See all
117 photos

New York Prime Steakhouse

Steakhouse$$$$

North Buckhead, Atlanta

Save

8.5^/10

ratings

Ranked #10 for steakhouses in Atlanta
"Great steak and service."(2 Tips)
"Stone crabs are in season and they are amazing."(2 Tips)
"special events like cigar and scotch dinners"(4 Tips)
"I loved the live music and food of course!"(2 Tips)

31 Tips and reviews

Filter:

steak
cigars
live music
great value
chocolate chip cookies
mashed potatoes
bar
corn
dinner
staff
porterhouse
carpaccio
singers
blue cheese
events
parking
town
takes reservations
(13 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

AJCFebruary 11, 2015
Everything seems to live larger than life at this Buckhead staple. Make sure to try their massive onion rings to complement your meal. Read more
Seth ShadburnAugust 5, 2011
Not only are the steaks and sides amazing, but the Sea Bass is the BEST piece of fish I have EVER tasted! Definitely worth the price and I cannot wait to go back! This place is my slice of heaven on
Upvoted Nov 3, 2024
AustinDecember 11, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Great setting, Pittsburgh style steak - WTF - is that a thing? Regardless, it's very good. However, not close to Rathbun. The setting, bar staff, and cigar smoking is what makes this place fun.
eileen ungerJanuary 7, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Order anything on the menu - it's worth it. And the extensive wine list makes it that much better. Keep an eye open for special events like cigar and scotch dinners, wine dinners, etc.
Lindsay WilliamsJuly 3, 2016
Great service and delicious steaks. Eat, drink, smoke and enjoy yourself.
Noelle Folmnsbee-CarltonFebruary 13, 2011
The steak specials before 6:30 during the week are crazy. I was just there and had a great NY strip for $15.00!!! The wine list is fab as well - I will go back!
Angel Flight SoarsJune 11, 2012
Everything is mouthwatering delicious ... the filet, stone crab claws, cheesy mashed potatoes ... and that CORN ... it tastes like heaven
Prince KashmereDecember 12, 2011
Oh I just love this place everything is simply amazing the singer the food everything hard to find but so worth it
ChuckJune 26, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Great bartenders- service and good. It is a cigar bar so can be smokey- live music
Cliff SinonOctober 17, 2023
Been here 10+ times
Order garlic chicken blackened with fettuccine alfredo. Sleeper on the menu..
Ahmed AL-MeharishDecember 29, 2018
Best fillet steak I ever ate in my life 😍
Melody DavisMarch 25, 2012
The absolute BEST chocolate chip cookie. I've had better cheesecake, but the chocolate chip cookie....... amazing.
George OgorekJanuary 27, 2012
Stone crabs are in season and they are amazing. Try the carpaccio, delicious.
Don MillerOctober 14, 2013
Great Steak and service.
George OgorekJanuary 19, 2012
What a great steak! I love this place the food, service, and bartenders rock!
Carley PierceDecember 15, 2009
If you are using Mapquest or your GPS to find NYP Atlanta, be careful. The restaurant has a Peachtree At. address but the entrance is actually off of Lenox Road right across from the AMC at Phipps Pl
George OgorekJanuary 20, 2012
Get the porterhouse for 2. Perfectly cooked and out of this world.
Christian SmithApril 6, 2016
I loved the live music and food of course!
UpShift DigitalMay 2, 2013
Very smokey - don't come if you don't like a smokey dark bar. Food is great though.
Caroljean IrwinFebruary 9, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Fun night with Meghan!
Lindsay WilliamsJuly 3, 2016
Steak, cigars , drinks.
tinaJuly 18, 2013
Great steak and service.
Jon JewellNovember 13, 2012
Great FREE dinner at NY Prime tonight for Veterans!!
Nikki GroteMay 27, 2011
Get the Tito's Martini, Straight Up w/ Blue Cheese Olives. Is it hot in here now or is it just me??
TracyApril 29, 2013
ACVB'S CENTENNIAL COCKTAIL: Woodford and Mint
Greg GreenbaumFebruary 23, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Unbelievably great meal. Manuel singing made it even better
Dani CJuly 9, 2013
Fabulous service!!
Zoubir MesbahiMarch 8, 2012
Hottest bar in town.
Matt ColemanNovember 10, 2011
The singer knocks Lou Tasks out of the park.
amber stewartMarch 2, 2012
Great bar!!!!
Arturo MilanOctober 27, 2022
El Tomahawk buenísimo

117 Photos

Planning a trip to Atlanta?

Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.

New York Prime Steakhouse

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after New York Prime Steakhouse

Appears on 35 lists

Top places in the area