Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI
Stresa is one of Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI.

1. Stresa

7.6
1524 Northern Blvd (Shelter Rock Road), Manhasset, NY
Italian Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: This place is filled with flavor-packed specialties. Superior pastas: bigoli with cabbage, pancetta and tomatoes; bucatini alla Norma; and ravioli. Don't forget to try the delicious desserts!

18 Bay is one of Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI.

2. 18 Bay

7.8
23 North Ferry Rd., Shelter Island, NY
American Restaurant · 10 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Chef-owners change their fixed-price menu each week, but the quality remains consistent and delicious.

Casa Rustica is one of Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI.

3. Casa Rustica

7.4
175 W Main St, Smithtown, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Dishes shine here with regional Italian flavor. The cold antipasti is recommended, and the home-made cannolis are a must-have!

The Trattoria is one of Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI.

4. The Trattoria

8.5
532 Route 25A, Saint James, NY
Italian Restaurant · 9 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: The menu here changes frequently. You may be here for spaghetti all'Amatriciana and butternut squash ravioli or the herb-crusted hake with fregola and escarole. The tiramisu is recommended!

Nick & Toni's is one of Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI.

5. Nick & Toni's

8.2
136 N Main St, East Hampton, NY
Italian Restaurant · 57 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Highly recommended: ricotta gnocchi with Gorgonzola, toasted pine nuts and poppy seeds, wood-oven-roasted striped bass or the spice-rubbed hanger steak, and for dessert: the chocolate honey cake.

Ristorante Da Claudio is one of Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI.

6. Ristorante Da Claudio

7.1
51 Cedar Swamp Rd, Glen Cove, NY
Italian Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: A grand dining experience. Recommendations include: gnocchi in filetto di pomodoro sauce, lobster ravioli in pink sauce, whole branzino with roasted garlic and asparagus, dark chocolate mousse.

Trattoria Diane is one of Favorite Italian Restaurants on LI.

7. Trattoria Diane

7.3
21 Bryant Ave, Roslyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · 8 tips and reviews

NewsdayNewsday: Authentic Italian dishes include: spaghetti alla carbonara, fried artichokes and nearly candied Brussels sprouts, pan-seared pork chops, and lastly, vanilla ice cream doused with the three-berry pie.