See all
23 photos

Nightingale Supper Club

American Restaurant and Cocktail Bar$$$$

Sturgeon Bay

Save

8.3^/10

ratings

Ranked #2 for American restaurants in Sturgeon Bay
"Best prime rib around!! Also get a frozen alcoholic grasshopper!!"(7 Tips)
"Mondays is lobster night and 8 ounces of superb tail is delicious!"(2 Tips)
"Absolutely amazing asparagus and lobster soup!! Yummmm!"(2 Tips)
"Excellent food & service - reservations suggested!"(2 Tips)

18 Tips and reviews

Filter:

prime rib
garlic mashed potatoes
surf & turf
good for dates
loaded potatoes
asparagus
soup
takes reservations
cocktails
dinner
good for special occasions
parking
(7 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Dave & Barbara ReinboldSeptember 25, 2019
Mondays is lobster night and 8 ounces of superb tail is delicious! Asparagus with crab soup is over the top excellent, surf and turf great choice, cocktails perfect👌We’ll be back!
Kyle KubichekAugust 6, 2017
Absolutely amazing! Call ahead to make a reservation because they are busy but worth the wait! Tenderloin and shrimp combo with garlic mashed.... out of this world!
Jim BaileyMay 19, 2021
Yup the prime rib was amazing. Great local Super Club, a must try.
Luke CJuly 2, 2013
Been here 5+ times
A local favorite. Monday night is lobster night and it's outstanding.
Tammy RaymondSeptember 8, 2017
Did is very good, service is great, and cocktails are the bomb.
Cathie MartyMarch 20, 2015
Excellent food & service - reservations suggested!
Rebecca Battista-SullivanSeptember 1, 2013
Absolutely amazing asparagus and lobster soup!! Yummmm!
Nathan NowackMay 10, 2012
Best prime rib around!! Also get a frozen alcoholic grasshopper!!
Mike BlackleyJanuary 19, 2015
This is my favorite local place for Prime Rib!
Dan ReynardDecember 19, 2012
Awsome prime rib, wish I got up here a little more often.
JamesNovember 2, 2013
Prime rib is awesome!!
Jeremy EvensenApril 20, 2021
Prime rib!
Jackie Pavlat SnowSeptember 27, 2013
Amazing!!!!!
Nathan NowackMay 10, 2012
Best prime
Larry KedzieSeptember 4, 2011
Great prime rib
Patrick NormoyleSeptember 6, 2015
Told wait was an hour..ended up being two. Couldn't order appetizers while waiting for table. Service slow. Tenderloin Oscar sauce was too salty. Food was too expensive
Jamie SchillingAugust 19, 2012
One of the worst experiences I have ever had. Especially at a supper club.
Manda SoykAugust 19, 2012
BAD service. Lengthy. Sent a steak back TWICE; still not good.

23 Photos

Nightingale Supper Club

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Nightingale Supper Club

Appears on 6 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.