Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
18 Bay

18 Bay

American Restaurant$$$$
Shelter Island
Save
Share
18 Bay
7.8/10
32
ratings
  • Stars
    Ranked #3 for American restaurants in Shelter Island
  • Tips
    Stefanie D.
    "Unique concept for the East End that makes sense."(2 Tips)
    Yasmin K.
    "Great tasting menu."(2 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon10 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • tasting menu
  • lamb meatballs
  • grilled lamb
  • desserts
  • music
  • (4 more)
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • David V.
    David VonOehsenAugust 28, 2014
    Everything is great here. This is a place you can come, eat and enjoy. When you leave you feel good. Best deal around. $65.00 prefix. You choose fish or meat. I could eat here every day. So fresh.
  • Stefanie D.
    Stefanie DAugust 23, 2013
    Unique concept for the East End that makes sense. Menu changes weekly, highlighting the season's best ingredients. Space is inviting, service is friendly & easy. Music: fantastic. Food is phenomenal.
  • Explore L.
    Explore Long IslandFebruary 12, 2013
    We visited 18 Bay and enjoyed the antipasti with bluefish crudo paired with celtuce, or celery lettuce, and grilled lamb meatballs. Read more
  • MLMA O.
    MLMA OlleromaApril 6, 2012
    Amazing localized food. Very creative and great tasting. Menu changes daily. A welcome addition to east end cuisine.
  • Newsday
    NewsdayJuly 26, 2013
    Chef-owners change their fixed-price menu each week, but the quality remains consistent and delicious.
  • Robin B.heart icon on user image
    Robin BrianMay 30, 2014
    The meal was excellent , service was good, the dessert was just ok, but lovely overall
  • Danie B.
    Danie BJuly 3, 2013
    Vegetarian and vegan tasting menus upon request.
  • Yasmin K.
    Yasmin KhakooAugust 31, 2013
    Been here 10+ times
    Great tasting menu. Very attentive service
  • Chris
    ChrisMay 14, 2012
    Amazing 5 course menu and great service!
  • Jennifer F.
    Jennifer FriedbergMay 17, 2013
    Everything is extraordinary at 18 Bay.
Photos22 Photos
Compass icon
18 Bay
23 North Ferry Rd.
Shelter Island, NY 11964
United States
Get directions
Information icon
We serve a four course Italian inspired Chefs menu - four different antipasti, followed by a handmade pasta, a choice of entree and dessert - all direct reflection of the local markets. The menu changes weekly. We offer a vegetarian menu and accommodate for any allergies or aversions.
Clock icon
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
  • Mon, Wed–Sun
    • 5:30 PM–10:00 PM
Phone icon
(631) 749-0053
World Wide Web icon
Twitter icon
@18bay
Open Table icon
Make Reservation
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Dining Options
Table Service
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner, Dessert, Tasting Menu
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after 18 Bay

Appears on 24 lists

See all
United States » New York » Suffolk County » Shelter Island »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.