6 items • 3 followers